(NSFW) Oh Eegra how did you know I love CAD hate

McBradders said:
All senses of humour are the same, after all.


Well according to some members here opinion is worthless. Apparently the 360 controller is the best controller ever and that is a fact that cannot be disputed - so surely this would be the same?

In case you or others don't get it i am joking, i don't find PA funny i do know that some people do.
 
5bdb3d2f256b4993f8452a22ddf310d47276db2e.jpg


Premaddona :)
 
CAD really shouldn't have tried to go into that self-pretentious 'deep' shit. Hope the CAD author reads the pisstakes and finally realizes to himself 'hmmm maybe I'll just stick to video game comics instead of trying to prove my own asinine point'.
 
I don't get it, I don't read CAD... is it a web comic about gaming?

Then.. why, why... what?

I don't understand.

Is he going through some stuff in real life or did he just decide to make a gaming comic into a 'drama' suddenly?

Huh?

*gives up confused*
 
Conrad Link said:
I don't get it, I don't read CAD... is it a web comic about gaming?

Then.. why, why... what?

I don't understand.

Is he going through some stuff in real life or did he just decide to make a gaming comic into a 'drama' suddenly?

Huh?

*gives up confused*
Well at one point he was accused of being a pedophile. Or something. I don't know the whole story.

Point is, the art sucks, the humor sucks, the serious sucks. The comic sucks.

mio said:
WTF I almost can't see the drawings, with all those balloons >.<
I have a theory that he hasn't actually drawn anything NEW in forever. It almost looks to me like he takes the same template for the character every time, maybe in a few different poses, and just pastes a different expression on the face.

Sometimes I notice little inconsistencies, but I suspect he does it on purpose to fool people lesser than myself.

Yes, I read the comic.

No, I don't know why.

I think it might be habit.

God.

I hate my life.

EDIT: I saw the "animated series" of CAD once. One episode. Someone I know actually BOUGHT that shit.

Oh god it was terrible.

Multiple.

Lines.

At least VG Cats has a good artist. Even if you don't like the style or the writing, he knows how to draw. This shit? It's just BAD. Ugh.
 
Defuser said:
I rather read my webcomics with game plus insults

0740.png
I post on another forum with the guy who draws this comic, and the original version had Scorpion instead of Sub Zero, and I told him to fix it :lol
 
TheOneGuy said:
From the link from the websites from the heart:

20070718.jpg


20070328.jpg


And this is why PA is good... and CAD is not!

You stole that comparison from Yahtzee
 
NinjaFridge said:
You stole that comparison from Yahtzee
Um... Yes, I did.

Did you follow the link I quoted, or did you just assume I'm an ass who doesn't give credit where it's due?
 
Something happened, and I didn't see the PA comic in the other post.
As soon as I made my post it was there and I was like :O
 
TheOneGuy said:
Um... Yes, I did.

Did you follow the link I quoted, or did you just assume I'm an ass who doesn't give credit where it's due?

You know as well as me that most people reading this won't follow the link just pointing it out
 
NinjaFridge said:
You know as well as me that most people reading this won't follow the link just pointing it out
Maybe...maybe that's why he posed a super-compressed form of Yahtzee's argument in the form of the two similar comics...?
 
I don't see what's the big deal about the CAD storyline to be honest. Although I was quite surprised to see something like that on a webcomic. So what CAD tries to have some sort of storyline.. get over it people.
 
Sqorgar said:
You've heard of it? Neat.
The comics were serviceable, but I enjoyed the articles about "10 quick videogame ideas" or something.

That squidi guy was a fucking drama queen, though.
 
McBacon said:
People pay for a forum that has goatse's URL spammed a million times.

Newsflash: SA has dozens of subforums. That thread is in a branch of the gaming subforum called "Your console sucks". I think what I'm trying to say here is pretty obvious.
 
RocketDarkness said:
Maybe...maybe that's why he posed a super-compressed form of Yahtzee's argument in the form of the two similar comics...?
Yup. O:

sneaky77 said:
I don't see what's the big deal about the CAD storyline to be honest. Although I was quite surprised to see something like that on a webcomic. So what CAD tries to have some sort of storyline.. get over it people.
Well... he's also a bad writer.
 
