• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Mel Gibson Being Cancelled (Again) This Time Over Comments Made in 1995 (25 Years Ago)

Grinchy

Banned
Let's just pretend it's true - who the fuck cares? This is like the Beavis and Butthead thread that was made here with the OP being surprised by the 90s humor.

Making edgy jokes in the 90s was extremely common. Calling a Jewish person an "oven dodger" was no different from calling your friend who won't get on the roller coaster a "faggot." It sounds harsh to today's pearl-clutchers, but those were much better times. Race relations were way better back then as well.
 
Last edited:

Bolivar687

Banned
those Mel Gibson tapes... What? WAHT!?

They're doctored.

edit: I wrote a dumb thing. I dislike how people still want to hold Mel's feet to the fire instead of forgiving him, but that doesn't excuse the horrible, hurtful, and idiotic things he has said on tape in the past.
 
Last edited:

GamingKaiju

Member
Like Mel Gibson gives a fuck. He burnt many bridges and still went onto to put out highly rated media. Passion of Christ, apocalito etc
 

Skyfox

Member
Winona damaging women's reputation 25 years into the future with this shit.

Youd swear he murdered someone the way this crap gets blown up. 25 years from now someone will have used a curse word and get fucking fired.

Nah. I've had it with this nazi surveillance ratting shit.

Fuck you Winona.
 

mortal

Banned
Mel Gibson should make a buddy cop movie with James Woods.
Which reminds me, Dragged Across Concrete was a pretty good watch. Not exactly buddy cop though.

giphy.gif

ImmenseQuerulousBorzoi-size_restricted.gif

giphy.gif
 

cryptoadam

Banned
I laughed.

He hates Jews, but at least he makes a good joke when being anti semetic.

Anyways not sure why they are trying to nail him for the Jew thing, thats passe. They need to catch him hitting on a girl or tying his shoe laces in a loop (noose) if they want him cancelled.
 

Jesus Carbomb

From Water into Guinness
Mel may be a piece of shit but at least he isn’t a thief. Fuck you, Winona, you thieving cunt. Imma still watch Stranger Things tho.
 

lachesis

Member
Always wondered when Mel Gibson would be cancelled yet again. lol..

I'd like to see Mel Gibson playing Joel in upcoming "The Last of Us" HBO series.... although he's little too old, and Druckman would flip out like crazy... (and that maybe what I'd like to see too, like an added bonus)
 

MrRogers

Member
:messenger_grinning_sweat: . The sjws have no power here, what Mel stated in the op is basically sunday morning brunch talk compared to his history of remarks. He is immuned to cancelling.
 

O-N-E

Member
They had to go back a quarter of a fucking century? LMAO

I'm sorry, but 'oven dodger' is kind of hilarious. It was just a joke, if a Jewish person said this, no one would give a shit.
It's the same thing with black people saying nigga.

It's fine to enjoy his movies and whatnot, but to pretend that "oven dodger" is just an innocent joke is nonsense.

Whether he said it or not, Mel didn't make it up. It's not a joke. People say it seriously. It's been used as a phrase to try and kindle fear in Jews. Make them feel small and in danger. "That man would kill me if he could get away with it..."

If any of you said that to a Jew? Fuck you.
 

mortal

Banned
It's fine to enjoy his movies and whatnot, but to pretend that "oven dodger" is just an innocent joke is nonsense.

Whether he said it or not, Mel didn't make it up. It's not a joke. People say it seriously. It's been used as a phrase to try and kindle fear in Jews. Make them feel small and in danger. "That man would kill me if he could get away with it..."

If any of you said that to a Jew? Fuck you.
Holy shit relax lol

If that bothered you, I can't imagine what you'd think of black humor.

I thought it was funny. I also believe what actual Nazis did to Jews during WWII was heinous and evil. Crazy, I know...
 

O-N-E

Member
Holy shit relax lol

If that bothered you, I can't imagine what you'd think of black humor.

I thought it was funny. I also believe what actual Nazis did to Jews during WWII was heinous and evil. Crazy, I know...

I am relaxed. I’m telling you the truth about the intentions behind those words based on personal experience, accounts from others, and video evidence.

I’m very calm when I say “fuck you” to anyone who uses that phrase.
 

mortal

Banned
I am relaxed. I’m telling you the truth about the intentions behind those words based on personal experience, accounts from others, and video evidence.

