Support NeoGAF

[Abstrusity]

when I say dickgirl I'm not referring to trans, just futa. that's literally what futa is, girls with dicks. while trans encompasses so much more than that.





I don't have a furry fetish so I can't say I ever thought of it that way. But my initial reasoning for putting them that high up was based on how common/accepted the particular fetish is. Perhaps I'm underestimating how normalized furry as a fetish is.

It's so "rare" as it were, because of how communities tend to push people out when they don't act according to how the community appears to be. An entire term was coined for it -- "fursecution." A portmanteau of "fur" and "persecution." A number of sites cropped up because of this phenomenon. Having won that particular "war," people continually kinkshamed others, leading to further isolation from the fetish world at large.

I wouldn't say it's particularly common, but it's certainly not rare. The rarity comes from furries that wear costumes according to their "fursonas" (another portmanteau, "fur" and "persona").

It's not my fetish, either, but I came across all sorts of things trying to figure out EXACTLY what I WAS.

 

[jroc74]

Oh shit. I didn't see that scale before I posted. lol.

For rape I do have fantasies about being raped by a woman or women. Tied up n raped. No pegging tho, fuck that.

 

[Goro Majima]

So what would a pregnancy risk fetish rate as?

Wikipedia says it's not even a fetish since we're all built with that in mind. On the other hand, I always feel horribly embarrassed talking about it like it's an 11 out of 10.

 

[Wild Card]

When people say rape fetish what are they referring to exactly, like they have a fetish of actual rape, as in real world rape stories? (Which is awful) I don't imagine that's what people are referring to. Like what is the difference, If I read a story that has the premise of a real rape vs. one of a husband a wife roleplaying, is there a substantial difference, is one more malicious, or would they both be regarded the same becuase all of it is fictional. Also when I look at yaoi why is so much of it anthro stuff? Or perhaps I should say alot of anthro stuff I run into is yaoi (Mostly be western artists).

 

[NoblesseOblige]

So what would a pregnancy risk fetish rate as?

Wikipedia says it's not even a fetish since we're all built with that in mind. On the other hand, I always feel horribly embarrassed talking about it like it's an 11 out of 10.

I think 'breeding' is what that fetish is called.

 

[FStubbs]

You entered a "weird fetish" thread, what did you expect to read about?

feet, belly buttons, ears, boobs, that sort of thing.

 

[Wild Card]

I think 'breeding' is what that fetish is called.

Isn't breeding more like women being used to pump out babies? Pregancy risk just sounds like having a lot of sex without birth control or condoms.

EDIT: Also I asked this earlier but is there really any difference between a foot fetish and an armpit fetish?

 

[CreepingFear]

I think 3 or 4, maybe less. Mine is fairly popular and common in pop culture.

 

[The_Kid]

Probably a 6.

Spoiler

For example my 600 dollars worth of leather pup gear came in the mail today.

Oh, saw the scale. 8.

 

[How About No]

Mostly fake but realistic. Like Niku Daruma or August Underground.

I have seen real stuff too

Spoiler

(Luka Magnotta videos)

since i'm a gorehound and check shock sites every now and then. For me all that stuff is morbid curiosity and fascination with gore and death but i know some people get on with such things. So it's a definite 10.

That's quite the NOPE you have there

Be a shame if someone ran away from it screaming

 

[Abstrusity]

When people say rape fetish what are they referring to exactly, like they have a fetish of actual rape, as in real world rape stories? (Which is awful) I don't imagine that's what people are referring to. Like what is the difference, If I read a story that has the premise of a real rape vs. one of a husband a wife roleplaying, is there a substantial difference, is one more malicious, or would they both be regarded the same becuase all of it is fictional. Also when I look at yaoi why is so much of it anthro stuff? Or perhaps I should say alot of anthro stuff I run into is yaoi (Mostly be western artists).

Generally, it's intent that makes the difference in fetishism. Rape is a terrible, forceful act (force not necessarily defined as PHYSICAL force), but if the partners consent to play a scenario including it, then its severity is lessened -- at that point, it's NOT rape, it's the FANTASY of rape.

But, if one partner doesn't consent, then it becomes rape, the crime. Even if it satisfies a fantasy. Only yes means yes.

Commonly, these sorts of scenarios (the same with BDSM scenarios) are capped off by copious amounts of after care.

 

[Mr.Galahad]

When I was about 6 or 7 I had my first erection while watching a magician saw a woman in half believing it was real and since then my fetishes only got more extreme.

I am probably a 9 now lol.

Funny thing is that I had a fetish before I knew what a fetish was.

 

[jackal27]

You entered a "weird fetish" thread, what did you expect to read about?

Haha, good point. I just went deeper than I meant to. Also, originally that post just said "rape" without the added bit about consent so that threw me for a loop.

Also, I'd say we're still at a 3. Nothing mentioned about sub/dom play though? Or is that what was mean to by light BDSM? Also, some things on that scale seem wacky to me.

