Don't tell the doctor where to go.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Mini Mafia III |OT| An Amazing Alien Abduction Adventure
- Thread starter YesNOnoNOYes
- Start date
Don't tell the doctor where to go.
Personal opinion, not even a little. As scum I would even consider bringing ccs to end game.
Would you?
---
Going from memory right now I think the list is:
Lynch now: LP,
Could lynch: gorlak, haly
???: squid,
Reevaluating Time because I think I have a better idea where he's at
Well, on one hand, he'll never get mislynched. Lynching him means someone dies without scum giving up any additional information. This was the same reasoning scum used to kill coppa and I when we were masons.
On the other, they have no chance of hitting a power role if they go CCS. So it comes down to what kind of game scum wants to play. Personally I would be in favor of a CCS kill.
Ugh, yall keep trying to pull me away from Nioh.
LP got weirdly worried about an ouro train leading to a hammer when it wasn't that close at all and pulled his vote. That's a weird thing to do but I think it was LP being dumb. That said I understand the suspicion there but I'm inclined to believe that neither LP nor the people voting on LP are scum.
I'm far more interested in looking at people like Kawl, Kyan, and Time. I don't like Kyan's attitude, Time's presence or Kawl for who he is as a person.
For more mechanical discussion speculating about scum targets re CCS is not particularly good for town, I doubt anyone here is going to bring up anything a doctor wouldn't be able to figure out on their own and giving scum threads to work with in terms of sewing confusion in later days is a bad idea.
In the same vein peeking was discussed earlier and again it provides information to scum. don't do it.
Now back to Nioh.
LP got weirdly worried about an ouro train leading to a hammer when it wasn't that close at all and pulled his vote. That's a weird thing to do but I think it was LP being dumb. That said I understand the suspicion there but I'm inclined to believe that neither LP nor the people voting on LP are scum.
I'm far more interested in looking at people like Kawl, Kyan, and Time. I don't like Kyan's attitude, Time's presence or Kawl for who he is as a person.
For more mechanical discussion speculating about scum targets re CCS is not particularly good for town, I doubt anyone here is going to bring up anything a doctor wouldn't be able to figure out on their own and giving scum threads to work with in terms of sewing confusion in later days is a bad idea.
In the same vein peeking was discussed earlier and again it provides information to scum. don't do it.
Now back to Nioh.
The biggest benefit of taking a confirmed town to final 3 is that it frames the debate very clearly. It becomes a thunder dome with 1 cleared townie that must be convinced. That heads up argumentive style is much easier for scum to stick to their narrative. Deciding which of the two people you know for a fact are town as final scum to pick as your scum case is difficult. Having an inno child there removes that burden. CCs has the added benefit of being someone who has shown he can be swayed by a strong enough argument more so than more stubborn people in our community.
Why you you gotta be like that squids.
I'm no Cabot, there's no need to hate me as a person
What made you think LP was just being dumb? Is there some example you remember even if it's small?
Give us your reads then. Even if it's just one. If Ouro really was a joke vote, you probably have one or two others that could be serious contenders.
I just mean that I think the overreaction to the votes on ouro is in and of itself dumb.
I agree with that escpecially considering majority lynches can't even happen in this game. You said it made you think he was town though and you're the only one that made that conclusion.
So the implication from a scumread is that both ouro and LP are scum together, that LP was worried about getting a scum buddy killed day 1 and overreacted.
I don't think that's what's going on, it's too much too soon.
So the alternative is Ouro is town and LP is scum.Why draw attention to it? you'd be on your way to a low information mislynch.
I don't find either of these scenarios to be the highest probability right now so I'm inclined to believe LP is town.
Yeah that makes sense.
Well I'm Town so do your own derivation.
melonrabbit
Member
I just want LP to answer a question directly instead of turning tail at the first signs of criticism.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
I'll have an answer for you tomorrow.
Kawl, are you the SK? You have to answer me, I'm a cop.
you're stealing my lines.
I asked you first
no you dunce.
although i would be stoked to have a dope role like that. wouldn't squander it like another gafia member who shall remain unnamed.
look, I am depressed about the state of my stupid fucking country, and may be slightly drunk
Timeasis is sheeping the vote on LP, and I suspect he is bussing because LP is just a Goon. If I am wrong and you think I am mafia, feel free to kill me tomorrow.
For you OW jackasses - there are no Lynchers in C9++, so fuck off.
Timeasis is sheeping the vote on LP, and I suspect he is bussing because LP is just a Goon. If I am wrong and you think I am mafia, feel free to kill me tomorrow.
