Support NeoGAF

[*Splinter]

VOTE: Ty4on


bye then.

VOTE: Ty4on


Bye, then. RIP.

What do you want? Sky was poor. He fucked it on himself?

RIP?

Day 2 was who I thought was scum. That's that.


Bye.

How many fingers am I holding up?

 

[melonrabbit]

I know?
Splinter also had a scum read on her:

Then why were you dumb enough to NK her?

 

[melonrabbit]

"Confirmed"

I'm talking about Kawl. He isnt confirmed but I'm calling him confirmed, because he is.

Where are you on the scale from 1 to blarg for talking nonsense?

Kawl just wants you to assume he's "confirmed."

 

[Sorian]

There can be two scum left with this setup right? Because the lack of effort cabot and melon are putting in is palpable.

Snark aside, why are you trying to "bye" out of here cabot?

 

[*Splinter]

Where are you on the scale from 1 to blarg for talking nonsense?

Kawl just wants you to assume he's "confirmed."

What makes you think that?

 

[cabot]

How many fingers am I holding up?

Do I care, lover?


No, I do not.

It's up to you if you think that's relevant. Otherwise, who gives a fuck.

 

[Sorian]

Oh and to melon, what does "Kawl is 1911" mean?

 

[Fireblend]

Hey all, I'm here but my gf just defended her thesis so I won't be super active. I'll keep up though.

My current D3 reads:

Ty is scum
Fire is likely scum
Kawl is 1911
*Splinter is giving me a headache
Stan is good
YNNY I'm null
cabot is here
Sophia is RIP
And there is you. Not loving you so far.

What about me makes you think I'm likely scum? I agree with Ty though, I kind of regret not pushing for him harder yesterday. You're also up there though, kind of hard to see the kind of scum team you think me and Ty are.

 

[Ty4on]

So day 1 was focusing on inactives.

Day 2 was playing with two town wagons.

And day 3 was hoping to mislynch the wagon who lost day 2 and ride the momentum of a close vote. Do I have that right?

D1 lynch was used to exploit SkyOdin's scummy vote.

Hell you had like 2 hours since you said you were here and didn't do anything apart from say you'll 'read into others posts'

How'd that go?

VOTE: Hyperactivity

SkyOdin voting on Terra is enough for me to seal this deal.

He's assumed to be scummy. I only remember cabot really scumreading Sky.

What, why?

Well I scumread you pretty hard right now and I was easing back on Terra. Compound that with Hyper's unconvincing case over the past two hours, and here I am.

For the record, I find that a very tenuous line of logic, even if I was scum (which I am not).

One facet. I stated the other reasons.

THE DAY HAS ENDED

CEASE POSTING IMMEDIATELY

STAND BY

Well that was a good night kill choice.



Right, SkyOdin.

VOTE: SkyOdin

How strong did you town read Hyper before day end?

 

[melonrabbit]

What makes you think that?

He's our resident serial killer.

Oh and to melon, what does "Kawl is 1911" mean?

Crack the code, dude.

No one is even trying

 

[Ty4on]

Forgot to show that I edited the last part out of cabot's last post (first post on D2).
He throws shade at melonrabbit. I wanna link the two as scum (dammit Sorian, now I look like even more of a bandwagoner), but I was too lazy last night.

VOTE: cabot

 

[Sorian]

When do YNNNY and Stan show up, I don't think I've had direct communication with either yet.

 

[Ty4on]

When do YNNNY and Stan show up, I don't think I've had direct communication with either yet.

Day start is 7am for Yeeny and 9am for Stanley. Stanley is not a morning person...

 

[*Splinter]

Forgot to show that I edited the last part out of cabot's last post (first post on D2).
He throws shade at melonrabbit. I wanna link the two as scum (dammit Sorian, now I look like even more of a bandwagoner), but I was too lazy last night.

VOTE: cabot

It's funny you should say that. I've been thinking you and melon were doing the same thing.

 

[Sorian]

He's our resident serial killer.



