I'm super LTTP, and would have made a new thread... but this just got bumped today.
So, I've never seen Alien. Or Aliens. Okay, any of them. (Well, I've seen the Predators anyway).
but that's not the point, I'm just setting the stage - consider this an opportunity, because I went into Prometheus totally blind.
I'm sure this has been beaten to death here, but this thread is massive...
Anyway, so... why do people hate this movie?
I ask, because... I thought it was really good. Beautifully done, great acting. Disturbing, for sure... my god, that surgery scene, glad I didn't see it in theaters. But why the vitriol?
Does it ruin something for Alien fans? Please feel free to connect the dots, but as an outsider, it was enjoyable. They came seeking the origins of life. They found only death. In fact, they found their own death, but righteous sacrifice saved humanity. I can buy that. We are worth saving. These Engineers didn't think so, given that guy's malice at being woken up. Maybe it's a bit cliche to come finding our makers, but end up finding a military installation with weapons bred for war, but I didn't think that made it a bad story?
I enjoyed Weyland coming for eternal life, only to come to find nothing awaits him in death. And Shaw deciding to keep her faith, because she wants to believe. It was a nice play on science vs faith there. In the end, despite everyone telling her she had given up, Shaw decides to keep searching for answers. Weyland tried to buy his way into it and - opps, bump on the noggin.
David on the other hand... what a trip. They mock him for not being able to create life; so he hatches a plan to make his own using Shaw's body? Damn. Brilliant and evil. And why did he do it? Well, 'because he can,' I suppose. Don't all children want to see their parents dead? Jeeze. I wonder if he even cared he was creating some kind of evil alien hybrid thing.
Two big questions for me, 1. what was the purpose of the first scene, showing the Engineer eat something funky and disintegrate? Was that showing the genesis of life on earth, how it's DNA was spread into the water? I imagine that was on Earth, in Africa? that's my current theory, 20 sec after I finished the movie.
Two, and we'll never know the answer to this I suspect... what did David REALLY say to the Engineer? He clearly had his own agenda - another play on an earlier discussion in the movie, about keeping that a secret - whatever he said, sure pissed the guy off though. I wonder if we'll find out what his deal is in Movie 2, because he certainly didn't ask Engineer to save his Daddy... he wanted him axed.
So, good stuff. Please feel free to enlighten, point me in the direction of a good summary, or agree. I'm not concerned with Alien spoilers either.