-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Overwatch Mafia |OT| Keep Your Vote On The Payload
- Thread starter Sorian
- Start date
We can't all be right all the time, doctor.
it's not lupus though, can we agree on that?
Tough call. Of course my first reaction would be to hear the person out and him/her speak up about the role and give us more infos before lifting the vote.
Thats the thing though. it will be a tough call either way. Thats why i liked this post of yours.
I'm against a Mazre lynch for now. I still feel he is Town.
Xamtheking
Member
I think we might need to cross that bridge when we get there
I'd be ok with lynching someone who claims doc
You linked Kyan and Barry, would you consider dear Kyan for today's lynch?
melonrabbit
Member
I'm shocked there is a Mazre lynch. At all.
1- mostly because is still day one and because I wouldn't like to get a roleclaim out of fear.
2- I called out Barry, ezekel, nin and theg before going to bed yesterday. Barry, ezekel and nin gave some thoughts about the game. TheG didn't. He had nothing to work with but bad posted.
3. I'AM willing to make a sacrifice for the greater good in the first day. We have nothing to work with right now and we don't know if the kills will give us something. I think getting info on Stanley could give us some (if he is scum).
4- Not defensive, but I have been posting all morning so...
I liked Sophia post's the first day but she seems abscent lately. It doesn't mean anything, it maybe be only RL so I'm willing to wait for a bit to see if she could give some more thoughts. I would vote for her now.
It does surprise me, especially because of the three votes on it I'm not particularly strong town reading them. Stanley most, but even that's not super strong.
I need to re-check the circumstances of votes, including Bronx's unvote.
He's still "null" for me right now, but tbh I do want to see what he flips for possible linkage to Barry.
as a prod or day end result?
Xamtheking
Member
it's a common problem, apparently
Certainly not a prod I'd hope, seeing as I'm here now and will be until day end.
neither option is good, given what was said.
A couple or hours before day's end. She is posting now but I would like if she didn't cast a vote before day's end.
The same can be said for all of you.
Xamtheking
Member
Yes, I do
Why, exactly? Because of that wishful thinking post? Nothing has lodged your thoughts or made you change your read on him?
melonrabbit
Member
I'll vote when I feel like it mom!
why would we ruin our perfect system of screwing around until 30 minutes before deadline?
Wouldn't like.
Xamtheking
Member
Yeah, that made absolutely no sense to me and still doesn't
Seems like a scum mispost and then tried to backtrack but couldn't without giving himself away
why ? i mean he vanished into the abyss.
VOTE: Xamtheking
Of the other candidates, I'm not feeling a Zeke, Bronx or Stan lynch.
I'm pretty much null on Mazre and AB, null enough to not be against lynching them. You could maybe add Barry to this as well.
Nin I was townreading earlier, but now I'm less sure.
Ty I haven't changed opinion on (still lean scum) but it's not strong enough for a D1 lynch. Also still uneasy about Burb although that's even weaker.
Ouro... I like his posts, but then I dont like his lynch targets. We were both on Ty for a bit, but Ouro seemed much more keen on actually lynching him. He's now on Verelios which I definitely disagree with.
I wrote most of this a couple of hours ago, now I see Fran becoming a potential lynch target? Not down with that at all, he's one of my clearest town reads. I think he's barking up the wrong tree with his "peeking is a grand scum conspiracy" stuff but it's an argument I've seen before, so not scummy. The rest of his stuff reads as town to me.
Of the other candidates, I'm not feeling a Zeke, Bronx or Stan lynch.
I'm pretty much null on Mazre and AB, null enough to not be against lynching them. You could maybe add Barry to this as well.
Nin I was townreading earlier, but now I'm less sure.
Ty I haven't changed opinion on (still lean scum) but it's not strong enough for a D1 lynch. Also still uneasy about Burb although that's even weaker.
Ouro... I like his posts, but then I dont like his lynch targets. We were both on Ty for a bit, but Ouro seemed much more keen on actually lynching him. He's now on Verelios which I definitely disagree with.
I wrote most of this a couple of hours ago, now I see Fran becoming a potential lynch target? Not down with that at all, he's one of my clearest town reads. I think he's barking up the wrong tree with his "peeking is a grand scum conspiracy" stuff but it's an argument I've seen before, so not scummy. The rest of his stuff reads as town to me.
Most of the suspicion I've seen has compared him to his previous game, but to me he seems the same here as he did then. Abrasive and sometimes sneaky, has his own opinions rather than trying to go along with the crowd.
