YesNOnoNOYes
Member
call my bullshit, is all cool :>
with a cop claim, it's easy to call bullshit. just lynch the accused and if the flip is town, lynch the one claiming cop. 1 vs 1 trade isn't bad for town, really.
BASIC MAFIA
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Mini Mafia I |OT| Why is it so small?
- Thread starter Timeaisis
- Start date
call my bullshit, is all cool :>
with a cop claim, it's easy to call bullshit. just lynch the accused and if the flip is town, lynch the one claiming cop. 1 vs 1 trade isn't bad for town, really.
BASIC MAFIA
Cool, that makes today's vote easy then.
Vote: melonrabbit
If she flips town, we flip Yn, that's always a good trade.
(at 9, lynching town melon if Yn is lying makes 8 with 2, nk make 7 with 2, still plenty of time to turn around and lynch Yn)
morganfreemanshesrightyouknow.jpg
Ugh, sorry, I was looking at how the godfather made it impossible and thought we had an extra non T.
melonrabbit
Member
So you are really going to wait 20+ hours without looking at anyone else? So on D4 you and your scum mates can clean up?
If it was a proper 1 to 1 trade we should be looking at Ty. Because you guys just mislynched Sky yesterday.
Y'all just forgot about Ty4on.
Which was their plan.
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
oh no, we can always scumhunt! i just had to come in with my result from last night because i was super happy to find a scum ^____^
we can use the remaining of the day to talk about anything we want! like, i think town can looksie people's reactions throughout the day and then use that information to find your partner.
why arent you voting for me if you really are calling me a liar, though???? i would vote the liar if i was in your shoes but.... i guess you know for sure that im actually right about you, right?
i donno about 'us guys' mislynching sky. i was the one holding the unpopular view that he was town.
Nah, people should keep looking and I plan to do so a bit later. I'm still very much suspicous of Ty, don't you worry little wolfbro.
melonrabbit
Member
I wasn't referring you. I was referring to the rest of the town. So not you.
Because your username is hard to spell.
Vote: YesNOnoNOYes
It's midnight and he seems pretty wasted.
melonrabbit
Member
Glad at least one of you is talking some sense.
Hmm, fair, I didn't even think about him doing that because drunk, it is Friday, nevermind then.
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
oh also, that's not a 1 to 1 trade.
1 to 1 trade is lynching someone who is accused by someone else claiming cop to test if the one claiming cop is telling the truth or not. lynching someone else outside the equation is not how 1 to 1 trade work....
we're at 9 now. town had one mislynch. 1 to 1 trade at a later stage is actually more dangerous for town. so this is actually not a bad place for town to be, right now.
and when you flip maf, town will be at a better position to hunt for the remaining scum member yay :>
and thank you for taking the effort to spell my name right with your vote o7 (vote tool will work regardless of capitalisation, just as an fyi) (i know my nick is a pain in the butts to spell)
(sozz)
melonrabbit
Member
Regardless, giving Ty another night is dangerous also. He's playing you again. He doesn't have to do anything expect watch town go after town.
Also, why are you so certain there's two left?
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
uh mechanics discussion from kawl and ty and sorian.... TTTT or TT likeliest, if im following the talk correctly.
something about goon + gf + rb and no sk or 2 goons + rb or somesuch...
melonrabbit
Member
melon where were you planning to go with the 1911 thing?
Also props for keeping up the lie, but you'd be the "right" lynch to make even if you were town
1911 is the SK. The longer they wait to kill someone the more likely they can catch us off guard.
I thought you of all people would be at least open to questioning things that seems at little to convenient.
melonrabbit
Member
But how come you don't know which it is?
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
melon where were you planning to go with the 1911 thing?
Also props for keeping up the lie, but you'd be the "right" lynch to make even if you were town
^ yep
also i find it telling that i had to prompt her vote on me. i know she said my nick is hard to type, but come on, we're playing forum mafia. if i was legit calling someone a liar, i'd have lashed out and made the effort to strike back and lay down a vote without having to be called out for it~
Simply put theres no where this its t vt with you and yn sorry.
