You probably see a lot of them as they're also the most popular phones around.
Quick GAF; iPhone 5s or Samsung Galaxy S5
- Thread starter Psychoward
- Start date
- Status
You probably see a lot of them as they're also the most popular phones around.
Psychoward
Banned
Went with the S5 because the HTC One wasn't waterproof and didn't have any waterproof case options.... I think I made a huge (pun intended) mistake. The S5 is gigantic... with the Lifeproof case it's even worse. This is near impossible to hold with one hand. I think the iPhone screen size is too small to navigate with, but I'd choose that over this behemoth. Ugh. Also this UI is god-awful, probably will warm up to it but with every minute the $35 restocking fee is looming closer and closer.
You could always install another launcher although that won't take away all of TouchWiz.
Psychoward
Banned
Also whenever I get a text it sounds like a foghorn is going off, the vibration is really odd.
BronsonLee
Member
You can change all of that in the settings.
Or you can just give me the phone, either works 
Psychoward
Banned
I did but it was really hard to tell with the thing on the display stand, I had to rush too because the store was closing and the deal was gone after today.
Also everyone I talked to in the store said they would recommend the S5 over the 5s as well, I don't know. I made a stupid, rushed decision. If I do go with the 5s though, I'm really worried about the low battery life.
if you wanted small, powerful and waterproof - you should have picked xperia z1 compact
infiniteloop
Member
The Best smartphone you can buy
http://www.theverge.com/2014/6/11/5797664/the-best-smartphone
http://www.theverge.com/2014/6/11/5797664/the-best-smartphone
iPhone 5s
-Pyromaniac-
Member
If you gotta choose one of em now, iphone 5s. If you can wait a bit then iphone 6.
Psychoward
Banned
Yeah the screen and amount of options are really nice, but the thing is just gigantic. Then again I think the iPhone is too small. Ugh.
As baekshi said the Z1 Compact could've suited quite well if it was available for you.
Ninja Kn1ght
Member
iPhone 5S. Great hardware and an amazing app ecosystem.
Alligatorjandro
Banned
Get a Nexus 5
Psychoward
Banned
I don't think either the Z1 or Z2 was available for me.
Is the battery life really as awful as it seems?
Edit: Actually my account is eligible for one free exchange, and the case is a free return for 14 days anyway
So GAF, now that I at least have a working phone I have a bit more time to think about this. Thank god. The HTC seems to be out though unless someone can provide proof that a waterproof case is coming.
GoodCoffeeJoey
Banned
iPhone
infiniteloop
Member
Pity. The Z1 Compact would probably suit you quite well. Waterproof, good battery and it's not much bigger than the iPhone despite packing a 4.3" screen
I have read some users having problems with the glass cracking on it though.
Psychoward
Banned
Cracking through regular use? Because I would get a regular case too obviously that would go slightly over the edges of the screen.
PseudoKirby
Banned
how about a fucking windows phone.
Grimm Fandango
Member
I'm in a similar predictament. Lock button on my launch iPhone 4s suddenly stopped working. Thinking about 5s, S5 or One M8. Leaning towards the M8.
Psychoward
Banned
Brother has one, the UI is an eyesore to me.
Like I said, if the M8 was waterproof I'd get it in a heartbeat, but I've learned my lesson. I also work part-time as a lifeguard and while I never have my phone physically on me during my shifts, it's still at a pool complex most hours of the day.Grimm Fandango said:
Askherserenity
Member
Don't listen to him. Please.
Get a Nexus 5 or the HTC One. If you really want an iPhone for some reason, just wait for 6.
Only one worth getting is the Icon.
Yeah apparently so http://talk.sonymobile.com/t5/Xperi...a-self-cracking-screen-like-the-Z/td-p/401577
Grimm Fandango
Member
In your case yeah S5 seems best. There's been some rumblings the next One will be waterproof like the S5 but that's next year.
PseudoKirby
Banned
such a bad eyesore that Apple Decided to take it as inspiration for their design..
Psychoward
Banned
Well the waterproof debate between the S5 or 5s is moot since I'd be getting a lifeproof case for the 5s regardless. It just excludes the One sadly.
Yeah even my gigantor hands have trouble hitting all spots on the screen. But it does have a small screen mode.
Its staggering how much more you can do with the S5 over the iPhone.
NFC, IR Blaster, mountable storage, extendable storage, water proofing, USB 3.0, and shooting 4K video are all reasons why it is a no-brainer to me. The build quality is great too, no creaking like prior Galaxy phones.
Finally, Google Now is a certified game changer. The broadcasting of contextual information is awesome. Flight schedules, rental car info, places to eat, and even alerts about where you last parked your car are all wonderful features.
Its just a better, more durable phone. Perhaps it will change with the iPhone 6, but this comparison is not even close.
NFC, IR Blaster, mountable storage, extendable storage, water proofing, USB 3.0, and shooting 4K video are all reasons why it is a no-brainer to me. The build quality is great too, no creaking like prior Galaxy phones.
Finally, Google Now is a certified game changer. The broadcasting of contextual information is awesome. Flight schedules, rental car info, places to eat, and even alerts about where you last parked your car are all wonderful features.
Its just a better, more durable phone. Perhaps it will change with the iPhone 6, but this comparison is not even close.
