SEGAvangelist
Member
Sure. That one too.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Redfall | Review Thread
- Thread starter Draugoth
- Start date
PropellerEar
Member
Shut up dingleberry.
Hot air diSpencer and sycophants were just in the XCast apologizing in behalf of Redfall on the "Creative Risk" it took and not succeeding.
Copy paste sheit with abysmal implementation...
Death Stranding took real creative risks, there was no game like it, it is subjectively creative and on top of that a good game. Death Stranding doesn't need to be tainted by this thread.
Last edited:
MasterCornholio
Member
OK after seeing some of the comments here. There's really no need to be so angry over this. Not every game has to be fantastic. That's OK because there are plenty of other titles to play. HiFi Rush and Pentiment are solid titles but this one isn't. There will be better games in the future. Not every game is poor and that's something you can look forward to.
No need to get mad and fight over this.
kyussman
Member
We should find an excuse to talk about Death Stranding in EVERY thread......it would make this already great forum even better,lol.
Gambit2483
Member
XXL
Gold Member
Agreed. But since his departure, the quality has 100% dropped off. Maybe others left with him.
I'll still keep an eye out for their games, but very cautiously after Deathloop and Redfall.
Varteras
Member
OK after seeing some of the comments here. There's really no need to be so angry over this. Not every game has to be fantastic. That's OK because there are plenty of other titles to play. HiFi Rush and Pentiment are solid titles but this one isn't. There will be better games in the future. Not every game is poor and that's something you can look forward to.
No need to get mad and fight over this.
kyussman
Member
Yea,if the year was 1979.
A serious game of the year contender
Gambit2483
Member
How does this exist...like, seriously?
A serious game of the year contender
Last edited:
Aenima
Member
Giallo Corsa
Member
Maybe so Bernard but the guy was being dog piled and that's never fun, I can understand him getting upset in the end - even if he started it (which he didn't really, he just expressed his opinion).He did use an insult towards good ol' grumpy GHG but in the end...
It's fucking video games for fuck's sake, why do some people get so upset I'll never understand, I mean, I have no love for MS but this thread - IMO - has ran it's course, it's just beating on a dead horse at this point, and no, the whole "lowering the standards" thing (even if it is true) doesn't really matter in the end, why ? Because Redfall isn't the first nor will it be the last piece of broken code/media that get released in this terrible state...
"BUT IT ALL DEPENDS FROM US" some will say except it really won't , "us" in this case being nerd consumers inhabiting a virtual microcosm (forum) and can do jack and shit about all the other millions that don't give a flying fuck about such problems - the same millions that keep preordering games (and shitty ones at that), the same millions that have to get the latest and greatest "limited" edition with bullshit and childish paraphernalia included in the box, the same millions that keep buying COD/FIFA/MADDEN each and every Goddamned year, the same millions that ejaculate when shitty AAAA video game trailer No.8585800 gets released with hip-hop music in it, the same millions that are Marvel/DC/Star Wars Fanatics and will consume and gobble whatever shit those shit companies shit out all of the time, the same millions that...you get the idea, there's no winning this thing, it is what it is.
Anyway...
Death stranding you say ?
You got a PS5 you say ?
Play that shit ASAP my brother, it's silky smooth on the PS quintuple and - IMO - one of the best games of the past 10 years, it really is different than everything else on the market, sure, the story is bonkers and (especially towards the end) something gets lost in translation (you'll understand) but, again, there's just no other game like it Goddammit, to think that it ran on a PS4 is just crayzeee
To think that it got shat on for weeks on end is one of the things I'll never understand - and I've been playing games for a good 35+ years (both good and bad).
Cheers
Last edited:
Bernardougf
Member
ZoukGalaxy
Member
I agree, for the worst and ugly game award.
A serious game of the year contender
Must be REALLY good one
Last edited:
Crayon
Member
I wouldn't call it astroturfing. Here, pheromones are released from the mangina glands and carry a signal to protect the hive. The drones then spread out to cover comments and youtube with lines of sticky, fragrant bullshit.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
It's like a script.
A serious game of the year contender
Fermbiz
Gold Member
A serious game of the year contender
Im gonna go with satirical article
Nydius
Member
Then that same outlet proceeded to give the game a 6.0. Different reviewer than the previewer, but still.
It ties right back into WorthABuy's video questioning why all these outlets were giving glowing previews of the game a week before launch based on 2 or so hours of gameplay (which should have been more than enough to see all the glaring problems this game has) only to turn around and give it a "this game is utter shit" score... which they conveniently couldn't communicate to people until one hour before the game launched.
Last edited:
The Inventor
Member
Kinda what I said in another thread and as expected.
Nothing to see here, shame.
Nothing to see here, shame.
ShadowkillXNA
Member
If by 2.1 million, you really mean around 50,000 and change, you're right on the money.
balls of snow
Gold Member
I do think the hate is amplified by this being the big AAA from ms since halo infinite ( which had its own requiem) and its not even close to a mediocre game at the current state of release. Justified in this case when you look at ninty/ sony output the last few years. If Redfall was after supposed bangers like Forza, Starfield and Hellblade no one would care about a stinker.