I’m very calm when I say “fuck you” to anyone who uses that phrase.
I'm sure you're telling the truth, but you don't get to decide what's a joke or not. That's extremely arrogant
Intentions behind words absolutely matter, that is why you can't go around treating everyone finding humor in taboo subjects as some sort of anti-semite
 
Last edited:

O-N-E

Member
I'm sure you're telling the truth, but you don't get to decide what's a joke or not. That's extremely arrogant
Intentions behind words absolutely matter, that is why you can't go around treating everyone finding humor in taboo subjects as some sort of anti-semite

I’m talking about realities in the wild. Not comedy clubs.

Also, how the fuck can I get away with saying “noose dodger” or “plantation dodger” right in the face of a Black man? Are you thinking this through?
 

mortal

Banned
I’m talking about realities in the wild. Not comedy clubs.
What does that even mean? That's such a non-statement. No one is talking about "comedy clubs". Since when is humor exclusively reserved to comedy clubs?
Also, how the fuck can I get away with saying “noose dodger” or “plantation dodger” right in the face of a Black man? Are you thinking this through?
because CONTEXT MATTERS.

Are you thinking this through? lol

Do you realize how many jokes have been made in reference to black slavery, many of which are made by black people?
 
Last edited:

mortal

Banned
The context is not a Jew saying “oven dodger” to someone they barely know.
You aren't amused, and that's understandable. It's a good thing humor is subjective then.
That’s fine. Don’t pretend you’re not gonna get an ass-beating in the above context.
Wait why would I get an ass beating? How does making jokes deserves an ass beating? lol
That would only show how emotionally unstable the person being violent is. You're not one of those 'speech is violence' people, are you?
 

O-N-E

Member
You aren't amused, and that's understandable. It's a good thing humor is subjective then.

Wait why would I get an ass beating? How does making jokes deserves an ass beating? lol
That would only show how emotionally unstable the person being violent is. You're not one of those 'speech is violence' people, are you?


I’m not saying I’d personally react like that. Might light them up with words, though.

But it’s wishful thinking to approach a black man you barely know and say some provocative shit and not expect some physical pushback? I’m sure you’re aware of a certain series of notorious prank vids.
 
Last edited:

mortal

Banned
But it’s wishful thinking to approach a black man you barely know and say some provocative shit and not expect some physical pushback? I’m sure you’re aware of a certain series of notorious prank vids.
Why would you assume a black man would react violently though? What makes you think there wouldn't be any context for that joke?
What makes you assume that black man wouldn't have a sense of humor and the rationality to not take it personally or literally?

I never brought up pranks, so no I'm not aware of a certain series of prank vids.
 

O-N-E

Member
Why would you assume a black man would react violently though? What makes you think there wouldn't be any context for that joke?
What makes you assume that black man wouldn't have a sense of humor and the rationality to not take it personally or literally?

I never brought up pranks, so no I'm not aware of a certain series of prank vids.

I advise you to try it out for yourself. A learning experience.

Clearly you haven’t yet.

:messenger_tears_of_joy:
 

O-N-E

Member
Why aren't you answering my questions? lol

Video evidence and witnessing irl proves that such provocations are by and large not tolerated. You are likely to be knocked out depending on the physical capacity of the person you approached.

Disingenuous to pretend otherwise.

That’s why I lol’d. You’re ignoring reality.

There’s nothing more to say at that point. Move how you please.
 

mortal

Banned
Video evidence and witnessing irl proves that such provocations are by and large not tolerated. You are likely to be knocked out depending on the physical capacity of the person you approached.

Disingenuous to pretend otherwise.

That’s why I lol’d. You’re ignoring reality.

There’s nothing more to say at that point. Move how you please.
Video evidence lol. You make a lot of assumptions. Do you believe all black people think the same?
Also, you still haven't answered my questions.
 
Last edited:

O-N-E

Member
Video evidence lol. You make a lot of assumptions. Do you believe all black people think the same?
Also, you still haven't answered my questions.


I never made an absolute statement that all Black people will react the same, but if you have some fucking common sense, you’d know that by and large, again, they’re not tolerant of provocative behaviour towards their race and history.

We’re going in circles.

I feel like I’m being too nice explaining this in baby steps to you.

If you disagree then OK. You believe in a different reality.
 

O-N-E

Member
M mortal how about you answer some questions.

Have you ever called a black man the N word (it’s just a joke bro)?

Have you ever called a Jew an oven dodger?

Have you ever called a gay person “faggot”?

To their faces? How did that work out?

🧠
 
Top Bottom