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
cuz im not maf \o/
to be honest, im not too on top of the mechanic discussion .... BUT! i am following the general gist that there is likely TWO mafia left though!
but i know you are maf
and with your flip, we will know more information to determine the composition of your wolf team :>
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
SK has to attempt to kill every night thoughhh? they dont actually get to wait to kill someone...
melonrabbit
Member
OK. But maybe lynching the people that start backstabbing town would be a better go. Ynny have tunneled on me since D1, she cooled on D2 when it didn't get traction and now is going after me again as easy target.
As a narrative, I can't be scum.
Doesn't make sense.
And I was right about being targeted with LP because it is still happening.
You were right because that was why you killed him?
with 2 C's confirmed and a second night of only 1 kill, we are confirmed to be in a 3 scum set up.
melonrabbit
Member
You were right because that was why you killed him?
No. I was right about Ty setting me up. Along with ynny's help.
Look, a cop claims scum, you lynch the target and if they flip town you lynch the cop. Especially in a set up you know doesn't contain insane cops, switchers, etc.
Sorry mate.
You can't defend yourself from this lynch. Your best bet is to stop throwing shade at Yn, because she is definitely gone if you are town, and actively hunt for scum so that if you flip town we have some actual worthwhile discussion from you to look back over.
Does it actually say that anywhere?
Think I know why Sophia died.
Way back in Danganronpa, we (scum) ended up in a pretty bad situation with a shitload of confirmed (or "confirmed") townies that outnumbered the pool of lynch able players (which included all the scum). Town was aware of its strong advantage, so the remaining scum chose to throw a curveball by NKing one of the few townies that could still have been lynched. It was hoped that this would spook town into changing course.
It was wholly unsuccessful, but there you go.
Tl;dr melon and Ty are scum gg wp
Way back in Danganronpa, we (scum) ended up in a pretty bad situation with a shitload of confirmed (or "confirmed") townies that outnumbered the pool of lynch able players (which included all the scum). Town was aware of its strong advantage, so the remaining scum chose to throw a curveball by NKing one of the few townies that could still have been lynched. It was hoped that this would spook town into changing course.
It was wholly unsuccessful, but there you go.
Tl;dr melon and Ty are scum gg wp
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
so it is the absence of multiple kills each night that points to the 3 scum set up? ....okay, i see.
thanks kawuru o7
sorian, i thought that's the standard SK? i saw the ones played in the past GAFia games have all been that way. They had to attempt a kill every night phase.
That was always mod discretion, PW SK wasn't required to kill for example. It would be completely ineffective most likely but a SK could play as a survivor if they wanted to unless I'm missing a rule somewhere.
Thankfully this is a semi-open setup.
Doesn't look like they have to kill every night, but they cannot win as a survivor.
melonrabbit
Member
You got one right.
You want to be scum hunt for you Kawl? I did yesterday and put forth evidence that Ty was running a gambit against me. Today confirms it.
Should have said survivor at the start, yeah, they can't team with anyone, figured that.
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
tbh the one i remembered clearly was kark from season 1, the others were imprinted upon by that particular SK set up, but yeah, i thought i have heard a few times in GAFia that SKs are generally compelled to attempt a kill every night.
but, mmm, i admit i didn't follow PW closely so i thank you for that information o7
AND TY AND BATSIE TO THE RESCUE. MUCH GRATEFUL <3
*crunch*
It's interesting to note that it seems from the win percentages on this set up type that SK cannabalizes scum win chance. It's also used as a way to weaken scum it seems compared to the amount of power roles town has.
I'm a bit disappointed we don't have a SK and apparently no vig.
If we do have a one shot lurking around can you shoot Ty pretty please?
I'm a bit disappointed we don't have a SK and apparently no vig.
If we do have a one shot lurking around can you shoot Ty pretty please?
