• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Pink Floyd to REFORM for LIVE 8!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, my jaw dropped (literally) when I heard about this. Aren't the Live8 concerts being televised globally? Then we should all be able to see the reunion.

My buddies and I have a pact that we'll fly to London to see a reunited Pink Floyd, if the travel is necessary. Unfortunately, this is happening so soon that it would be extremely hard to do, and an even bigger problem is getting a ticket to the concert when we're all here in the States. So right now, I'm praying for a tour...

Come on, Roger! Ca Ira is going nowhere. Give that shit up and go jam with your old buddies.
 

Bat

Member
milanbaros said:
A world tour would easily surpass any previous tour by any band ever. They could play night after night at the biggest stadium in the world and charge $100 a ticket and it would still be a sell out. I would sell my soul to see Pink Floyd, especially for the lasers.

I don't think there is any way Waters would ever do another stadium tour....maybe arenas.
 
Holy fucking shit! That was totally unexpected news to wake up to...

Add me to the list of people who'd do anything (sell organs, etc) to see them on tour.
 

jett

D-Member
HOLY MOTHERFUCKING FUCK.

FUCK.

I sooooooooo wish I could attend that concert. :\

P.S.: The Syd Barret-era of Pink Floyd(just one measly album...he only contributed one song to the second one) is worse than Gilmour's. ROGER WATERS ERA FOREVER.

P.S. 2: BEST NEWS EVAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAR. EVAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAR. EVAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAR!!!!!!!
 

8bit

Knows the Score
Unless you start queueing early enough to be the first in(like today), the only Pink Floyd you would see at the concert is either on the big screen, or as tiny hippie shaped dots on the horizon. Even then you would have to put up with Elton John, Dido, Sting and other worthy acts.
 

Shinobi

Member
I think they randmonly distributed the London tickets (which are free) last week already. Regardless, you can expect to see tickets going for four or maybe even five figures on eBay.

BTW, which Pink albums would you guys recommend? And which one is regarded as their definitive album?
 
Dark Side of the Moon is considered to be their definitive album, but elitist hardcore fans usually say Meddle (not that they're necessarily wrong, but you know...).
 

CrunchyB

Member
Dark Side of the Moon & Wish You Were Here are probably their best works.

The Wall, Animals and to a lesser extent, Meddle and The Final Cut are great as well.

Some of the older stuff is quite trippy and not very accessible. The latter Pink Floyd/Roger Waters albums aren't half bad, just not nearly as good as PF in their prime.

I also recommend Dave Gilmour's Live DVD. Great stuff.
 

jett

D-Member
Shinobi said:
I think they randmonly distributed the London tickets (which are free) last week already. Regardless, you can expect to see tickets going for four or maybe even five figures on eBay.

BTW, which Pink albums would you guys recommend? And which one is regarded as their definitive album?

The thing with Pink Floyd is that most of their albums sound really different from each other, but most people would say that Dark Side of the Moon is their definitive album. I recommend DSOTM, Animals(personal favorite), Wish You Were Here and The Wall. You can't go wrong with any of those four.
 
I would say Darkside and The Wall are the definative albums, but Meddle is definately my favourite. If you like more hippy/dreamy stuff Piper and Saucerful of Secrets are really good.
 

Kon Tiki

Banned
Jonnyboy117 said:
Everyone forgets Atom Heart Mother. Great stuff on that one. Saucerful of Secrets is also awesome.
Heh, After listening to Octavarium (the song) for the 100th time, I went back and listened to AHM (which is celebrating it's 35th anniversay, with a behind the scenes DVD). It may have been rough, the band may hate it, but it is still listenable to this day. Very progressive track.
 

Prospero

Member
Shinobi said:
BTW, which Pink albums would you guys recommend? And which one is regarded as their definitive album?

If you think that Waters is the heart and soul of Pink Floyd (that is, you think lyrics are slightly more important than music), then you probably think either Dark Side of the Moon or The Wall is definitive.