After you first called him out I remember him asking someone else about you. That specifically gave me deja vu, he gets suspicious of people who accuse him, and asking someone else's opinion seems like a reasonable way of wondering "is it just me or is there something else here"
melonrabbit
Member
There doesn't seem to be much there either way.
Actually... I just looked at the votes on Fran and...
Hey Ezekel, the hell you trying to pull with the bait and switch here? Voting for two people in the same post?
I don't really see a lynch forming on him beyond that tho.
Yeah of these two opinions, I'm more inclined to agree with nin. Mazre is null to me, but for inactivity alone I'm not surprised to see him gaining votes.
Well not just votes but the direction of the conversation. Fran is getting mentions, most of them negative.Actually... I just looked at the votes on Fran and...
Hey Ezekel, the hell you trying to pull with the bait and switch here? Voting for two people in the same post?
I don't really see a lynch forming on him beyond that tho.
Read this to yourself again Ynnek.
The only difference here is that there are no ordinaries, which means PRs are weakened in their stature because there are so many of them. So then move onto what you describe. Possibly two town dead, maybe more than that on Day 2 start.
You could sub any game of Mafia in there aside from pure vanilla ones, it's not a unique situation. You shouldn't be afraid of hitting a power role in a game that is all power roles.
VOTE: Ynnek7
My lynch list is still pretty large, you'll do for now.
Still hoping WAMD checks in before day end though.
Hmm.... can't say I see it? Except for Ezekel. Mind pointing some examples out?
One thing that bothers me about Ezekel is how quickly he went from this
To voting for him.
That was only a timeframe of like six hours at best. :\
He's on my list. I'd like to see one of them go - I don't have an order. But I'll go where my vote will matter.
Why is he on your list?
Vote Count:
Mazre (3)
Xamtheking
Bronx-Man
Haly
StanleyPalmetree
EzekelRAGE (2)
Barrylocke
Ouro
Barrylocke (1)
Ouro
Ty4on
melonrabbit (1)
Mazre
AbsolutBro (1)
Burbeting
EzekelRAGE
StanleyPalmtree (1)
franconp
franconp (1)
EzekelRAGE
Xamtheking (1)
*Splinter
Ynnek7 (1)
cabot
cabot
WhereAreMahDragonz (0)
cabot
Ty4on (0)
Mazre
*Splinter
Ouro
Verelios (0)
Ouro
cabot
Ouro
Kyanrute (0)
Burbeting
*Splinter (0)
nin1000
nin1000 (0)
Haly
melonrabbit
Haly (0)
Ty4on
cabot
Kingkitty (0)
cabot
franconp
12 votes needed for majority
Mazre (3)
Xamtheking
Haly
StanleyPalmetree
EzekelRAGE (2)
Barrylocke
Ouro
Barrylocke (1)
Ty4on
melonrabbit (1)
Mazre
AbsolutBro (1)
Burbeting
StanleyPalmtree (1)
franconp
franconp (1)
EzekelRAGE
Xamtheking (1)
*Splinter
Ynnek7 (1)
cabot
WhereAreMahDragonz (0)
Ty4on (0)
Verelios (0)
Kyanrute (0)
*Splinter (0)
nin1000 (0)
Haly (0)
Kingkitty (0)
12 votes needed for majority
I'm not going through this again. Scroll back.
AbsolutBro
Member
Reread, but honestly not sure how much good it did. I'm getting lost in the "peek vs no peek" and "claim vs no claim" posts and missing the conversation links between posters. I've tried a couple times to get a reads list going but it just won't coalesce in my brain. So I'm going to ramble a bit more.
I probably would have drifted towards a TheGoddamn vote, but with him bowing out that doesn't really hold shape anymore. EzekelRage still trying to build a working peek strategy just feels off though.
Ouro and Cabot are discussion leaders, and while it wouldn't be a first for scum to take discussion leads, I do not really get a scum vibe from either of them just yet. Ty4on is up there as well I suppose, but I honestly blur his and melonrabbit's posts together because for whatever reason their avatars blur together for me. It's weird. Honestly not sure which is pulling the other down.
I got Sophia as my role in Gafia 2, but I do not believe we have ever actually played a game together. Leaning town at this point; scanning over her posts I like her drive to lynch for "scum" not "not-town". If that makes sense.
Mazre is a tough one for me, since I think I'm still being negatively biased against his posts from DR. I actually do agree that we probably lack a cop. I have no real evidence for my agreement, but my gut says that with this many roles in play a cop would be "too normal".
