Impressions upon playing the 360 at my neighbors last night:
First game on the docket was PGR3, which is undeniably gorgeous, but damn it all if I cannot stand how the game controls. I of course wasn't able to get
that in-depth with it, but I was blown away at how identical it was to PGR2. The handling of the cars was near identical, with little to no further refinement, albeit it feels like they've stripped back a tiny bit of the arcadey-ness (which just furthers my distaste of the game). It never decides which type of game it wants to be, and resides in this awkward no-man's-land that tries to be both Burnout and Gran Turismo at once (to a degree), and fails at both. My neighbor doesn't have Live, so I couldn't try out the online stuff (this is why I feel reviewers need to judge games seperately on whether or not you can/will play online). I'm sure the multiplayer stuff is quite good though.
My impressions on the 360 so far were mixed, but I really tried to not let my pessimism take over. The next two games I tried didn't help though;
at all. They were Madden and NBA Live. Call me high maintenance, but if this is next gen, then I pray EA goes bankrupt. I just came off PGR3, and ten minutes into each of these two I was simply shaking my head. Both games look fairly solid (though the animations don't fit with the crisper visuals), but the disappointment was immediately apparent. Madden 360 simply didn't impress me on the same level that NFL 2k or Madden 2001 did way back when. I ended up only playing these two, combined, for about 30 minutes of the 7 and a half hours or so (!! I know) I was over there. Admittedly I'm not a sports gamer though, so I concede my opinion here is of little worth.
The next game made me eat a nice handful of crow. Call of Duty 2. I've been hard on the game over the past week or so ever since I was ridiculously disappointed at the kiosk demo, but I must say I enjoyed it quite a bit. It ain't gorgeous, high-end PC at best, but some of the effects are real nice (the smoke is sex), and the atmosphere is great as usual in WWII games done right. I still don't think it deserves the scores it's been getting, because at the end of the day it really is just another WWII shooter with little new to offer, but it is fun, and is a solid launch title.
Next up was Kameo (Rare lovers steer clear), and it was probably the most underwhelming title I tried. My neighbor had specifically rented it for that night for the both of us, and I'm pretty sure he was glad it was just a rental. The awful controls jumped out initially, because I didn't remember them being this bad on the kiosk demo. The visuals are certainly nice, but are woefully inconsistent. Some sections look oh-so-wonderful, even absurdly brilliant at times, but others look straight up shameful. In the end though, none of that mattered as much as the disappointing gameplay. It was surprisingly simplistic, and barely meets the standards of this gen, let alone next. It's obvious this game is a byproduct of current gen development; problem is it never should have been upped to the 360 IMO.
Next up was the best game of the bunch, and my pick for best launch title, in Ridge Racer 6. To me (a non-hardcore but decent Ridge fan) 6 feels almost exactly like the PSP version I adore, and it is ridiculously and wickedly smooth. Like silk I'm telling ya's! I played for probably close to 2 hours, getting some good time in the faster class 3 and 4 cars (as Bebpo encouraged me to do in another thread). I can understand why the game isn't seeing the greatest reviews though, as it doesn't seem to evolve much beyond the PSP version. If Namco can deliver a Ridge Racer 6 Ultimate or whatever at the PS3 launch, I will be in heaven. Everyone who bought a 360 needs to get this game.
Last up was PDZ, which I'm not going to say much about because I hated it and it's the last game I'm talking about (don't want to take away from the games I enjoyed). Again, no Live meant no online, but the singleplayer portion of this game is barely a 5-6/10 IMO. I got up to the 4th level I think, and by then it was getting quite late, and I was sick of the game. The visuals are very nice in a technical sense, but are far too shiny and completely devoid of personality. The controls are meh, the A.I is at best barely passable and at worst pathetically stupid (I cannot believe the reviews didn't mention this!!), and the level design is uninspired and hastily thrown together. No more on that.
Overall, I'm not going to snag a system for myself just yet, but I did come away more impressed than I thought I'd be, mostly due to both CoD2 and, especially, RR6. I wouldn't call the others bad (well, actually, Kameo and PDZ are pretty damn underwhelming), it's just I don't see how anyone can justify playing those over the upteen amount of other games released this Fall that are so much damn better. Bottom line, I'll be over at my neighbor's house another 3-4 times this week for some more RR6 loving I'm sure. I guess it just depends whether or not he's there to let me in, or whether I'll have to, you know, break in myself.
Yeah.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1c4fb/1c4fb4a004ac374ae735c210f8560be0dce354ac" alt="Big grin :D :D"