Hyperactivity
Banned
Btw guys, scum have a pretty cool name you should call us by:
M.O.U.S - Mafia Of Unusual Size
ok back to the dead thread
M.O.U.S - Mafia Of Unusual Size
ok back to the dead thread
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
im going to ISO a few players soon, just in case maf will kill me tonight, i wanna leave a good trail of thoughts.
first up is STANLEYPALMTREE
so he began with a post saying that he had expected the gafia meta to carry through to this game but apparently we were having a productive scumhunting D1 and he was surprised. he was also proclaiming #teampeek (bear this in mind, he later didn't report a peek) though he also questioned the plan:
then he followed through with a slight push towards the plan but with a persistent disclaimer against it, in that it had to be EVERYONE or that it would be pointless:
the next post is a little gem. he called sophia out for calling me for coasting. this is great because if there was anyone who was coasting at that stage, it would be stanley and terrabyte20xx.
the following two posts are soft shades at kawl, but not enough to lay a vote. they are what i call FLUID POSITIONING posts, which are often a scummy tell:
then followed a few back and forth with cabot about cabot's joke-vote on me at the start of the game. not sure how i would describe them, except that they were another set statements saying that i was hard to read for him.
however, the two following posts after that made me townread stanley since he took a solid stance against someone without much prompts:
Furthermore, he didn't move his vote at the end of the day, and this made me townread him a little further. He wasn't concerned about positioning his vote one way or another for later analysis.
... alright that was Stanley on D1. Now D2, he began his posts with his consistent position at terra's butts:
Then he followed with a little post that I kinda liked, reminding everyone that we have to keep suspicion on everyone in play:
his next post was a little wishywashy, mostly saying that his hunches on hyper was correctish, and that he didn't report a peek cuz he thought it wasn't going to be useful.
and more wishywashy note in the following post:
the next post had a defensive tone, because i called him out for not reporting a peek:
but the post after that had a hint of honest self awareness, saying that he realized his bias. not a winner of a post, but one that made me felt that he was genuine.
then he voted against terra, which had been a consistent position with stan, this post made me townread him a little more:
but then his next post after was a little mixed bag. it read wishywashy on skyodin and melon, in fact, he sort of just adopted my position on sky-o. but i did notice that he came out quite openly about feeling good about sophia, with a reasoning of her playstyle.
then he followed through with providing more explanation on his townread of sophia. this post was a good post in my book:
but then he finished with another non-committal post:
though to be fair, he has been consistently wishywashy about certain people (sky-o, fireblend, melon) and consistently not wishywashy about certain other people (terrabyte, sophia, me)
so, all in all, i read stanley as SLIGHTLY TOWN. just barely.
(sorry for the long read. took a while to put that together)
first up is STANLEYPALMTREE
so he began with a post saying that he had expected the gafia meta to carry through to this game but apparently we were having a productive scumhunting D1 and he was surprised. he was also proclaiming #teampeek (bear this in mind, he later didn't report a peek) though he also questioned the plan:
then he followed through with a slight push towards the plan but with a persistent disclaimer against it, in that it had to be EVERYONE or that it would be pointless:
the next post is a little gem. he called sophia out for calling me for coasting. this is great because if there was anyone who was coasting at that stage, it would be stanley and terrabyte20xx.
the following two posts are soft shades at kawl, but not enough to lay a vote. they are what i call FLUID POSITIONING posts, which are often a scummy tell:
then followed a few back and forth with cabot about cabot's joke-vote on me at the start of the game. not sure how i would describe them, except that they were another set statements saying that i was hard to read for him.
however, the two following posts after that made me townread stanley since he took a solid stance against someone without much prompts:
Furthermore, he didn't move his vote at the end of the day, and this made me townread him a little further. He wasn't concerned about positioning his vote one way or another for later analysis.