Separately, I also don't think we have a regular motion detector, since with everyone having a role "so and so moved" is close to meaningless. A tracker (so and so targeted so and so) makes more sense if that kind of role is in play.
WAMD started off feeling sketchy to me. Early posts are kind of empty (Hi pot, I'm kettle, nice to meet you!). That said, she was against both the peek and the mass claim, so there's that I guess.
Stanley is, sadly, no longer a rootinest tootinest crazy old man persona. Also, even one of his more recent posts wants to dredge peeking back up, which I do not see a reason for. (the dredge, not the strat. well, not the strat either) Not great feelings here.
Barry is Barry.
*Splinter I struggle with also, because DR is the standout game we both played and I try not to judge off DR. It was a fun game, but man. That said scanning over a search of his posts doesn't give me much either way. A couple are pretty on point (noticing Ouro's Tracer/Tracker post, which generated basically 0 discussion otherwise), while other seem to basically ride cabot's posttails. I realize he and cabot have a history though, so I try to ignore those.
going to post and take a break. my eyes are starting to hurt. just in case:
vote: EzekelRAGE
I have said several times that I suspect a scum players to be hiding in the peek or mass claim defenders. Peek being the more likely for reasons I said elsewhere, that's what I looked at. That's where my vote goes for now.
I need some aspirin.
I probably would have drifted towards a TheGoddamn vote, but with him bowing out that doesn't really hold shape anymore. EzekelRage still trying to build a working peek strategy just feels off though.
Ouro and Cabot are discussion leaders, and while it wouldn't be a first for scum to take discussion leads, I do not really get a scum vibe from either of them just yet. Ty4on is up there as well I suppose, but I honestly blur his and melonrabbit's posts together because for whatever reason their avatars blur together for me. It's weird. Honestly not sure which is pulling the other down.
I got Sophia as my role in Gafia 2, but I do not believe we have ever actually played a game together. Leaning town at this point; scanning over her posts I like her drive to lynch for "scum" not "not-town". If that makes sense.
Mazre is a tough one for me, since I think I'm still being negatively biased against his posts from DR.
I actually do agree that we probably lack a cop. I have no real evidence for my agreement, but my gut says that with this many roles in play a cop would be "too normal".Separately, I also don't think we have a regular motion detector, since with everyone having a role "so and so moved" is close to meaningless. A tracker (so and so targeted so and so) makes more sense if that kind of role is in play.
WAMD started off feeling sketchy to me. Early posts are kind of empty (Hi pot, I'm kettle, nice to meet you!). That said, she was against both the peek and the mass claim, so there's that I guess.
Stanley is, sadly, no longer a rootinest tootinest crazy old man persona. Also, even one of his more recent posts wants to dredge peeking back up, which I do not see a reason for. (the dredge, not the strat. well, not the strat either) Not great feelings here.
Barry is Barry.
*Splinter I struggle with also, because DR is the standout game we both played and I try not to judge off DR. It was a fun game, but man. That said scanning over a search of his posts doesn't give me much either way. A couple are pretty on point (noticing Ouro's Tracer/Tracker post, which generated basically 0 discussion otherwise), while other seem to basically ride cabot's posttails. I realize he and cabot have a history though, so I try to ignore those.
going to post and take a break. my eyes are starting to hurt. just in case:
vote: EzekelRAGE
I have said several times that I suspect a scum players to be hiding in the peek or mass claim defenders. Peek being the more likely for reasons I said elsewhere, that's what I looked at. That's where my vote goes for now.
I need some aspirin.
@Sophia
There was melon as well:
This conversation went for a bit, with Zeke's vote somewhere in the middle.
Ty4on also asked (someone) about Fran which isn't explicitly negative but definitely keeps him in the conversation.
It's just a possibility, with so many people on 1 vote it doesn't take much for anyone to become a lynch candidate.
There was melon as well:
This conversation went for a bit, with Zeke's vote somewhere in the middle.
Ty4on also asked (someone) about Fran which isn't explicitly negative but definitely keeps him in the conversation.
It's just a possibility, with so many people on 1 vote it doesn't take much for anyone to become a lynch candidate.
Allow me to assist you, because I was already checking your posts.
I think I got everything, but I'm not... quote convinced? Just the way it flows from Ezekel being a "late bloomer if he's town" to suddenly voting for him doesn't sit right with me, Ouro. :\
You also have fairly few posts on him too...
Understandable. He's probably tied with Burb as my "least likely to be scum" out of that list. I've said that I'd rather go for Verelios or Ty, but if that's not going to happen today I'll move down the list.
He's right tho