• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Recently i watched Interstellar. yeah this is the greatest science fiction movie ever made right?

JokerMM

JokerMM

Gay porn is where it's at.
I went into Interstellar not expecting much, not even heard of it much until my family decided to watch it the other night.

By the end of the movie my mind was basically fucked. Honestly 10/10. I legit think this is the only movie I'd ever rate 10/10

also, that fucking soundtrack....
 
kurisu_1974

kurisu_1974

Member
I thought it was pretty silly to be honest. All the ruckus about 'real science" turned out to be just marketing, and I actually said to my wife, during one of the first scenes,
wanna bet that it is McConnaughy behind that bookshelf sending messages from some other dimension
and yeah that was fun being right. Also that ending was just shit, the part with the water planet was ridiculous, the part with the aging dude...

Not a big Nolan fan outside of Memento to begin with, and this did not win me over.

It's 2001 or Solaris for millenials.
 
Last edited:
gaming_again

gaming_again

Member
JokerMM said:
I went into Interstellar not expecting much, not even heard of it much until my family decided to watch it the other night.

By the end of the movie my mind was basically fucked. Honestly 10/10. I legit think this is the only movie I'd ever rate 10/10

also, that fucking soundtrack....
Click to expand...

It has its flaws certainly but I can't think of a sci-fi with more heart in it.

There's no way I could watch it since becoming a parent. At least not in any company. No fucking way.
 
The Cockatrice

The Cockatrice

I'm retarded?
The praise for 2001 is weird to me. I watched it ages ago and rewatched it rcently and besides amazing visuals especially considering the year it came out, its just incredibly tedious and boring to watch. As for Interstellar it was good, predictable tho but has some amazing scenes like the docking one. The best sci fi? Prolly not but Im not sure which movie I'd consider the best. Blade Runner is cybeprunk but still considered sci-fi so either that or Alien is what I consider one of the best.
 
SlimySnake

SlimySnake

Flashless at the Golden Globes
Yeah, its probably my favorite. Some dialogue about love transcending time and space made it a meme and took away from an otherwise stellar story.
 
Trunx81

Trunx81

Member
2001 .. I remember watching it and afterwards my dad asked me "and, did you skip forward?" He expected me to find it boring, but the cinematography kept me captivated.

Interstellar, though .. I don´t know, got mixed feelings on that one. The philosophical gut punches where forced sometimes and it just didn´t "get" me that much as others.

Tennet, on the other hand: Loved that movie! Still don´t understand how people got confused by it, for me it was totally logical in the end.
 
gaming_again

gaming_again

Member
The Cockatrice said:
The praise for 2001 is weird to me. I watched it ages ago and rewatched it rcently and besides amazing visuals especially considering the year it came out, its just incredibly tedious and boring to watch. As for Interstellar it was good, predictable tho but has some amazing scenes like the docking one. The best sci fi? Prolly not but Im not sure which movie I'd consider the best. Blade Runner is cybeprunk but still considered sci-fi so either that or Alien is what I consider one of the best.
Click to expand...
I think 2001 is my favourite film of all time, depending on my mood, but I get your criticism.
 
gaming_again

gaming_again

Member
Trunx81 said:
2001 .. I remember watching it and afterwards my dad asked me "and, did you skip forward?" He expected me to find it boring, but the cinematography kept me captivated.

Interstellar, though .. I don´t know, got mixed feelings on that one. The philosophical gut punches where forced sometimes and it just didn´t "get" me that much as others.

Tennet, on the other hand: Loved that movie! Still don´t understand how people got confused by it, for me it was totally logical in the end.
Click to expand...
Tenet is amazing. Nolan makes the films I wish I’d written. It’s as though he’s pulling stuff from the bottom of my soul.
 
winjer

winjer

Gold Member
For a movie that claimed to be scientifically accurate, it shit the bed in the last part.
The part with the bookshelf was just plain dumb.
It seemed like someone watched 2001, but didn't understand the underlying metaphors, and thought that just putting some random non-sense would make some deep philosophical sense.
 
AJUMP23

AJUMP23

Parody of actual AJUMP23
I think the first act is far too slow. Once they get to space it is great but getting there takes to long. The Original SW is the greatest SCI film. Because it is a fantasy film set in space.
 
thefool

thefool

Member
Probably not but as a theater experience is certainly up there with anything. Its enthralling as few things are.
 