... alright that was Stanley on D1. Now D2, he began his posts with his consistent position at terra's butts:
Then he followed with a little post that I kinda liked, reminding everyone that we have to keep suspicion on everyone in play:
his next post was a little wishywashy, mostly saying that his hunches on hyper was correctish, and that he didn't report a peek cuz he thought it wasn't going to be useful.
and more wishywashy note in the following post:
the next post had a defensive tone, because i called him out for not reporting a peek:
but the post after that had a hint of honest self awareness, saying that he realized his bias. not a winner of a post, but one that made me felt that he was genuine.
then he voted against terra, which had been a consistent position with stan, this post made me townread him a little more:
but then his next post after was a little mixed bag. it read wishywashy on skyodin and melon, in fact, he sort of just adopted my position on sky-o. but i did notice that he came out quite openly about feeling good about sophia, with a reasoning of her playstyle.
then he followed through with providing more explanation on his townread of sophia. this post was a good post in my book:
but then he finished with another non-committal post:
though to be fair, he has been consistently wishywashy about certain people (sky-o, fireblend, melon) and consistently not wishywashy about certain other people (terrabyte, sophia, me)
so, all in all, i read stanley as SLIGHTLY TOWN. just barely.
(sorry for the long read. took a while to put that together)
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
:<
i ... i was doing some ISO work. sorry that others lack the drive to scumhunt *throws shades willynilly*
melonrabbit
Member
Lynch me today and YNNY tomorrow after I flip town. Instead of being idle and not accomplishing anything we need to focus on the long-term and better protect the town from scum further causing us to turn on each other. We got really lucky D1 and got hyper and I think they felt the pressure and are now laying the ground to steamroll us.
So what do we know?
There are likely 3 scums. Exact roles undetermined but we at least have some clues about who they are/were --
- Hyper was scum (and needs to stick to the dead thread)
- YNNY is scum or worse
- And now we have to look and determine whom the remaining scum is.
I believe Ty4ons actions during the last two days have given enough evidence of suspicion. If you want to actually listen to specific again Ill advise you to my previous posts.
Rereading the thread and giving special attention to how D2 closed. Sorian is there other person that stands out to me. Apparently this town has a short memory given how suspiciously Terra acted and now youre not even questioning Sorians behavior and accept him as town when he basically took control of how the vote when down yesterday and made sure you lynched Sky.
If you recalled we had a 4-3 for Sky, Ty. The two votes for Terra were all but locked in because both Stan and YNNY were asleep.
Sorian swoops in to chats with Ty about how unlikely he was getting lynched:
and then Sorian puts a vote on me (a safe questionable target):
Making sure to mention hed switch to Sky last minute.
When it became 50/50 between Ty and Sky he was able to seamlessly move his vote over to Sky without anyone seeing that he was helping out his scummate:
We got played.
VOTE: Sorian
So what do we know?
There are likely 3 scums. Exact roles undetermined but we at least have some clues about who they are/were --
- Hyper was scum (and needs to stick to the dead thread)
- YNNY is scum or worse
- And now we have to look and determine whom the remaining scum is.
I believe Ty4ons actions during the last two days have given enough evidence of suspicion. If you want to actually listen to specific again Ill advise you to my previous posts.
Rereading the thread and giving special attention to how D2 closed. Sorian is there other person that stands out to me. Apparently this town has a short memory given how suspiciously Terra acted and now youre not even questioning Sorians behavior and accept him as town when he basically took control of how the vote when down yesterday and made sure you lynched Sky.
If you recalled we had a 4-3 for Sky, Ty. The two votes for Terra were all but locked in because both Stan and YNNY were asleep.
Sorian swoops in to chats with Ty about how unlikely he was getting lynched:
Melon has one vote and only Sky really going after her...
I... I don't think she's getting lynched
and then Sorian puts a vote on me (a safe questionable target):
Making sure to mention hed switch to Sky last minute.
When it became 50/50 between Ty and Sky he was able to seamlessly move his vote over to Sky without anyone seeing that he was helping out his scummate:
We got played.
VOTE: Sorian