If you favor Gilmour's contributions to the band over Waters' (like I do--sacrilege, I know, but PF's music trumps lyrics for me), then you probably think either Dark Side of the Moon or Wish You Were Here is definitive.

I went through a completist PF phase in college, so back then I'd've said that every album is a good album. But now I'd say that you could get by if your collection had Meddle, DSotM, WYWH, The Wall, and A Momentary Lapse of Reason (shut up about AMLoR, haters--"Learning to Fly" and "One Slip" are on there). I actually balked at including The Wall because so much of it is filler and I haven't listened to it in its entirety in six or seven years, but there are so many classic songs in it that it's a must-own.
 
Dark Side of the Moon in 5.1 Super Audio CD is the shit.

And just because it wasn't mentioned, The Division Bell rocks *wink to Alucard*
 

jgkspsx

Member
Absolut Essentials: Meddle, Dark Side of the Moon, Wish You Were Here

Essentials: Early Singles EP (but Relics is an acceptable stand-in), Animals, The Wall (or Is There Anybody Out There?: The Wall Live -- both have their good and bad points)

Close-to-essentials: Piper at the Gates of Dawn, Obscured By Clouds

Worthy purchases once you know what you like: A Saucerful of Secrets, Atom Heart Mother, Ummagumma - Live*, The Final Cut, A Momentary Lapse of Reason, The Division Bell

Completists only: More, Ummagumma - Studio*, Pulse

Absolute dogshite: Delicate Sound of Thunder

Notable solo albums: Syd Barrett's three (Madcap Laughs, Barrett, Opel) are excellent (but can really do a number on your mental state). Roger Waters's Pros and Cons of Hitchhiking is somewhat monotonous but quite effective. David Gilmour's first (eponymous) solo album is fairly light and mostly instrumental, but well worth a listen.

* No, they don't come separately :p
 
Oh yeah Pulse fucking owns.

Why wont they fucking release on DVD already! I so regret not picking up the bootleg when I had the chance :(
 

jgkspsx

Member
Burger said:
I disagree. Pulse got me started on PF.
Bah. The aMLoR stuff and the Division Bell stuff on Pulse is great (and so is One of these Days), but I hate the production on the classic tracks -- listen to Hey You, fercryingoutloud. I also hate the live DSotM. It's a good video, but it's not really a worthwhile album.

But, sure, move it to "worthwhile purchase if you know you'll like it."

Zabriskie Point (damn, I knew I forgot one!) has Come in Number 51 Your Time Is Up, which is by far the best studio version of Careful With That Axe Eugene. While it carries nowhere near the power of the song live (Pompeii is the best I've heard, Ummagumma version among the worst), that alone is enough to make it worthwhile to some. Yeah, mainly completists.

Live At Pompeii is an absolutely essential concert video. Just make sure to get either the extended VHS or to choose "Classic Movie" in the extras of the DVD. They butchered it horribly (with loads of lame, lame, lame CG) for the main program of the DVD.
 

Bat

Member
I have a bootleg VHS (which I then dubbed to DVD) of one of the live Wall shows in 1980 (this one in Nassau colleseum)....it's such an amazing concert performance. As I get older, I find myself gravitating more and more Floyd's less accessible music, either thematically (The Wall, The Final Cut) or musically (Wish, Saucerful). Dark Side is everyone's favorite....but it's a little too bleh for me at this point. It sounds good, has some nice lyrics....but is a little too "safe" compared to their other works.

There are also a bunch of their albums that I adore, but are rather inconsistent. Meddle and Atom Heart Mother have some amazing stuff, but also some not-so-good stuff.
 

Burger

Member
Naked Snake said:
Oh yeah Pulse fucking owns.

Why wont they fucking release on DVD already! I so regret not picking up the bootleg when I had the chance :(

You shouldn't regret it, apparently it's a worthless copy of the VHS. Faux 5.1 etc etc. I heard that Pulse was out on DVD soon, Gilmour is taking his time with the 5.1 track.
 

