the hypocrisy is clear to see for everyone so I am not going to bother with another long explanation.
I've explained each post that you've brought up. Not sure how it's hypocrisy. Seems like you're simply saying that because you can't come up with anything else to say (and are giving up).
you are just dancing around your comments saying you didn't mean this or you didn't mean that.
You took many of those posts out of their context either using them to try and state how I felt the game would help October system sales (when yet I was clearly referring to the Holiday season) or to try and say that I was expecting a 2:1 by bringing up how MGS4 helped PS3 sales and I wasn't -- I simply brought that up since I (at the time) expected the Xbox One to do better than the PS4 during the month Halo released.
i am sure it is sometimes nice to given open ended vague silly predictions like halo 5 will move some consoles or uncharted 4 will sell some consoles!!!! the point is you expected more from halo 5 the game and halo 5 the system seller and neither happened
I did expect a bigger impact from both but I'm not sure what that has to do with what I said about Uncharted 4 helping PS4 sales in March -- that's what started our discussion right?
As I said before, I was referring to the Holiday season as a whole in those posts you dug up from the past (haha). November and December results/stats aren't out yet since the month isn't over.
Halo 5
did help sell systems since it helped the XB1 sell more than the PS4 (NPD), something it rarely does. The same was true for MGS4's launch and the PS3 last gen (vs. 360). So I'm not sure I understand your push for a "gotcha!" moment considering that what I said in that post actually happened.