Only of these is getting a sequel and its not the one with the Fall in the title.
Only of these is getting a sequel and its not the one with the Fall in the title.
Giallo Corsa
Member
SLESS
Member
This hurt my head ffs
YeulEmeralda
Linux User
Death stranding, regardless if you like the game, launched pretty stable and feature full. No 6 months of patching the broken mess needed (see Jedi, the last of us and cyberpunk).
STARSBarry
Gold Member
Seems like games in the same genre are over taking it.
Perhaps it's time to put them at a similair price.
Last edited:
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
Latest scores.
I think this will be the final score now ... but I still wouldn't bet on it, lol, it keeps dropping.
I think this will be the final score now ... but I still wouldn't bet on it, lol, it keeps dropping.
Last edited:
Gamer_By_Proxy
Member
That GOTY contender article just proves ChatGPT can do the impossible.
We should be more worried about AI.
We should be more worried about AI.
GHG
Gold Member
Seems like games in the same genre are over taking it.
Perhaps it's time to put them at a similair price.
A decade between the two games and you really wouldn't know it looking at them side by side. In fact you wouldn't blame anyone for thinking far cry 4 is the newer game.
The lack of overall progress over the last decade is a worrying trend.
Last edited:
gow3isben
Member
Latest scores.
I think this will be the final score now ... but I still wouldn't bet on it, lol, it keeps dropping.
Lol I knew it would drop but not this much looks like they only gave it to the shills initially and still it was only 64 early on
Nydius
Member
Let the “player engagement” spin articles begin!
www.gamesradar.com
Redfall has a strong start on Xbox despite negative reception
Arkane's latest has drawn a crowd on Xbox
BadBurger
Many “Whelps”! Handle It!
A serious game of the year contender
Damn. Dude admitted he's a paid shill in one fell swoop.
TheAmazingSpiderMan
Member
I’m 110% sure MS are paying him, there is a no way he is just an ordinary fan, if he is he needs to seek professional help.I was sad enough to scroll down his Twitter page and it’s just PR for Redfall every few hours.
Last edited:
Haint
Member
It's very much in line with expectations. The "next-gen" consoles are just 2x improvements over the 7 year old "Pro" consoles of last-gen, and the Pro consoles themselves were just 1440p or Checkerboard versions of the base consoles. So when you're targeting 60fps or native 4K you're not going to get assets radically different from base PS4. Hell Forbidden West and Ragnarok on base PS4 and certainly Pro look better than 95% of "next-gen" games.
Last edited:
Captain Toad
Banned
This is some of the worst math that I've ever seen.
Luigi Mario
Member
Hawking Radiation
Member
How did this game get any positive previews from the gaming press?
One website even labelled this a potential 'Game Of The Year candidate' in their preview article.
One website even labelled this a potential 'Game Of The Year candidate' in their preview article.
Last edited:
Pasta la Vista
Member
Feels like this is just twisting the knife at this point. It sucks, I love Arkane's past games, before Deathloop. This is probably the most attention this dev has gotten since the original Dishonored and it sucks that they will basically be remembered for this piece of shit instead by the vast majority of people.
The fact that this was also considered to be a true current gen game with no cross-gen version AND it was the first new console exclusive deemed "worthy" of a $70 price tag is a huge mis-fire. The price was obviously a MS decision and along with all the issues, it has done nothing to help the optics of the Xbox brand. It has every right to be raked through the coals, still it's tragic.
The fact that this was also considered to be a true current gen game with no cross-gen version AND it was the first new console exclusive deemed "worthy" of a $70 price tag is a huge mis-fire. The price was obviously a MS decision and along with all the issues, it has done nothing to help the optics of the Xbox brand. It has every right to be raked through the coals, still it's tragic.
MatrixReloaded101
Member
Game previews = Paid Marketing
This is why I stopped watching/reading game previews before release once I firgured this out.
You won’t get a real assessment of the game until it’s released.
chilichote
Member
Topher
Identifies as young
Latest scores.
I think this will be the final score now ... but I still wouldn't bet on it, lol, it keeps dropping.
Good grief. And Phil Spencer said their internal reviews had the game double digits above external reviews and that was when metacritic had it in the 60s.
Honey Bunny
Member
That end credits goes some way to explaining why the game is disappointing, but not in the way they wanted it to.
Last edited:
kyussman
Member
Yea,I bought the game day one and played for a full month every day until I finished it,not a single bug or glitch.Considering it's a game where you make your way across crazy terrain I never once glitched in the enviroment....that game was very polished.
Nicktendo86
Member
Is this a joke?
Talk about getting excuses in early.
kyussman
Member
Is this a joke?
"Our focus is always atmospheric world building,exploration and game mechanics that encourage players to improvise.The challenge was to keep these elements strong as we added an open world mission structure and four player co-op"............yea,I don't know why you thought you could do this.
xrnzaaas
Member
You'd be surprised how many reviewers and editors fail to spot good and bad sides of new games or their serious performance issues. Doesn't help that some of them don't play that many games and therefore have no experience with similar titles from the past.