 

[Moff]

1 - missionary vanilla sex with hand holding
2 - sex toys in the bedroom, food in the bedroom
3 - light BDSM
4 - swinging, cuckoldry, exhibitionism
5 - BDSM, pegging, rimming
6 - tentacles, watersports
7 - rape (the fetish, not the crime. consent is present)
8 - furry, anthro, dickgirls
9 - scat, vomit, beastiality
10 - pedophilia, gore, dismemberment, necrophilia, crushing

rape fantasies are far too common to make them a 7, I'd put that under light bdsm

 

[Frozenprince]

I'm a 9.

Edit; Maybe I'm a 10. None of you have even mentioned blood stuff.

Ahem

Blood stuff best stuff.

 

[jackal27]

rape fantasies are far too common to make them a 7, I'd put that under light bdsm

No way. We like the rough stuff, but rape play definitely feels like another world.

 

[metalslimer]

I don't really see how rimming is a 5

Assplay in general is pretty much a 2 at this point

 

[Abstrusity]

No way. We like the rough stuff, but rape play definitely feels like another world.

Which is why I think we should use MY scale, that puts anything above light slapping, play slapping, etc., especially when nonconsensual, above 5.

 

[PreyingShark]

1 - missionary vanilla sex with hand holding
2 - sex toys in the bedroom, food in the bedroom
3 - light BDSM
4 - swinging, cuckoldry, exhibitionism
5 - BDSM, pegging, rimming
6 - tentacles, watersports
7 - rape (the fetish, not the crime. consent is present)
8 - furry, anthro, dickgirls
9 - scat, vomit, beastiality
10 - pedophilia, gore, dismemberment, necrophilia, crushing

I don't consider any of this close to a 10 tbh

 

[Wild Card]

Where does vore rank, that stuff can be pretty out there. Also some of the medling or merging stuff too, get's real odd.

 

[jackal27]

I don't really see how rimming is a 5

Assplay in general is pretty much a 2 at this point

It's so odd to me how common that stuff has gotten recently. Not saying it's positive or negative. Just kind of odd. Why now all of a sudden?

 

[DOWN]

I don't have any

1

 

[nkarafo]

I don't consider any of this close to a 10 tbh

Ok you got my attention.

What would you consider a 10?

 

[Abstrusity]

Where does vore rank, that stuff can be pretty out there. Also some of the medling or merging stuff too, get's real odd.

Soft, 8, hard, 10.

 

[DOWN]

I don't consider any of this close to a 10 tbh

Ok but I think that list is a good idea of how society at large would rank those things

What do you consider a 10???

 

[BaronMonstro]

I don't understand why anyone would stick any part of their body into where shit comes out of.

Is it that much better than classic coke or what.

If you couldn't tell from above I'm a 1.

 

[Mr.Galahad]

I don't consider any of this close to a 10 tbh

So you thing there are things worse than snuff/gore and pedophilia?

 

[Permanently A]

I don't consider any of this close to a 10 tbh

you're gonna have to explain what could be worse than crushing

 

[Goro Majima]

I think 'breeding' is what that fetish is called.

Eh I usually associate "breeding" as intersecting with interracial cuckold stuff.

Isn't breeding more like women being used to pump out babies? Pregancy risk just sounds like having a lot of sex without birth control or condoms.

Yeah it's just the thrill of the pregnancy risk itself without all the other semi-racist cuckold stuff tacked on.

Regardless, I have no idea how to rank that from 1-10.

 

[supernormal]

1 - missionary vanilla sex with hand holding
2 - sex toys in the bedroom, food in the bedroom
3 - light BDSM
4 - swinging, cuckoldry, exhibitionism
5 - BDSM, pegging, rimming
6 - tentacles, watersports
7 - rape (the fetish, not the crime. consent is present)
8 - furry, anthro, dickgirls
9 - scat, vomit, beastiality
10 - pedophilia, gore, dismemberment, necrophilia, crushing

Hmm. There's enough range between 1-10 so that there's levels for everything in between, so that's good. I would make rimming lower, to let's say whatever is one spot over regular oral. Also scat, and vomit shouldn't go with bestiality since there's a level of consent in the first two that is not present in the third. Either lower those 2 or put the third one with all that other illegal shit in 10.

 

[KillerBEA]

you're gonna have to explain what could be worse than crushing

Vore

 

[nkarafo]

Vore

Problem is that crushing involves real living things.

 

[NoblesseOblige]

Vore

Vore is usually depicted in such a nonsensical way that I have too hard a time not wanting to laugh at how stupid it is to rank it a 10.

It's especially silly when you get into 'anal vore' and 'dick vore'.

 

[KillerBEA]

Problem is that crushing involves real living things.

Hard vore can be enacted through Cannibalistic acts

Vore is usually depicted in such a nonsensical way that I have too hard a time not wanting to laugh at how stupid it is to rank it a 10.