Ah, was wondering when GAF would find out about this particular comic.
Here are just some of the things people particularly hate about this storyline (and they weren't exactly fans of it beforehand):

1) With a baby on the way, it was a chance for the author to change things up, explore different facets of his characters - but a miscarriage is a giant reset button. More than one person has criticized Buckley for his storytelling style, how he could improve his art, let his characters develop, but none of that has happened. So when the pregnancy storyline hit, his critics predicted that there was no way the baby would actually be born - either it was a dream, or it would be retconned, or they would lose the baby somehow. Because actual growth in the strip is just not its style.

2) On the front page of his website, he wrote a very long news post regarding this comic. Near the end he writes this:
Some many years ago, long before I started the comic, I was in a relationship and we suffered a miscarriage. Now, this relationship was toxic to begin with and doomed to fail regardless, so that the miscarriage was the straw that broke the camel's back came as no surprise. It was a pregnancy neither of us wanted in the first place, so the event didn't effect me nearly as much as it would, say, a couple who was trying for a child. Still, I saw the emotions it can bring up first hand, and I saw how it could truly hurt someone. It's a tough thing to handle because it's nobody's fault. There's nobody you can blame.
Now this is just my opinion, but reading the bolded text above, I think the author of this is a gigantic insensitive douchebag.

3) The final panel is a perfect punchline to all of the people who like to edit his comics.
With one single comic, Buckley has turned his ENTIRE RUN into one big "dead baby" joke.
1212475043599.jpg
 
Man, that Eegra comic is funnier for me because I had a friend procliaming to high heavens how incredible CAD is after that strip.

Time to email him. :lol
 
sneaky77 said:
I don't see what's the big deal about the CAD storyline to be honest. Although I was quite surprised to see something like that on a webcomic. So what CAD tries to have some sort of storyline.. get over it people.

Because this is the comic appeared two weeks before the storyline started.

20080519.jpg


And in two weeks we'll get a parody of whatever new game is out. You can't do a deep storyline when your comic is revolved around one dimensional characters and jokes about games and gamers.
 
Ezduo said:
So, would it have been possible for the doctor to catch this or what?
Only sometimes, as far as I know. I think it just happens spontaneously for the most part.

I'm no doctor, though.
 
Pojo said:
If you find this funny you're a sick shit. That's all.
Oh look another person who doesn't get what the actual joke is.

HINT: It's not making fun of miscarriage.

Find it funny or not, but at least try to understand it before making a comment.
 
going through the archive is making me whince. I never really gave it thought before (mainly since I never bookmarked the comic to begin with, but would occasionally check when a certain gaming blog would show poll results for any particular week of webcomics), but the guy really does suck.

Well, that might be too harsh for someone I've never met.

He's just not good. I mean, seriously, Yahtzee is right.

It was one thing when Fred Gallagher took the reigns of writing Megatokyo, and people asked where the punchline was for the first comic that was nothing but Piro being emo, its another with CAD. I mean, yeah, I get that he's trying to turn the comic into a "comic about gamers" or something now, based on what I managed to glean off of his news rant, but why now? Is it because he realized he sucks at telling jokes? Because he clearly likes to write a lot of text in word bubbles? Is it going to be heavy handed storytelling about the characters now? Characters no one really cares about? The comic's always been written off as a Penny-Arcade rip off, as one of the many rip offs that had sprung off of Penny-Arcade's archaic beginnings. What's sad is that these rip offs still hold onto these crusty pieces of what remains of Penny-Arcade years 1-3. They have absolutely zero growth in art diversity, almost as if time has been frozen.

Or maybe this is expected of webcomics nowadays, for them to just be shit. All of these comics I bookmarked and used to read as a tween are now dull and pointless, and I now find these new gems in the massive payload of dirt that is the internet, such as xkcd, perry bible fellowship, bee power, castle vidcons, and eegra.

Its a new age of webcomics, and there is no country for old men (with the exception of Penny-Arcade and Megatokyo, I suppose)
 
OP comic was dumb, though I did like the upside-down mouth.

I'll be perfectly honest - I don't care much for Buckley as a person, but I thought the original comic was fairly good. People go into webcomics expecting funny, and when the author decides to do something of a more serious nature, they get blasted for it. In fact, when Jim Davis was a couple years into writing Garfield, he wrote a disturbing comic for his Halloween strip, and people complained about it because they thought it was too depressing. So now every strip amounts to "Garfield likes lasagna and hates Mondays."

Ctrl Alt Del sucks but that strip in particular I liked (as well as the photoshops).
 
Top Bottom