Rodgers at his current age is still a top 3 quarterback. Some would argue he's still the best. I mean, he's just coming off 2 MVP years where he had combined 85 touchdowns to 9 interceptions. So, I don't know what stats you can point to that say Davante Adams is more talented. If we're strictly talking talent, he's probably the best ever at the position.
The bottom line is, you can argue Aaron Rodgers current place among the best QBs in the league, but no matter where he lands on that list, he's going to bring more value to a team than Davante Adams.
What part of, "Rodgers isn't consistent," did you not understand?
Free NFL football player stats and stats leaders in simple, easy to read tables. This page tracks yards per pass thrown statistics.
www.teamrankings.com
Just look through Aaron Rodgers' rankings for yards per pass thrown from 2008 onward:
2008 - Rank 10
2009 - Rank 3
2010 - Rank 2
2011 - Rank 1
2012 - Rank 8
2013 - Rank 2
2014 - Rank 3
2015 - Rank 33
2016 - Rank 14
2017 - Rank 20
2018 - Rank 17
2019 - Rank 16
2020 - Rank 4
2021 - Rank 5
2022 - Rank 11 (ongoing)
Consistency rankings from FF Today.
www.fftoday.com
That shows Rodgers ranked as 8th.
eDraft provides NFL, MLB, NBA & NHL picks for today, daily fantasy advice & tools for FanDuel. Dominate your fantasy football, baseball, basketball & hockey!
edraft.com
That shows Rodgers ranked as 22nd in overall consistency.
Consistency is key in fantasy football, and looking at the most consistent quarterbacks from last year can help us spot potential sleepers and busts in the 2022 rankings. Bob Lung from bigguyfantasysports.com gives us an exclusive look at his QB consistency ratings.
www.sportingnews.com
That shows Rodgers ranked as 10th.
In 2021 and 2022 he managed to get back to his pre-2015 self, but even last year he choked hard against the 49ers resulting in a single touchdown the entire game. Anyone who watched that game could see the myriad of errors that Rodgers made. The 49ers had a great defense, but Rodgers screwed up offensive plays just as often as the defense had great defensive plays.
The difference between Rodgers and Adams is consistency. Davante Adams is consistent, and Aaron Rodgers is so up-and-down. Just look at this season's passing yards per game:
NFL Football passing yards per game, by team.
www.teamrankings.com
The Packers are ranked 21st in passing yards per game. Their two teams were the Vikings with a defense ranked 18, and the Bears with a defense ranked 21. If this was the same Rodgers that played last year he would have wiped the floor with these teams this year. Instead, the Vikings beat the hell out of the Packers, and the Bears got destroyed by Aaron Jones far more than by Aaron Rodgers.