Say you wanted a dress watch in the $2-3k range. Looking for a classy watch with an in house movement. Which of these two would you choose:
Frederique-Constant Slimline Moonphase
Nomos Orion 38mm
Edit -- I love the moonphase on the FC, and the fine Dauphine hands (if that is the term for these). On the downside, it's gotta be a lot harder to dress down, plus resetting the date and moonphase if the watch runs down will be a pain.
As for the Orion, it may be just a touch too clinical/bauhaus for my taste, but is more versatile.
Mmmm, now that's a complicated one.
So, when it comes to the product:
- Movement wise, Nomos does only in-house when FC does a bit of both, but this specific model has the (great) caliber FC-705, which is as in-house as it gets in this price range. Both have a great finish and look great through the case back.
- My gf actually has a vintage watch with an FC strap on it, it's honestly built, but not great (a bit thin, and gets deformed quickly), Nomos straps are just a notch better (but who buys a watch over another for the strap? Nobody right?)
- Case-wise it's really a question of taste, the bevels, overall finish, brush/polish work on the FC may be a bit more subtle but it comes from the fact that it's also a much less modern design.
- Both brand are quite new in the grand scheme of things (founded in the late 80s), but both also proved in their existence that they were faithful to traditional horology and they should be taken seriously
- The Nomos only comes with the small second complication, when the FC embarks a moonphase. I do think it makes the FC dial more interesting, but also much more classic, versus the modern bauhaus design of the Nomos.
So, draw IMHO.
When it comes to context:
Yeah, it's true that the FC is a tad more dressy, and the nomos much more versatile, but at the end of the day, you have your SPM for casual fridays and week ends
And a moonphase is a playful complication, I thought I would never be able to dress down my GO PML, but it actually works pretty well with a shirt/ bluejeans...
Draw again
So, one could just conclude 'go with the one you prefer, they are both great', but let me please explain why I will not:
Yes, the Nomos design is a bauhaus design that basically a lot of manufacturer uses, from Stowa to Rodina, but in my mind, those are just nomos-wanabees
So going for the Nomos, you have what should be considered the 'original' with that style.
And yes, you see me coming, the FC Slim moonphase, while a great piece, is VERY inspired by the JLC MUT Moonphase. A VERY honest homage in terms of quality, but not the original for sure.
So yeah, go for the Nomos, or wait a bit more to save for a JLC MUT moon phase
(and you already have an auto, so you'd need a winder for the FC, when you will be winding your nice Nomos before going to bed
)
Nomos is fantastic, but I have to go with the Moonphase.
The complication is utterly superfluous, but utterly gorgeous.
Given that the human body is 70% water, I tend to disagree: when it's the full moon, I do NOT get surprised at that bunch of drunk guys dancing in the bus nor at the work meetings that will end up in a fight between people who usually like each other
(those are not invented examples
). So yeah, it's gorgeous, but no, sometimes it's useful. (I know it sounds ridiculous).
GS, congrats on the baby, and a very desirable watch. i'm sure your son will love it when he gets it.
Thx mate!