Blackleg-sanji1
Banned
That's how I feel about it. Manga is still awesome. The anime I'm not really feeling especially for a short season run.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
My Hero Academia Anime |OT| Go Beyond! PLUS ULTRA! (No Manga spoilers!)
- Thread starter SalvaPot
- Start date
- Status
I don't feel they've tried to hit the highs of the manga art but I do feel they done pretty good in getting the character design right and the colours our spot on.
What I find odd is that for 13 episode shounen the animation is very minimal when it comes to big flashy key animation,most of set piece scene's have been super short.
This week was one of the few episode Umakoshi Yoshihiko was actually involved in but with some odd title of "Cooperation animation supervisor" with 5 other guys,
I want to see the guy who did episode 2 get another shot at an episode
Dedication Through Light
Member
Never understood people compaing manga pages to the anime. The times when anime tries to do good art like the manga people say its lazy and and like a slideshow of the manga. Again proof that manga fans are never happy with any anime they are given.
Blackleg-sanji1
Banned
I was happy with one punch man,your lie in April,one piece(even with shitty animation and pacing), hunterXhunter,fairy tail,sword art online, food wars,prison school it goes on. People just expected more since they were doing it by seasons.
Did he? His two buddies voted for him, but I didn't necessarily think the third vote was him voting on himself.
Blackleg-sanji1
Banned
It wasn't clarified so idk if he did or not. I wonder if It'll be bought up later that somebody else had faith in him too.
I suspected this too, but then there was no onscreen reason for us to believe he voted for the only other person to get more than one vote, specially since Lida got 0 and if anything that would be who Deku would have voted for if not for himself.
it's funny how 1 episode can make people turn on this adaption lol, as if all the good episode never existed.
As much as a I despise bones,there actually quite a few postive aspects to them unlike JC staff(foodwars) who are the equivalent to a shovelware studio, they make nothing but cash grap low quality otaku shit.
Boku no hero is far from a bad adaptation and it's better then the A1 stuff & there sicking love for puting Yuuki KAJI(voice actor) in everything.
Blackleg-sanji1
Banned
I'll say Amen to this lol
Hey there, the Soma adaption was awesome, and they did Heavy Object as well, which was great too.
Dedication Through Light
Member
World trigger was really good.
Well, for more positive news the anime bump was enough to put My Hero Academia in the Top 10 for the first half of 2016
1 (2). One Piece (Eiichiro Oda, Shueisha) - 6,470,105 (575, 961 down from last year)
2 (3). Assassination Classroom (Yusei Matsui, Shueisha) - 4,391,966 (839,192 down)
3 (4). Attack on Titan (Hajime Isayama, Kodansha) - 4,370,941 (676,784 down)
4 (5). Haikyu!! (Haruichi Furudate, Shueisha) - 4,016,578 (428,212 up)
5 (new). "Kingdom" (Yasuhisa Hara, Shueisha) - 3,561,489
6 (1). The Seven Deadly Sins (Nakaba Suzuki, Kodansha) - 2,712,499 (4,346,901 down)
7 (new). "One-Punch Man" (One/Yusuke Murata, Shueisha) - 2,553,331
8 (new). "Bokudake ga Inai Machi" (Kei Sanbe, Kadokawa) - 2,332,110
9 (6). Tokyo Ghoul: re (Sui Ishida, Shueisha) - 2,179,345 (461,446 down)
10 (new). "My Hero Academia" (Kohei Horikoshi, Shueisha) - 2,135,591
With 8 volumes released, that is not bad at all, I guess we can expect a season 2 for sure.
1 (2). One Piece (Eiichiro Oda, Shueisha) - 6,470,105 (575, 961 down from last year)
2 (3). Assassination Classroom (Yusei Matsui, Shueisha) - 4,391,966 (839,192 down)
3 (4). Attack on Titan (Hajime Isayama, Kodansha) - 4,370,941 (676,784 down)
4 (5). Haikyu!! (Haruichi Furudate, Shueisha) - 4,016,578 (428,212 up)
5 (new). "Kingdom" (Yasuhisa Hara, Shueisha) - 3,561,489
6 (1). The Seven Deadly Sins (Nakaba Suzuki, Kodansha) - 2,712,499 (4,346,901 down)
7 (new). "One-Punch Man" (One/Yusuke Murata, Shueisha) - 2,553,331
8 (new). "Bokudake ga Inai Machi" (Kei Sanbe, Kadokawa) - 2,332,110
9 (6). Tokyo Ghoul: re (Sui Ishida, Shueisha) - 2,179,345 (461,446 down)
10 (new). "My Hero Academia" (Kohei Horikoshi, Shueisha) - 2,135,591
With 8 volumes released, that is not bad at all, I guess we can expect a season 2 for sure.