Crack the code, dude.

No one is even trying

The serial killer that never kills, truly the most dangerous of animals.

Forgot to show that I edited the last part out of cabot's last post (first post on D2).
He throws shade at melonrabbit. I wanna link the two as scum (dammit Sorian, now I look like even more of a bandwagoner), but I was too lazy last night.

VOTE: cabot

What a sheep.

/s

 

[cabot]

OK Ty, I made a fucking solid case for going no more than A+ nonsense, Give me more than that to sort the problem.

.

 

[Sorian]

It's funny you should say that. I've been thinking you and melon were doing the same thing.

Ty4on is confirmed town though

 

[cabot]

VOTE:Ty4on


Tell me why you voted me, right now.

 

[melonrabbit]

Hey all, I'm here but my gf just defended her thesis so I won't be super active. I'll keep up though.


What about me makes you think I'm likely scum? I agree with Ty though, I kind of regret not pushing for him harder yesterday. You're also up there though, kind of hard to see the kind of scum team you think me and Ty are.

Catvoca acted a little fishy D1 before you subbed in. And I think you some of your voting has been questionable without much reasoning behind it (almost as if you had to throw out a vote not to look bandwagoning). I think you and Ty would make a fine team with you coasting in the middle tier and Ty4on fielding the heat.

 

[Ty4on]

VOTE:Ty4on


Tell me why you voted me, right now.

You didn't answer me.

Catvoca acted a little fishy D1 before you subbed in. And I think you some of your voting has been questionable without much reasoning behind it (almost as if you had to throw out a vote not to look bandwagoning). I think you and Ty would make a fine team with you coasting in the middle tier and Ty4on fielding the heat.

Good thing we get to choose our scum teams instead of relying on RNG.

 

[Fireblend]

Catvoca acted a little fishy D1 before you subbed in. And I think you some of your voting has been questionable without much reasoning behind it (almost as if you had to throw out a vote not to look bandwagoning). I think you and Ty would make a fine team with you coasting in the middle tier and Ty4on fielding the heat.

Mind providing some quotes for Catvoca's fishiness? And what vote of mine have you thought had little reasoning? Can you bring up any examples?

 

[Ty4on]

Ty4on is confirmed town though

There's only like two out of six setups without a Godfather tho.

TTTTTTT = Goon + Godfather, Serial Killer (Investigation Immune OR 1-Shot Bulletproof) - IMPOSSIBLE

TTTTTT = Goon + Godfather - IMPOSSIBLE

TTTTT = Goon + Godfather, Serial Killer (Investigation Immune OR 1-Shot Bulletproof) - UNLIKELY

TTTT = 2 Goons + Roleblocker

TTT = 2 Goons + Roleblocker, Serial Killer (Investigation Immune OR 1-Shot Bulletproof) - UNLIKELY

TT = Goon + Roleblocker + Godfather

T = Goon + Roleblocker + Godfather, Serial Killer (Investigation Immune OR 1-Shot Bulletproof) - UNLIKELY

0 Ts = Goon + Roleblocker + Godfather

 

[Sorian]

There's only like two out of six setups without a Godfather tho.

I'm going to be real here, I don't understand this set up at all. How are the first two things there marked as impossible?

 

[cabot]

You didn't answer me.

Good thing we get to choose our scum teams instead of relying on RNG.

You are scum. Bye, then,

 

[*Splinter]

I'm going to be real here, I don't understand this set up at all. How are the first two things there marked as impossible?

A cop is CC. Even if that's our only PR that would only leave TTTTT.

Not sure why he marked a TTT as unlikely though.

 

[Ty4on]

I'm going to be real here, I don't understand this set up at all. How are the first two things there marked as impossible?

You roll a 100 sided die seven times.

1-50 is T (no town PR)
everything else is various PRs (51-65 is cop, or C)
For a normal cop you need 2Cs so the two setups with 7T and 6T are impossible
For a second one shot cop we need 3C so then 5T is also impossible
4C is two cops etc...

