Meteos: 1up.com review

S

sammy

Member
8.0

a review of the japanese import -

"Meteos is an interesting take on the puzzle genre and stands out enough to be worth a look. It may not be to everyone's liking -- it took quite a while to grow on me -- but stick with the game and explore its depths and you'll be pleasantly surprised by how entertaining it can be. Insanely fast, frequently clever and perfectly suited to the Nintendo DS, the game doesn't quite live up to the standard set by its PSP-based sibling Lumines. But so long as you don't mind getting your action in three-minutes bursts, Meteos is fun, unique and highly addictive. "
 
The game doesn't quite live up to the standard set by its PSP-based sibling Lumines.
Click to expand...

Attacks from people who have played neither, commence.... NOW!


CAVEAT: All from people who know who Koji Kondo is.
 
Too bad this didn't score higher than Lumines, I was hoping to get an even better experience from this. Regardless I will end up buying this since Q Entertainemnt really showed me they can make puzzle games.
 
Seems like a really great game. I don't have the patience to play a puzzle game for 3 hours per round, so I'd probably enjoy this more.
 
Do you think the DS will finally deliver a gem by way of an original IP developed specifically for the system, or do you think it will take yet another iteration of the classic standby's, ie. Mario, Zelda, etc.?
 
I'm sure I'll enjoy both for what they bring to the table (slow zen vs fast stress)



but if 1up.com gives Meteos an 8.0 that means it mus really be like a 15.infinity or an eleventeen.
 
For fucks sake, the game sounds great from all we've read. Even this.

Why are people intent on pitting good game against good game and making one the 'loser' so to speak? Fuck that noise. Don't give some of the people above the satisfaction.
 
I'm going on a trip for a couple days this afternoon.

Meteos is in my back pocket. I shall play it.... that is, if I can tear myself away from the thrilling card action that is the u.s. version of Metal Gear Acid. :rolleyes

And yes, Mizuguchi am cry.
 
Some people just feel the need to whip out thier brand loyality dicks to see whose is bigger and so forth. Best thing to do is ignore or mock them.
 
sammy said:
but if 1up.com gives Meteos an 8.0 that means it mus really be like a 15.infinity or an eleventeen.
Click to expand...

Does that mean Lumines is a EIGHTEENISTTWENTY?

Just kidding.

Meteos sounds fucking awesome. Can't wait to get my hands on it.
 
Bah, Meteos.. Lumines. They're no bowl of Special K.

(One site on the internet gave the game an 8.0 so this means I'd better sell my DS and buy a Power Rangers hand held game from Tiger Electronics)
 
lumines.gif

Hello Gaming-Age!
Buy my game at Amazon.com
 
heh I hope this thread backfires and that the obvious bitchfest between Lumines and Meteos dont happen as someone tried to start.
 
Meteos apparently has a serious gameplay flaw that might hurt it's review scores if reviewers take it against it. It's not something you can't avoid with some self-restraint, but if you want to exploit, it allows you to cheat very easily, and finish the whole game, just by quickly sliding the stylus down the screen couple times a second. Someone on Tokyopia basically finished the whole game just by doing this, only stopping couple of times to actually think what to do next.
 
...Jeremy Parish imported a copy and received it today (mine is due to arrive on Monday, I was not on the ball this time) but let me play it all afternoon. Amazingly, both Meteos and Q Entertainment's other puzzle game, Lumines, are both equally compelling plays. But something about Meteos just resonates with me. From the CG opening (yes, it's so cool, spaceships, all kinds of crap) to the send-the-falling-blocks-blasting-off-into-space-on-rocket-thrusters gameplay is in danger of having me in withdrawal systems until my own copy arrives. Luckily it's coming to the States but everything about this game is so cool. Even the menu bars slide around like air hockey pucks when you moosh them with the stylus. I predict that this will call my DS home for quite some time to come. I can hardly wait to kick Mr. Driller to the curb.
Click to expand...

http://milkman.1up.com/
 
i don't know why you'd want to do that gameplay trick :\

the more i play meteos, the more addicted i become :D i've moved off 'star trip' mode into the 'choose skin/speed/lives/gravity' mode - and its awesome. i played it for about 4 hours straight last night. the way the sound effects sync with the music is awesome (in the level i was playing, like a steel drum sound) and i haven't ever been tempted to use that 'move the pen up and down' move. i'd rate it higher, more around a 9. it's not perfect, but it's bloody good.

oh, and that quote above pretty much nails it, the 'rocket' mechanic has an addiction to it - nothing like having a rocket slowly drift down to the bottom, and while its falling you set up some more blocks to line up with it - it hits the bottom and BANG! takes off at full speed :D
 
I just read the Another Code review thread and thought "OK, yeah, that's an 8.0 and I can deal with the PSP comparison once", then I come into this thread and WTF!? Another PSP comparison and another 8.0. Fuck, it's a decent score, but it's lame that they keep comparing the machines. You don't see the Xbox mentioned in every PS2 review.
 
