Yeah if you don't have any idea of how that even works and how his brothers sound nothing like him, sure.
You realize he would have to be 100% copied to even have a chance of that making sense, which he wasn't because they didn't grow him in a tube or something. Gonna just quote the wiki here: "In 1972, utilizing the latest in Analog Cloning technology and the Super Baby Method, an egg from Dr. Clark's Japanese assistant was fertilized with Big Boss's DNA and transferred to the womb of EVA, who volunteered to be the surrogate mother."
So yeah exact same vocal cords idea doesn't work. Not even in fictional MGS land.
Edit-In fact, Solidus was the perfect clone of the three, so that idea makes even less sense!
Too bad for you. Skipping what might be the best game in the series just for a voice actor is so..well..stupid. But that's just me.
HOOOOOLY crap at Sutherland phoning this in. lol, he sounds bored, or like he's embarrassed to be there almost.
It was Kojima's decision to change Snake's voice not Kris. And I agree with him. David Hayter's performance went downhill after MGS4.
I am. Unless he pukes "blood" there should be no trace of HIV and Cancer can't be diagnosed through puke. It doesn't work this way.
It was Kojima's decision to change Snake's voice not Kris. And I agree with him. David Hayter's performance went downhill after MGS4.
It was Kojima's decision to change Snake's voice not Kris. And I agree with him. David Hayter's performance went downhill after MGS4.
Got that vibe too
I still believe this is an elaborate troll
please say it is
Got that vibe too
I still believe this is an elaborate troll
please say it is
That's not the part I meant being serious about.
This. Geeze I cant believe people look at transition from MGS3 to MGSW for Hayter's Big Boss and think we need more of THAT voice for this game. Seriously. Hayter's raspy, gargled voice was horrible and I'm glad they're moving on and this is coming from someone who LOVED Hayter's work in MGS and MGS2.
I like that people aren't even trying to defend Kiefer's acting. Instead, saying the other guy would be no better.
I know. It's the fact I am going technical. I love that xD Doesn't change the fact that Kiefer's voice is awesome and that David Hayter sucked in PW. I don't want Old Snake's voice in MGSV, thank you.
Because his acting is awesome. You guys are too butthurt to see anything beyond your own pain.
HOOOOOLY crap at Sutherland phoning this in. lol, he sounds bored, or like he's embarrassed to be there almost.
I'm pretty sure Hayter was intentionally making himself sound like that to fit the role of an aged Snake. He wouldn't sound like that in MGSV. He was pretty damn good as Big Boss in MGS3.
It really, really isn't. I could practically hear him turning the script pages as he lifelessly read his lines.
His performance in that trailer was so wooden I had to call in an exterminator to get rid of some termites afterwards.
It's probably just hard to accept a natural performance when you're used to hearing that forced tripe that we've always got before. "Kept you waiting. huh" has always sounded stupid.
It's probably just hard to accept a natural performance when you're used to hearing that forced tripe that we've always got before. "Kept you waiting. huh" has always sounded stupid.
Performance quality has nothing to do with any of it though. If it did, this entire series would be completely different.
Someone else said it in another thread, but Kojima is simply a starfucker. He wanted a big-name, Hollywood actor in his lead role solely for the sake of having a big-name, Hollywood actor.
If he had recasted the part and given it Kiefer over Hayter for mocap reasons, that would at least make sense. But Kiefer didn't even do any of that, just the facial capture, so there's really no excuse other than him wanting a Hollywood actor in the role.
The voice... it's not Snake. ~cries~
1st stage is denial...
LOL at you thinking that was a natural performance.
Shit most of the old cast is still there.
the Snake thing is just going to tick me off more now.
The voice acting is painful...
Okay I'm reading backwards through this thread and the meltdowns just keep getting better and better.
Sutherland might sound bored, but at least he doesn't sound like a parody of himself.
Kojima already explained why he chose Kiefer.
1) David's Snake voice as it is does NOT sound human at all when Kojima is taking a more realistic approach in that matter. The game is obviously darker and far more serious.
2) Kojima wants Snake to express emotions through facial expressions rather than relying on the tone of his voice or the words he says. Thanks to the motion/facial capture and the fact the english cast will be doing the mo-cap for this game, Kojima's fantasy would become a reality because Kiefer has years of acting skills and anyone who watched Season 8 from 24 would understand that his voice and facial capture would perfectly fit Big Boss' character and personality. The theme of season 8 is "Revenge" and Jack Bauer (Kiefer) shows it through his emotions. And I am so excited because I know how it is going to look like when Big Boss will be expressing those same emotions. (ex: Crying, shouting, torturing etc...)
3) David Hayter does NOT have acting skills and he would be just terrible at doing the facial capture. Not to mention his voice went downhill after MGS4. He sounded like Old Snake in PW when he shouldn't have. Thank you David, but I don't want Old Snake in MGSV.
4) I love David Hayter and I am sure he will return as Solid Snake and I believe that if Solid Snake was to be featured in MGSV, Hayter would definitely be back to take on this specific role. Big Boss is more human than Solid Snake will ever be. Kiefer sounds more human than David's Snake voice.
5) Kojima always took a risk with every iteration in the series and he always managed to deliver a masterpiece after the other and I really don't see how that is any different. Trust Kojima and wait for the final product before judging. I am positive that he will surpass every game he ever created with MGSV. Be patient guys and stop arguing when we haven't even played the game. Be optimistic. Semper Fi.
In Kojima We Trust.
I'd rather something be hammy and fun instead of completely fucking boring.
Also, major props to Robin Atkin Downes for being the only person in the trailer who gave even half a shit. It probably helps that he's a professional voice actor and actually knows what he's doing.
I'm pretty sure Hayter was intentionally making himself sound like that to fit the role of an aged Snake. He wouldn't sound like that in MGSV. He was pretty damn good as Big Boss in MGS3.
It's one thing to have an entire cast change, but hearing Miller's hella awesome voice alongside this... stranger's is bizarre. Frankly bizarre.
What was up with Miller in PW anyway? He just kinda turns up. Guess I should go listen to those codec files.
Shit most of the old cast is still there.
the Snake thing is just going to tick me off more now.
and going by this trailer Huey's(Otacon's) is the same,
this is going to be awfully weird(bad).
be sure to complete PW 100%.
Dude read again. I clearly said he sucked in PEACE WALKER. MGSV is a sequel to PEACE WALKER. If David SUCKED in PEACE WALKER, he would SUCK in MGSV. Get it now?
The lack of logic in this statement strikes me as equal parts humorous and sad.
He had one lackluster performance and several awesome ones. The probability is he would have another awesome performance.
And Hayter's poor voice acting is still miles ahead of the Robot Sutherland I heard in the MGSV trailer.
I'd rather something be hammy and fun instead of completely fucking boring.
Also, major props to Robin Atkin Downes for being the only person in the trailer who gave even half a shit. It probably helps that he's a professional voice actor and actually knows what he's doing.
Puke has no trace of cancer or HIV. Your post is pure ignorance as fuck.
These new consoles didn't have enough power for some SSAO? Everything looks so flat now. Snake looks like he's floating at the start on the hill.
Also, I'm disappointed in how crappy his hair looks. Raiden's hair in MGS2 felt way more next gen than what I get from this.