 

[*Splinter]

A cop is CC. Even if that's our only PR that would only leave TTTTT.

Not sure why he marked a TTT as unlikely though.

Oh right, unlikely because it includes a serial killer

 

[melonrabbit]

Mind providing some quotes for Catvoca's fishiness? And what vote of mine have you thought had little reasoning? Can you bring up any examples?

Catvoca was really into discussing the peek plan and probably spent more time talking about it than he did with other players. Looking back it seems like he was trying not to make waves but still wanted to appear agreeable. This all read a little off to me which it why I brought it up.

You have remained somewhere in the middle tier and are also not making too waves—this can be explained A) subbing and catching up B) play style C) scum. Factored this in your random LP vote on D1 and yesterday bus attempt something isn’t right here.

 

[melonrabbit]

There's only like two out of six setups without a Godfather tho.

I'm still angry about that.

 

[Sorian]

A cop is CC. Even if that's our only PR that would only leave TTTTT.

Not sure why he marked a TTT as unlikely though.

You roll a 100 sided die seven times.

1-50 is T (no town PR)
everything else is various PRs (51-65 is cop, or C)
For a normal cop you need 2Cs so the two setups with 7T and 6T are impossible
For a second one shot cop we need 3C so then 5T is also impossible
4C is two cops etc...

Oh I see, I wasn't understanding the distinction between a single C and a double.

 

[YesNOnoNOYes]

G'morning! ^____^

So, I have good news \o/ yey \o/

checked on melonrabbit last night and she is scum

vote: melonrabbit

 

[Sorian]

G'morning! ^____^

So, I have good news o/ yey o/

checked on melonrabbit last night and she is scum

vote: melonrabbit

To the shock of no one.

Vote: melonrabbit

 

[Ty4on]

Didn't know this day could get any weirder.

VOTE: melonrabbit

 

[melonrabbit]

G'morning! ^____^

So, I have good news \o/ yey \o/

checked on melonrabbit last night and she is scum

vote: melonrabbit

Is this you claiming?

 

[YesNOnoNOYes]

This was my one shot~

I didn't use it on N1 cuz my D1 reads were only giving me about 75% scumminess on her and i only have the single shot so it was precious *____*

but she continued to give me scumread on D2 specially since Sophia picked up that she continued to hitch rides on other people's target... as she mentioned it in her post no. 576. so i thought it was worthwhile to use my one shot on N2 \o/ and i found scum hooray~

 

[Fireblend]

Catvoca was really into discussing the peek plan and probably spent more time talking about it than he did with other players. Looking back it seems like he was trying not to make waves but still wanted to appear agreeable. This all read a little off to me which it why I brought it up.

You have remained somewhere in the middle tier and are also not making too waves—this can be explained A) subbing and catching up B) play style C) scum. Factored this in your random LP vote on D1 and yesterday bus attempt something isn’t right here.

Those are some cool invisible quotes from Catvoca. I'm convinced

And get out with the "somewhere in the middle" thing. Vague accusations are going to get you nowhere. My L_P vote wasn't random and I already explained why. I don't even understand what bus attempt you're talking about yesterday. Against ty? The guy you think is scum? Try harder.

 

[Fireblend]

Vote: melonrabbit

 

[Sorian]

So if YNNNY is telling the truth which I am happy to test, that means the only setup we can further eliminate is the goon, godfather, SK one? So no real new info there.

 

[melonrabbit]

Those are some cool invisible quotes from Catvoca. I'm convinced

And get out with the "somewhere in the middle" thing. Vague accusations are going to get you nowhere. My L_P vote wasn't random and I already explained why. I don't even understand what bus attempt you're talking about yesterday. Against ty? The guy you think is scum? Try harder.

You're getting awful defensive for someone I think might be town.