CrunchyFrog
Member
Can I say that this is one of the coolest damn features of the thing? Took it on a kayaking trip last weekend, dove 15 feet into water while taking a selfie vid. Sure you couldn't see a damn thing from the footage but man if the thing doesn't still work perfectly. Only minor niggle is that the water messes with the headphone detection so underwater music playing is a no-go unless you get some kind of headphone jack cover/insert.
The IR blaster is neat too, though the built in samsung smart remote app leaves a bit to be desired in the button placement department.
Psychoward
Banned
Alright so if I was to change to the 5s in a few days, I just have two questions. Is it as responsive as the S5 and does it have the option to have Haptic Feedback/change the intensity of it? Thanks bros
BuggyDClown
Member
Came to post this.
I had an iPhone 5s since its launch in September, and recently just got a Galaxy s5 last months. Heres my list of pros and cons.
iPhone 5s Pros:
-Apple EcoSystem
-iMessage
-Everything just feels snappy and I never experienced delays in the software.
-The build quality of the device is second to none.
iPhone 5s Cons:
-Battery life was horrendous on it during usage. Standby time was god-like, but when I used it to browse the internet, the battery drained ridiculous amounts.
-screen was a little too small for my liking
S5 Pros:
-The battery life is great. I normally get about 5.5-6 hours of on screen time and don't have to worry about the device dying.
-The water-resistant design is nice. I actually dropped mine in a pool the second day I had it and no problems.
-The wireless charging cover (extra $30) is awesome. I just throw my phone down onto the charger and it starts charging. No worry about any cables.
-Screen is perfect for me. I have large hands, and I can still use the phone one handed.
S5 Cons:
-Software is sometimes slow, but not anything that will break my experience with the device, yet it is noticeable at times.
-Some people don't like the plastic design (I don't have a problem with it at all).
Either one you choose (or even the m8), all are great phones.
iPhone 5s Pros:
-Apple EcoSystem
-iMessage
-Everything just feels snappy and I never experienced delays in the software.
-The build quality of the device is second to none.
iPhone 5s Cons:
-Battery life was horrendous on it during usage. Standby time was god-like, but when I used it to browse the internet, the battery drained ridiculous amounts.
-screen was a little too small for my liking
S5 Pros:
-The battery life is great. I normally get about 5.5-6 hours of on screen time and don't have to worry about the device dying.
-The water-resistant design is nice. I actually dropped mine in a pool the second day I had it and no problems.
-The wireless charging cover (extra $30) is awesome. I just throw my phone down onto the charger and it starts charging. No worry about any cables.
-Screen is perfect for me. I have large hands, and I can still use the phone one handed.
S5 Cons:
-Software is sometimes slow, but not anything that will break my experience with the device, yet it is noticeable at times.
-Some people don't like the plastic design (I don't have a problem with it at all).
Either one you choose (or even the m8), all are great phones.
Psychoward
Banned
About the wireless charging cover; Do you just not use a regular case at all? Or do you just switch them out? Because I already bought one and am using it currently to protect the phone itself if - more like when - I drop it. Also, I'm pretty sure the iPhone has something similar.
Well its not really a cover, just a replacement back piece. It makes the phone a couple mm thicker, but in my opinion that actually makes it a little easier to hold.
http://www.amazon.com/Samsung-Wireless-Charging-Cover-Galaxy/dp/B00ITI24EK/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1402879977&sr=8-2&keywords=s5+wireless+charger
And yeah, I don't use a case on my phones at all lol. The 5s does have qi charger cases, but honestly they're all third party and might not work too well (and the ones Ive seen are ugly). With the replacement s5 back, you can't even tell that its different.
Psychoward
Banned
Heresy, as much as I dislike cases for the added bulkiness, I can't imagine not using one.
Also, have I been rused? HTC One M8 Water Test. If this is actually legit I'll switch out the S5 for the M8 (and get a thinner case) in a heartbeat.
Why would you need a Lifeproof case for the S5? It's already water resistant and dustproof.
Just get a smaller TPU case for the occasional drop. Maybe a glass screen protector if you're really paranoid.
And I gotta say, I have both the S5 and the M8, and I honestly prefer the S5. The camera is leaps and bounds better, I like OLED screens over LCD, and the Galaxy S5 is way easier to hold on to. The metal M8 is a slippery sucker. Battery life also seems a bit better on the S5.
Just get a smaller TPU case for the occasional drop. Maybe a glass screen protector if you're really paranoid.
And I gotta say, I have both the S5 and the M8, and I honestly prefer the S5. The camera is leaps and bounds better, I like OLED screens over LCD, and the Galaxy S5 is way easier to hold on to. The metal M8 is a slippery sucker. Battery life also seems a bit better on the S5.
Echelon079
Member
As a guy that repairs iPhone glass all day, I will say that I see far less 5s than any other I phones. 5c are junk.
……forgetit
Member
There are hundreds of YouTube videos for this, in the end it depends on you, for me personally the iPhone 5s is way too small to comfortably use, the S5 is very customizable but has a higher learning curve. What specifically do YOU want in a phone.
Why did you get a Lifeproof if it's already waterproof? Or are you wanting protection from drops as well?
Just get a slim case, since the waterproofness is handled by the phone itself.
Psychoward
Banned
Yeah I realized that was a mistake, luckily I can return that for free. I'll just get a slim case to protect it from drops, that will help reduce the bulkiness too which is currently my biggest issue with it. Although the small screen option is pretty neat.
- Status