Personally, I think the current chase is great. It's been exciting as hell. Mission accomplished from where I stand.
I'm a knowledgeable, but fairly casual NASCAR fan, so I don't really have an emotional tie to the "traditional" way of crowning the champ. If F1 went this way, I'd probably flip my lid however, so I can empathize with you dyed in the wool guys. I'll happily watch "moot" F1 races, as I'm sure you guys would for NASCAR.
I thought Newman's move was fine. There's not a single other person who wouldn't have done the same thing. It's going to be the same next week, so we all better get used to it! Will Harvick be the dumper or the dumpee? That's my partial prediction. I guess I'll go with the dumper as he was my pick before the Chase started. Harvick dumps Logano on a GWC. Chaos ensues. Book it