Leafs without a doubt have the wrong core to build around. MLSE is a joke for even bringing back Carlyle and Nonis this season. The game has clearly passed Carlyle by and they are both extensions of Burke. Ties should have been severed ages ago. For the Leafs to truly start moving forward, Carlyle and Nonis both have to go.
Leafs will never win with this core.
You're right. Which is why they're making changes to management now to change the way they get players soon. I doubt (least I hope) there won't be a trade or signing blunder with all these new voices looking at fancy stats advising Nonis.
Nonis and Carlyle will be gone. Nobody lasts forever, and the writing is on the wall, but Shanalytics came in too late last year to do complete sweeping changes. I think he wanted to give them one good chance to redeem themselves and gave them tools to do it (Hunter to help with evaluation, that other dude to help with contracts, Dubas to get the analytics, and Spott to provide emotional support for the players and Horacek to improve the defense). However, I also think should a better candidate become available for either position, he's gonna shoot these two out of a cannon.
It also takes awhile to change the core on the ice.
Kessel would have suitors but I think he has a NTC? He is a star though and tear it up with a star playmaker.
JVR is an excellent trade piece but he's so good that we should keep him at this price.
Kadri still has room to grow, but he could go.
Lupul is getting on the wrong side of his career, so I'd argue he's one we should trade now.
We're stuck with Clarkson til his contract is done. Nobody is taking that off us unless we retain salary.
Phaneuf makes way too much money for what he does to move easily though I think Edmonton could use a guy like him.
Gardiner can be traded due to Percy, and he can fetch a good return but I'm not ready to give up on him yet.
Rielly goes nowhere. Bernier needs to find his game but he stays. The Jets just should have taken Reimer...
So I don't see a clear way out of this mess right now.