F

FullMetalx117

Member
LimanimaPT said:
I don't think so. 2001 A Space Odissey is still unbeaten.
Click to expand...
Maybe it was a different time - but I tried really really really hard to watch this movie. Multiple times, not one time did I fail not falling asleep.

The ending is something tho, I researched it a lot. But tbh this movie screams only being considered good because it’s “artsy” not because it’s actually a good, engaging movie
 
Fbh

Fbh

Member
I'm not a fan of the ending (and the third act in general) but I still think it's up there.
I liked Arrival more overall though the grand audiovisual presentation of Interestellar definitely made it the more memorable movie going experience.
 
NeverYouMind

NeverYouMind

Member
It is one master cut from being the greatest sci-fi film. The time shananigans and attempt to keep the protagonist alive keep it from achieving the bittersweet epic it sets out to be. If they were to simply remove the tasseract with dust manipulation and commit to the protagonist's sacrifice to cradle the new dawn of the human race on another planet it would fare better. As is, it is inferior to 1997's Contact. That said, I hold the unpopular opinion that 2001: A Space Odyssey is pretentious rubbish with equally as many poorly written plot elements as Interstellar.

 
Last edited:
EverydayBeast

EverydayBeast

ChatGPT 0.1
interstellar space GIF
 
LimanimaPT

LimanimaPT

Member
FullMetalx117 said:
Maybe it was a different time - but I tried really really really hard to watch this movie. Multiple times, not one time did I fail not falling asleep.

The ending is something tho, I researched it a lot. But tbh this movie screams only being considered good because it’s “artsy” not because it’s actually a good, engaging movie
Click to expand...
I like it not because it is artsy, but becuse it is a realistic way for an alien civilization to contact us. From a scientific perspective it is very reallistic.

I actually forgot to mention Close Encounters of the third Kind. I really like this one and it sure deserves to be mentioned.
 
IDKFA

IDKFA

I am Become Bilbo Baggins
Great film, but let down by the ending. It needed more of an emotional punch.

I wouldn't class it the greatest sci-fi movie ever made. Not even in the 21st century (I'd rank Moon, Arrival and Ex Machina above it)

Fantastic film, but it was just missing something that truly made it one of the all time greats.
 
Grildon Tundy

Grildon Tundy

Member
I watched 2001 only once, when I was about 14, and I had NO CLUE what was happening in the last act.

Wasn't until I read up about it that I understood what was happening, regarding the main guy getting evolved to a higher consciousness. Is that at all apparent to people without additional context not present in the film itself?
 
Rentahamster

Rentahamster

Rodent Whores
Ballthyrm said:
Not sold on the power of Love through spacetime thing.
Click to expand...
In what way? That theme is an abstraction of what is actually occuring. Dr. Mann explained it in more "biological" terms in that particular scene, if you feel like "the power of love" isn't a suitable theme for science.
 
F

FullMetalx117

Member
We need to split the sci-fi category into sub categories. The greatest sci fi considering everything (story, theme, visuals, audio, pace, etc.) it's Blade Runner 2049 for me. In this category I would put movies like Dune (maybe), Ex Machina, iRobot, etc.

Interstellar is in the realm of Space Odyssey, Gravity, Ad Astra, etc. Because it's in space/specifically about space, there's a heavy visual and audio element that the director must get right for it to be great imo. Blade Runner/Dune/Ex Machina, etc. are philosophical heavy (not saying Interstellar isn't, but not to the extent these are). A movie like Blade Runner and Dune can survive off of having excellent dialogue and a single great atmospheric setting. Interstellar is great because you saw a wormhole, you saw a water planet, ice planet, black hole, inside a black hole which was all done in a believable fashion - this is why it's the greatest space sci fi movie.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Alien Romulus | Rotten Watch
News Community 9 10 11 12 13
639
35K
jufonuk replied
Hey Anime-GAF, what are some good recent anime OSTs (Not OP-ED)
0
637
Fbh replied
Do you watch / Have you returned to watching pro wrestling recently?
2
50
3K
violence replied
  • Locked
Has anyone else here ever struggled with not wanting to be alive?
48
3K
GigaBowser replied
Deadpool & Wolverine | Rotten Watch
Community
29
3K
Durien replied
Top Bottom