It's especially silly when you get into 'anal vore' and 'dick vore'.

Don't forget boob vore

 

[Mr.Galahad]

Vore is usually depicted in such a nonsensical way that I have too hard a time not wanting to laugh at how stupid it is to rank it a 10.

It's especially stupid when you get into 'anal vore' and 'dick vore'.

Isn't extreme vore basically a suicide fetish? Pretty fucked for me.

 

[Wild Card]

Eh I usually associate "breeding" as intersecting with interracial cuckold stuff.



Yeah it's just the thrill of the pregnancy risk itself without all the other semi-racist cuckold stuff tacked on.

Regardless, I have no idea how to rank that from 1-10.

I'd wager a 3, as long as it's basically just vanilla sex, the act of the risk doesn't really seem to far and away from like public sex, perhaps with more risk, but if those are the only factors I wouldn't rank it too high.

 

[ClutchAnderson]

One hunnid/10...weird doesn't even begin to describe it ya heard? lol

 

[NoblesseOblige]

Isn't extreme vore basically a suicide fetish? Pretty fucked for me.

Yeah, that's 'hard vore' or 'realistic vore', but like 90% of 'vore' is just the depiction of things being swallowed whole, and then living inside the stomach/rectum/penis/sac of the consumer. And that's so far beyond crazytown that I have a hard time seeing it as anything other than a joke.

 

[Wild Card]

Vore

Most of that stuff I've run into has been pretty tame, visually at least, of course the implication of vore can often be death, being eaten whole, absorbed, but most of what I've seen doesn't really depict the end result of that stuff usually, unlike gore things which are by their nature quite explicit.

 

[OniBarubary]

Well I did make this thread, so...

...like a 7?

 

[nkarafo]

Hard vore can be enacted through Cannibalistic acts

That could be just cannibalism. Which i agree is a 10 as it's similar with dismemberment, gore, snuff and anything else that includes murder.

 

[Naudi]

As weird as my wife let's me get lol. Every passing year it gets better. Not really weird stuff though I guess, just super porno ish. If that makes sense.

 

[Wild Card]

What about asphyxiation? That's at least a 5 right?

 

[Abstrusity]

Most of that stuff I've run into has been pretty tame, visually at least, of course the implication of vore can often be death, being eaten whole, absorbed, but most of what I've seen doesn't really depict the end result of that stuff usually, unlike gore things which are by their nature quite explicit.

Right. That's the difference between soft and hard vore. One's implicit, the other, explicit. Of course, other times it could be more fantastical, but then, what isn't, in most porn?

 

[Frozenprince]

Vore is usually depicted in such a nonsensical way that I have too hard a time not wanting to laugh at how stupid it is to rank it a 10.

It's especially silly when you get into 'anal vore' and 'dick vore'.

I don't and never will get how people think it's a sexual thing. It's just weird.

 

[nkarafo]

As weird as my wife let's me get lol. Every passing year it gets better. Not really weird stuff though I guess, just super porno ish. If that makes sense.

If it can be shown on youporn it's below 6.

 

[Goro Majima]

I'd wager a 3, as long as it's basically just vanilla sex, the act of the risk doesn't really seem to far and away from like public sex, perhaps with more risk, but if those are the only factors I wouldn't rank it too high.

Yeah that sounds about right.

Just wasn't sure if it warranted a 6 or 7 since there literally can't be a less sexy fetish to have for some people where having kids is the scariest thing ever (even though it's usually just roleplay and dirty talk).

 

[Mr.Galahad]

Yeah, that's 'hard vore' or 'realistic vore', but like 90% of 'vore' is just the depiction of things being swallowed whole, and then living inside the stomach/rectum/penis/sac of the consumer. And that's so far beyond crazytown that I have a hard time seeing it as anything other than a joke.

Yeah, compared to some stuff with real cruelty like crushing and snuff, it's pretty abstract and non tangible. I think hanging and drowning are some of the more common suicidal fetishes.

 

[DarthWoo]

I'd say probably 8-9. Some of the things I'm into might qualify as a 10, but there are still other things that still gross me out, so I believe that would drive my overall score back down a little bit.

 

[KillerBEA]

Isn't extreme vore basically a suicide fetish? Pretty fucked for me.

I would assume there are people who prefer being the predator rather than the prey.

Yeah, that's 'hard vore' or 'realistic vore', but like 90% of 'vore' is just the depiction of things being swallowed whole, and then living inside the stomach/rectum/penis/sac of the consumer. And that's so far beyond crazytown that I have a hard time seeing it as anything other than a joke.

I have seen more digestion stuff than anything else.

Most of that stuff I've run into has been pretty tame, visually at least, of course the implication of vore can often be death, being eaten whole, absorbed, but most of what I've seen doesn't really depict the end result of that stuff usually, unlike gore things which are by their nature quite explicit.

I agree a lot of it can be pretty tame and childish almost, but I have seen some pretty fucked up vore pieces.