For you OW jackasses - there are no Lynchers in C9++, so fuck off.
seriously? I would totally do it.
C9++ = 13 players
assuming 3 scum
4.5 days until majority? Sure.
sure, use that reasoning
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
CURRENT VOTE TALLY:
Lone_Prodigy (5)
CzarTim #169
Haly #202
Crab #222
batsnacks #260
Kawl_USC #323
Timeaisis (2)
Ourobolus #215
CCS #310
Gorlak (1)
Ourobolus #60 #215
batsnacks #63 #260
Kawl_USC #175 #323
Timeaisis #200
Kyanrute (1)
squidyj #259
batsnacks (1)
Gorlak #57
Timeaisis #82 #200
CCS (0):Kawl_USC #90 #132
melonrabbit (0):Kawl_USC #132 #175
squidyj (0):Haly #58 #115
Crab (0):melonrabbit #137 #237
Ourobolus (0):Lone_Prodigy #69 #165, CzarTim #106 #169, Haly #115 #202
Kawl_USC (0):melonrabbit #109 #137
No active vote for Day 1: Kyanrute, Lone_Prodigy (has previously voted), melonrabbit (has previously voted)
Day 1 ends:
Automated vote tally here
Lone_Prodigy (5)
CzarTim #169
Haly #202
Crab #222
batsnacks #260
Kawl_USC #323
Timeaisis (2)
Ourobolus #215
CCS #310
Gorlak (1)
Timeaisis #200
Kyanrute (1)
squidyj #259
batsnacks (1)
Gorlak #57
CCS (0):
melonrabbit (0):
squidyj (0):
Crab (0):
Ourobolus (0):
Kawl_USC (0):
No active vote for Day 1: Kyanrute, Lone_Prodigy (has previously voted), melonrabbit (has previously voted)
Day 1 ends:
Automated vote tally here
I'm at work and could only skim. Will be catching up and provide further insight in about 6 hours.
For the time being I want to call out squidyj. Either I missed it or he did not comment on me vs. Bats which is pretty weird since in our last game he saw a pretty similar conversation between the exact same people. Squid what's your take on the situation?
Comparable Ouro's lack of interest is feeling off. Usually he's fucking around with me all day(see his first comment towards my first vote) since then radio silence.
Something was wrong with crab's question. Will look for it now before my break ends
For the time being I want to call out squidyj. Either I missed it or he did not comment on me vs. Bats which is pretty weird since in our last game he saw a pretty similar conversation between the exact same people. Squid what's your take on the situation?
Comparable Ouro's lack of interest is feeling off. Usually he's fucking around with me all day(see his first comment towards my first vote) since then radio silence.
Something was wrong with crab's question. Will look for it now before my break ends
Time isn't voting lp and in fact defended him, wtf are you going on about?
I don't see them as w/w. And I feel like every time I move off of someone day one even though they did something scummy, I end up regretting it. I think I'm comfortable with lp for now.
There it is. Vote goes to bats, already explained. After that probably Kyan. Will wait for Ouro's reaction. Indifferent on Lp atm.
Second question is wrong. I don't think many ppl started playing aggressive towards me. It was only bats with a ridiculous argument that makes no sense. Since he refused to discuss it any further my scum read on him is pretty strong.
Anyone else wasn't aggressive imo.
Long day yesterday, now back to work. As I said will be back.
No majority lynch makes people so eager with their votes. Makes certain someone stand out teehee. Right now would vote for Time and I am thinking about secondary candidates.
Crab, satisfied with the spread v focus answer?
Squid, why do you consider my perfect attitude unlikable?
and i could ask why gorlak wants to kill me but i get the feeling i know the answer
Crab, satisfied with the spread v focus answer?
Squid, why do you consider my perfect attitude unlikable?
and i could ask why gorlak wants to kill me but i get the feeling i know the answer
melonrabbit
Member
At work, I'll be back at lunch to post more thoughts.
Not sure what is going on with Ouro. Seems a big oversight to miss that Time wasn't even voting for LP and has been on Gorlak all day.
Hopefully by then LP can get back to me. Also would be interested hearing from Squid and that Kyan vote.
Not sure what is going on with Ouro. Seems a big oversight to miss that Time wasn't even voting for LP and has been on Gorlak all day.
Hopefully by then LP can get back to me. Also would be interested hearing from Squid and that Kyan vote.
Care to elaborate?
Darkness Against Domestic Violence? Or maybe Domain Analysis for Data Visualization?
Dead air, dead villager