This was my one shot~

I didn't use it on N1 cuz my D1 reads were only giving me about 75% scumminess on her and i only have the single shot so it was precious *____*

but she continued to give me scumread on D2 specially since Sophia picked up that she continued to hitch rides on other people's target... as she mentioned it in her post no. 576. so i thought it was worthwhile to use my one shot on N2 \o/ and i found scum hooray~

This was my one shot~

I didn't use it on N1 cuz my D1 reads were only giving me about 75% scumminess on her and i only have the single shot so it was precious *____*

but she continued to give me scumread on D2 specially since Sophia picked up that she continued to hitch rides on other people's target... as she mentioned it in her post no. 576. so i thought it was worthwhile to use my one shot on N2 \o/ and i found scum hooray~

That's super convenient you have a shot. Suddenly.

I'm sorry you wasted it because I'm vanilla town.

Also I now know you're liar. Grats.

 

[melonrabbit]

@Fire You're getting awful defensive for someone I think might be scum**

(Now I'm royal )

 

[*Splinter]

So if YNNNY is telling the truth which I am happy to test, that means the only setup we can further eliminate is the goon, godfather, SK one? So no real new info there.

If melon is a goon, the last scum is a role block. If she is a role block then you are correct.

I think?

VOTE: melonrabbit

 

[Sorian]

If melon is a goon, the last scum is a role block. If she is a role block then you are correct.

I think?

VOTE: melonrabbit

Oh that's true, we'd have her flip to consider as well.

 

[YesNOnoNOYes]

You're getting awful defensive for someone I think might be town.





That's super convenient you have a shot. Suddenly.

I'm sorry you wasted it because I'm vanilla town.

Also I now know you're liar. Grats.

wow

you quoted the same post of mine twice :> im flattered~

convenient? i donno what you mean, it's in my role PM :3 ??????? convenient for town, i guess since we had lost our full cop on N1?

i dont mind being proven a liar a champion of town with your flip~ come on, lets dance~

 

[*Splinter]

Oh that's true, we'd have her flip to consider as well.

Hmm... How did you come to that conclusion without considering her flip?

 

[Ty4on]

So if YNNNY is telling the truth which I am happy to test, that means the only setup we can further eliminate is the goon, godfather, SK one? So no real new info there.

No, that's not right. Because we can eliminate that setup we know we have at least one extra town PR.
Doctor only needs one D for a regular doctor unlike cop where one C is a one shot.

 

[Sorian]

Hmm... How did you come to that conclusion without considering her flip?

There would be 3Cs which only leaves 4Ts at max which means the 5T scenario is eliminated. Isn't that how you both just explained it to me?

 

[melonrabbit]

wow

you quoted the same post of mine twice :> im flattered~

convenient? i donno what you mean, it's in my role PM :3 ??????? convenient for town, i guess since we had lost our full cop on N1?

i dont mind being proven a liar a champion of town with your flip~ come on, lets dance~

Ynny,

I’m calling your bullshit here.

You defense why you chosen me is linking to someone else’s post. Why not one of your own on me? You have a few. Also if you had noticed I was questioning Ty’s actions prior to Sophia’s post anyhow. I find it strange you wouldn’t use your shot on Terra’s replacement who you spent so much time on yesterday.

In seems a waste of a shot especially when I’m (going into D3) a likely lynch candidate. Had you used it on Sorian you could’ve at least closed that lead.

I can give you credit for going this gambit. Ballsy.

I think we have our scum now team in hyper, Ty, ynny and maybe fire depending on the setup.

 

[*Splinter]

There would be 3Cs which only leaves 4Ts at max which means the 5T scenario is eliminated. Isn't that how you both just explained it to me?

Oh yeah. Duh

 

[Sorian]

No, that's not right. Because we can eliminate that setup we know we have at least one extra town PR.
Doctor only needs one D for a regular doctor unlike cop where one C is a one shot.

On the other hand, I've re read this post twice now and looked at that wiki page bats has and I don't see where this conclusion is coming from.

 

[Sorian]

Actually I guess that Time has since bats didn't post the OP for his own game.

Rookies.