Fenderputty
Banned
Should I offer to pay for the tow truck?
I don't necessarily think so. It's a nice gesture, but they're mad you didn't put yourself out for them. So make them feel like that won't happen again.
The fake AAA card thing is cheesy (my mom would have loved it though), but something like that IMO would be better.
Is there something around the house they need taken care of. Do that for them