Town
Natiko
Flat Earth Panda
Hyperactivity
WhereAreMahDragonz
Plop
Slight Town
Starsketch
Pkgaming
Verelios
Franconp
Null
11037
Zippedinhead
Slight scum
II-Vanguard-II
Scum
Exmachine64
Matt Attack
Okay so i thought about this a bit over night.
-Everything he has said has been fluff and questions. From day 1 till now have you ever seen him post a reads list or any in depth comments about fellow players no he keeps it really light.
-Was one of the first to unvote Style as soon as he roleclaimed yet does not want to give Starsketch this same chance while she really has not had many scum tells.
-Didn't even defend himself on day 1, like it was already determined who would take the fall and surprise it was the guy with no power, meanwhile Style and Ex live to see another day.
My theory
3 scums messed up on day 1 and immediately called suspicion on themselves
Exmachina
Exodus
Style
With Style roleclaiming there was no option for either Ex or Exo to do the same. So Exo took the fall with the added bonus of Exmachina getting big town vibes just for getting voted on by Exodus.
I keep it light because Exodus almost got me lynched and I'm town. We've seen the most active users be killed each night phase and I worry that if I do even an adequate job, I'll get killed during the night. Keeping to myself and trying to be inactive helps that, however, that does make it easier to be read the way you're reading it.
I wanted to take the pressure off Style so he would feel more at ease and hopefully trip up. No one from the remaining players has had many scum tells, but we either have to make a guess from gut feelings or not lynch anyone today -- an inactive PR is an unfortunate casualty, but I'd rather do that than lynch a town that's contributing more.
I didn't bother defending myself on Day 1 because I thought I was going to be lynched. That may not sound like the strongest justification to all of you, but this is only the second time I've played Mafia with GAF. The first time I got lynched on Day 1 because I made a stupid comment. I went hard against Exodus because of a gut feeling and I initially thought Sophia's end-of-day post was that he was an innocent Persona user. I didn't know I should focus on the role message instead of the flavor text. So I spent the entire first night phase thinking I had fucked up and I was going to get turboed on Day 2. The scum have killed our strongest players, so I'm just worried about fucking everything up again.
I doubt any of this will convince you since I'm confirmed scum in your mind, but you also considered Vanguard likely scum.
Anyway, since you want a list of reads:
My strongest reads currently are BlackBuzzard, StarSketch, and PK.
BlackBuzzard: He's trying to bus me with this weird conspiracy theory that I willingly (gleefully?) went rogue and helped lynch two scum. He's been strongly pushing me as scum since Day 1, I'll go back through his post history and try to link appropriate posts if I survive to Day 4.
StarSketch: I think most of us aren't comfortable with the idea that she sacrificed using her power on the first and second nights and could have helped steer us toward scum. She wanted to preserve her own life, perhaps at the cost of a town victory. I don't want to be overly suspicious of her, but most of the players aren't really active and with no one talking and providing info from night phases, we're just getting nowhere.
PK: I've suspected him since Day 1. His posts mainly consist of a quip and a meme/gif. I don't think he's a PR. We know he's watching the thread, but trying to be as inactive as he can. Besides that, he keeps trying to divert suspicion away from my other suspects.
If I'm killed during the night, town should focus on StarSketch and BlackBuzzard.
Star, you might be town, but you really need to produce some info for the next day phase.