Jdw40223

Member
Shinobi said:
I think they randmonly distributed the London tickets (which are free) last week already. Regardless, you can expect to see tickets going for four or maybe even five figures on eBay.

BTW, which Pink albums would you guys recommend? And which one is regarded as their definitive album?

DAMNIT!! Not any longer!! This just in: Ebay Considered "Electronic Pimp"!! :lol :lol and forced to remove all Live 8 tickets after being swamped with false auctions and bidding wars!

http://money.cnn.com/2005/06/14/news/newsmakers/ebay_live8.reut/index.htm
 

Alucard

Banned
The Division Bell totally deserves more love. It was consistently good from beginning to end IMO. High Hopes, mofos!
 

Shinobi

Member
Heh, thanks for the recommendations...I always get a kick out of seeing fans of an artist or group debating their favourite albums.

And as Jdw mentioned, they didn't waste anytime throwing those tickets up on eBay, much to Sir Geldoff's dismay...and eBay's since banned the sale of those tickets after a ton of bogus bids and pressure from protesters (aka bitter fools who didn't get tickets themselves :lol).

Ebay bans Live 8 touts after Geldof calls for boycott
By Catriona Davies and James Burleigh
(Filed: 15/06/2005)

The internet auctioneer Ebay was forced to withdraw tickets for the Live 8 charity concert from its website last night after Bob Geldof demanded a boycott over its refusal to prevent touts selling tickets.

The company's climbdown came after hundreds of protesters made bogus bids on the site of up to £10 million in protest at sellers attempting to make a profit.

More than 400 pairs of tickets for the concert won in a text lottery were put up for sale on Ebay by touts.

Geldof, the organiser of Live 8, threatened legal action against the website - which he likened to an "electronic pimp" - and accused those people selling their tickets of "disgusting greed".

Earlier yesterday the website offered to donate its £1 per listing fee to the charity.

A spokesman said: "We are allowing the tickets because we live in a free market where people can make up their own minds about what they would like to buy and sell.

"Ebay believes it is a fundamental right for someone to be able to sell something that is theirs, whether they paid for it or won it in a competition."

However, Geldof and apparently hundreds of Ebay users were not appeased and last night the company gave in.

In a statement, it said: "Ebay has decided not to allow the resale of Live 8 tickets on the site. We have listened to Ebay's community of users and the message has been clear - that they do not want the tickets to be resold on the site."

Last week two million people entered a text message lottery to win pairs of the 150,000 tickets to see Sir Paul McCartney, Madonna, Coldplay and Pink Floyd at Hyde Park on July 2.

But within minutes of the winners being notified by text message on Monday, tickets appeared on Ebay, with starting prices of up to £2,000.

By yesterday there were more than 400 auctions. But many of the sellers received more unrealistic offers than genuine bids, making it difficult for sellers to determine which buyers intended to pay.

One auction had more than 120 bids that appeared to be bogus, and only 10 seemingly genuine ones.

The website became a battleground between sellers and protesters, with many trading insults in messages. Some sellers promised to donate a portion of their takings to charity, and accused the saboteurs of seeking to deprive the charities of money.

The Government also stepped into the debate, with the minister for music, James Purnell, writing to Ebay urging it to stop the ticket sales.

He said in a letter on behalf of the Department of Culture, Media and Sport: "It seems absolutely wrong that people should be able to profit in this cynical way from an event designed to highlight the need for action on poverty in Africa, and for which so many artists and others are donating their valuable time for nothing."

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/mai...15.xml&sSheet=/news/2005/06/15/ixnewstop.html

And in case you haven't heard, The Who has also been added to the London show...as if that lineup wasn't stacked enough.
 

Eminem

goddamit, Griese!
I still say Animals is the best floyd album. but to each his own.

man, the fucking who are gonna be there too? christ all mighty. they still actually sound really, really good.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom