-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Phil Spencer Confident in Decision to Delay Starfield
- Thread starter Lunatic_Gamer
- Start date
- News Business
Punished Miku
Human Rights Subscription Service
I don't see it scoring a 94. Skyrim was a long time ago. A completely different gaming landscape when open world design was still relatively novel, and limited to only a handful of studios. They have been surpassed by virtually every other studio out there in terms of gameplay, animations and modern game engines. I wrote this a few years ago.
Opinion - The Fate of Bethesda Game Studios (2002 - 2020)
2002 - The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind 2004 - IHRA Professional Drag Racing 2006 - The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion 2008 - Fallout 3 2011 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim 2015 - Fallout 4 2018 - Fallout 76 TBA - Starfield TBA - The Elder Scrolls VI In 2002, Bethesda was at the forefront of the...
I'd be shocked if it scores a 94. I'm expecting around an 88 personally. Fallout 4 is an 84. Fallout 76 is 53. Part of the reason Bethesda was interested in acquisition is because they've been surpassed by almost everyone in their one niche - open world design. They're playing catch up, and after the gameplay reveal we know they're not going to have radical changes to animation or graphics quality. The game looks like Fallout 4 on a bigger scale.
The only real hope for the game is that the writing and story are great. I am surprised they're even considering RTX, so I guess we'll see how that goes.
digoutyoursoul
Member
Well if the games turn out great he’s made the right call. I hope to see more from Ninja Theory in the coming months tho , Starfield is anticipated by many but I’m more excited by Project Mara and especially Hellblade 2 which looked great in its last showing.
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
94 is achievable but tough, for sure.I don't see it scoring a 94. Skyrim was a long time ago. A completely different gaming landscape when open world design was still relatively novel, and limited to only a handful of studios. They have been surpassed by virtually every other studio out there in terms of gameplay, animations and modern game engines. I wrote this a few years ago.
Opinion - The Fate of Bethesda Game Studios (2002 - 2020)
2002 - The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind 2004 - IHRA Professional Drag Racing 2006 - The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion 2008 - Fallout 3 2011 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim 2015 - Fallout 4 2018 - Fallout 76 TBA - Starfield TBA - The Elder Scrolls VI In 2002, Bethesda was at the forefront of the...www.neogaf.com
I'd be shocked if it scores a 94. I'm expecting around an 88 personally. Fallout 4 is an 84. Fallout 76 is 53. Part of the reason Bethesda was interested in acquisition is because they've been surpassed by almost everyone in their one niche - open world design. They're playing catch up, and after the gameplay reveal we know they're not going to have radical changes to animation or graphics quality. The game looks like Fallout 4 on a bigger scale.
The only real hope for the game is that the writing and story are great. I am surprised they're even considering RTX, so I guess we'll see how that goes.
Even a 90, to be honest, is pretty much a 10/10 because sometimes, a game gets bad reviews (Returnal got a 6
) that bring down the average. So even a 90 is near a 10/10 experience.
Punished Miku
Human Rights Subscription Service
90 is higher than I expect, but I guess we'll see how it goes. Even action games now are basically open world, while having Naughty Dog levels of polish. Bethesda just isn't that kind of studio right now. That's my main argument though - everyone caught up on open world design and retooled their engines while Bethesda basically stood still for 10 years. This game wont be a radical reinvention for them, but hopefully it's fun and has a cool story.94 is achievable but tough, for sure.
Even a 90, to be honest, is pretty much a 10/10 because sometimes, a game gets bad reviews (Returnal got a 6
deriks
4-Time GIF/Meme God
I was confident in a fart once, didn't go as planned.
Still, delaying a Bethesda game is for sure because of the bugs. Remember that since Fallout 3, EVERY BETHESDA GAME IS LAUNCHED ON BETA
I can easily see this game launching in 2024, and I'm fine with it
Magic Carpet
Gold Member
I disagree with Phil in this instance.
Starfield is very much needed right now. NOW.
They should have released with smaller content and added more content as time went on.
Gamepass, the very concept of gamepass can allow you to release stuff more often. Grounded, Sea of Thieves have shown this as possible.
I could be chewing my way through a starting area taking my time soaking in the world and lore and goodies.
The game is being used as an exclusive to Xbox so no need to dump and entire finished game on a disk on a shelf for Playstation or Nintendo.
Sometimes I think Phil is too standoffish. I want to hear an inside story of some office meeting that has him just Shouting at developer heads.
I see all those Developers and Studios, Thousands of People all earning paychecks, and the result is a shoulder shrug.
Crack some whips. I would not be earning my own paycheck if I was at work producing NOTHING.
Starfield is very much needed right now. NOW.
They should have released with smaller content and added more content as time went on.
Gamepass, the very concept of gamepass can allow you to release stuff more often. Grounded, Sea of Thieves have shown this as possible.
I could be chewing my way through a starting area taking my time soaking in the world and lore and goodies.
The game is being used as an exclusive to Xbox so no need to dump and entire finished game on a disk on a shelf for Playstation or Nintendo.
Sometimes I think Phil is too standoffish. I want to hear an inside story of some office meeting that has him just Shouting at developer heads.
I see all those Developers and Studios, Thousands of People all earning paychecks, and the result is a shoulder shrug.
Crack some whips. I would not be earning my own paycheck if I was at work producing NOTHING.
reinking
Gold Member
It is going to score 90 on hype alone. I agree with you about Bethesda. I have had a love-hate relationship with them going back to the days of falling through the world in Sea Dogs. Still, one of my favorite developers.
yurinka
Member
I think that it's better to delay games and to release them in the best possible way to make sure that players and reviewers get the best possible first impression.
I also think that it's better to don't announce the games too early, that it's better to announce the games as late as possible to make sure that when shown they are in a shape very similar to the final game, and that when they announce a date it's a pretty much final one. So I think the optimal point to announce and show AAA games is around a year or a year and a half before release and to announce the release date around 6 months before release, once it's on the final testing stages and they are very confident about the date.
I also think that it's better to don't announce the games too early, that it's better to announce the games as late as possible to make sure that when shown they are in a shape very similar to the final game, and that when they announce a date it's a pretty much final one. So I think the optimal point to announce and show AAA games is around a year or a year and a half before release and to announce the release date around 6 months before release, once it's on the final testing stages and they are very confident about the date.
ChorizoPicozo
Member
Keep talking Phill, keep talking
Umbasaborne
Banned
In the year 2021, they announced the 2022 date. Thats what I said
oldergamer
Member
unsure what you are adding
Tams
Member
On the other hand... you can end up with Duke Nukem Forever...
Mr Hyde
Member
Represent.
Represent(ative) of bad opinions
I’m just expecting this game to come out and be absolutely mediocre and not deliver on its premise. I just have zero faith in these newly purchased studios. Hope I’m wrong for once
gothmog
Gold Member
I'm not even sure I could handle a Bethesda game released without jank. Like what would that even look like?
OuterLimits
Member
I'm not a huge fan of Bethesda, but most companies have some major game releases that are either underwhelming or even downright bad. Fallout 76 was the first major blunder from Bethesda.
Swift_Star
Banned
GymWolf
Member
His job is just to hire as many fucking betatester he can to squash as many bugs as possible, triplicate the number that bethesda usually hire, they are clearly not even close to be enough.
Now they are under M, there is ABSOLUTELY ZERO EXCUSE for a shitty control quality this time, they are not bethesda anymore, they are a microsoft studios.
anthony2690
Member
I like Phil Spencer like most here do, but can we please get a mega thread for Phil Spencer, or even a full thread dedicated to each interview, rather than multiple threads with different quotes from the same interview please? 
chixdiggit
Member
So shocked you would guzzle cum?
Toots
Gold Member
Step up your meme game then
in case you’re really asking yourself : xxx was a mistake, and i put the satoru easter egg as a little hommage to Iwata-san
rodrigolfp
Haptic Gamepads 4 Life
Why do people insist on calling it Xbox exclusive? Was the PC version canceled?
JohnnyFootball
GerAlt-Right. Ciriously.
I get more confident when a Sony game get's delayed. Less confident in that game when Microsoft delays.
That's the difference between good studio management and piss poor studio management.
Absolutely unreal that MS hasn't reached a point where they are releasing 2-3 big exclusives a year. Absolutely unreal.
That's the difference between good studio management and piss poor studio management.
Absolutely unreal that MS hasn't reached a point where they are releasing 2-3 big exclusives a year. Absolutely unreal.
Magic Carpet
Gold Member
I hear over half the games are being released on Unreal. And they still can't pull it off.
Victor Omega
Member
What are some new game coming out before starfield for Xbox?
Kacho
Gold Member
Forza Motorsport and Redfall
azertydu91
Hard to Kill
I think Redfall is supposed to come out before Starfield, other than that, I'm not sure.
mansoor1980
Gold Member
So a ‘newly purchased studio’ mysteriously changes and loses all their talent and skill at making games?
TheGodfather07
Member
Even 2023 could still be too early.
synchronicity
Member
Personally, I wish all publishers and developers would ignore the whining public endlessly screaming, "When?!?"
Just do your work and do it to the best of your ability and release your game when you feel like you've realized your vision. Let the voices chirp and don't worry about it.
Just do your work and do it to the best of your ability and release your game when you feel like you've realized your vision. Let the voices chirp and don't worry about it.
DenchDeckard
Moderated wildly
Let's see what he thinks about the next delay!
BusierDonkey
Member
I'll be playing the shit out of this whenever it launches, they can delay it until the fall if they need to. Plenty of games to play in the meantime and I'd rather not have a Fallout New Vegas situation at launch where the game could become unplayable due to bugs.
There isn't a single Bethesda game I didn't put over 400 hours into and I'm sure this game won't be any different.
There isn't a single Bethesda game I didn't put over 400 hours into and I'm sure this game won't be any different.
bentanchorbolt
Banned
Skyrim and Fallout 4 were excellent and I probably put more time into those two games than any other single player game I've ever played. The only real gripe about the work they do would be with Fallout 76 and that was simply a case of releasing way too early, because the game as it exists today is pretty fucking good and it delivers on their original promise and then some.
TheThreadsThatBindUs
Member
No shit sherlock.
Shipping games too early is a bad idea.
It's hardly a rivetingly unique insight.
Shipping games too early is a bad idea.
It's hardly a rivetingly unique insight.
ZoukGalaxy
Member
I was confident in a fart once, didn't go as planned.
BTW it's not going to say otherwise Sherlock. It's "Phil PR BS" in all its glorious state.
The game will be released full of bugs as usual, it will become a new meme, they will release some update then modders will end the work as always again.
Last edited:
TheTony316
Member
Didn't he say the same about Crackdown 3?
bender
What time is it?
Bethesda's last great game was in 2002 though.