Jeremy already said on his blog that he was the only person in the ZD office who wasn't feeling Meteos. Claimed it was too hectic of a puzzle game for his tastes. But 8.0 is hardly a bad score, and he wasn't even blown away by it. I expect to see higher from others.
 
Jonnyram said:
I just read the Another Code review thread and thought "OK, yeah, that's an 8.0 and I can deal with the PSP comparison once", then I come into this thread and WTF!? Another PSP comparison and another 8.0. Fuck, it's a decent score, but it's lame that they keep comparing the machines. You don't see the Xbox mentioned in every PS2 review.
Click to expand...
Sorry, should I not have mentioned Lumines, a recently-released game designed by the same man... a game of the same genre as Meteos, which I was playing simultaneously for review alongside Meteos? I didn't realize that important contextual information would be so emotionally damaging to you.

I'll go back and add a random PSP comparison to the Touch & Go review if you ask really nicely.
 
IT'S A FUCKING EIGHT POINT OH, IT'S NOT LIKE JEREMY ANALLY RAPED YOUR MOM WHILE POURING SUGAR IN YOUR GAS TANK.

I bet some of you people are the same whiners who go bitch to the principal after you only get an A-minus in Gym.
 
ToastyFrog said:
Sorry, should I not have mentioned Lumines, a recently-released game designed by the same man...
Click to expand...
Mizuguchi designed neither Lumines nor Meteos. Meteos was created by Sakurai. And please do stick a PSP reference in the Touch & Go review for good measure. I love you, really :D
 
Sho Nuff said:
IT'S A FUCKING EIGHT POINT OH, IT'S NOT LIKE JEREMY ANALLY RAPED YOUR MOM WHILE POURING SUGAR IN YOUR GAS TANK.

I bet some of you people are the same whiners who go bitch to the principal after you only get an A-minus in Gym.
Click to expand...
Ya know, I only ever get Pass/Fail grades in gym. I never understood how someone could scale a letter grade to a PE class, but oh, well.
 
ToastyFrog said:
Sorry, should I not have mentioned Lumines, a recently-released game designed by the same man... a game of the same genre as Meteos, which I was playing simultaneously for review alongside Meteos? I didn't realize that important contextual information would be so emotionally damaging to you.

I'll go back and add a random PSP comparison to the Touch & Go review if you ask really nicely.
Click to expand...

Oh Toasty!
 
Jonnyram said:
Mizuguchi designed neither Lumines nor Meteos. Meteos was created by Sakurai. And please do stick a PSP reference in the Touch & Go review for good measure. I love you, really :D
Click to expand...
OK, OK, sorry -- designed was the wrong word (and in fact I avoided any overt reference to the man in the Meteos review). "Produced by"/"directed by"/"graced by the divine hand of," whatever. The point remains! A Meteos review without an aside to Lumines is like cornflakes without the milk.

The prospect of combining Touch & Go with the PSP horrifies me. Dragging a scratchy stylus across that delicate eggshell of a screen... yeep.
 
Out of interest, what does the Lumines review say about Meteos in terms of comparisons ?
 
i don't know why you'd want to do that gameplay trick :\
Click to expand...
As I've said, with some self restraint that issue should not be much of an issue. It does cheapen the game when you want to compare high scores with other people, though You can never know if they just went cheapo way, or payed fair.
 
DCharlie said:
Out of interest, what does the Lumines review say about Meteos in terms of comparisons ?
Click to expand...
Jack shit, because I hadn't yet played Meteos when I wrote the Lumines review. Tragically, I am constrained by linear time and wasn't able to accurately predict how I would feel about Meteos. Damn causality all to hell!
 
DCharlie said:
Out of interest, what does the Lumines review say about Meteos in terms of comparisons ?
Click to expand...

"We can't help but think that Meteos would have been better suited to the DS--well, no, not really, we're just fucking with you. Why? Because the DS is gay. How gay? Imagine if a giant gay star went supernova, then multiply that by a factor of about twenty. Now that is gay."

I guess they have every right to be angry. :(
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Metroid Prime 4: Beyond | Review Thread
Analysis Review  19 20 21 22 23
1K
1K
tr1p1ex replied
Where Winds Meet | Review Thread
Analysis Review 
9
896
Gamer_By_Proxy replied
Reach (nDreams) Review Thread
Review VR 
1
421
Romulus replied
Hades 2 | Review Thread
Review  2 3 4
178
3K
HYDE replied
MandaloreGaming: SOMA Review
Analysis Review Trailer 
1
157
IbizaPocholo replied
Top Bottom