Boku no hero adaption been pretty good but world trigger manga and it's anime adaption on a different level the series will never reach( afrokatra invasion arc and b rank wars arc is dat Goat ).
Rushersauce
Banned
Wait wait wait... are people finding this adaptation bad? It's pretty fucking good.
It is pretty good, I have no complains to be honest, its adapted almost 1:1 to its source material, the voice cast is perfect, the art direction is neat and bright and the pacing is a bit on the slow side but enjoyable.
The main complaints I concede is that its only 13 episodes, so it stops when it goes from good to great, and the sick art whiplash the manga has when it comes to villains didn't translate to the anime... yet. Next episode will justify if the animation quality is there. Impressive GIFs is what sells a show for newcomers.
I like it.
The problems are that the slow pacing with only 13 episodes throws some off and this latest episodes end was a letdown compared to the manga.
I like it too but the pacing is wonky though but it wouldn't be an issue if it had another season back to back. The music is great and has some good animation. The voices are topnotch too.
Depending on what you mean by this, it can be pretty creepy.
Temeeeeeee...!!!
Jigolo
Member
Yeah the anime isn't that good of an adaptation. The guy draws way better. Bones is doing an OK job at best. Ever since the the previews something about the look just felt off. Maybe it's this:
but I really can't pin in down for sure. But also the comedy in the anime feels different than from the manga in a worse way. Pacing is also slow. 2 chapters per episode would've made it a good pace.
but I really can't pin in down for sure. But also the comedy in the anime feels different than from the manga in a worse way. Pacing is also slow. 2 chapters per episode would've made it a good pace.
The joke timing is borked. Compare the bus scenes, that's probably the most obvious example to me.
foxuzamaki
Doesn't read OPs, especially not his own
Iirc this episode ended at the same point as the manga chapter
It cut an really good (though obvious) line and the impact was muted vs the manga
Dedication Through Light
Member
Planned in a rush? What? They sure are taking their time with the anime.
Jigolo
Member
Long running shounen anime
One Piece: F
Naruto: D
Boku No Hero: C
Attack on Titan: B
Hunter x Hunter 11': A
fix'd
foxuzamaki
Doesn't read OPs, especially not his own
I can agree with that
Grizzlyjin
Supersonic, idiotic, disconnecting, not respecting, who would really ever wanna go and top that
Had some extra time this morning and watched the first episode. Very slow start and nothing about it really grabbed me enough to want to watch more. If I hadn't seen so much praise for manga, I probably wouldn't have given it much of a chance beyond that. I think I might watch a few more episodes just to see if it picks up some speed. But looking around it seems like reading the manga might be the way to go with this series.
You should read the manga, but the anime isn't bad. We're just going through the "second thoughts" phase
I do suggest reading the manga it's so fucking good. And it's at a great part right now.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Will that be when Soul Eater Brotherhood comes out?
Pretty sure there's going to be a Season 2. It's not going to get a Gecko Ending.
brotherhood for everyone.
I still don't understand who thought it was a good idea to make this a 13 episode season.
They must have REALLY been locked in to that timeslot.
AnkiRendan
Member
The real question should be why the hell they greenlit an anime before the first volume was even OUT.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Kaminari fans are the best. a goldmine of captures.
Hey guys let's make an adaptation of this popular shounen jump manga and have it end before it gets really started....lol for maximum blue balls.
First volume came out November 2014. Anime was announced October 2015
It was still early though. Should have waited two years after it started.
AnkiRendan
Member
http://www.crunchyroll.com/anime-ne...obi-vol-16-reveals-rapid-production-schedules
I was referring to this article, sorry about that.
Blackleg-sanji1
Banned
Didn't naruto go thru the same thing and that's why they had a mountain of fillers before part 2
- Status