This too.
Given how small the game is, I'm not against claiming early. But do so at your discretion.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Rejected Pixar Movie [Mafia] | Won't Someone Think of the Children?
- Thread starter CzarTim
- Start date
Given how small the game is, I'm not against claiming early. But do so at your discretion.
Well actually there have been quite a few fake cop gambits as town lately. So I was seeing if that was the case. Because the ninja flip left me confused about the game state. Which is bad and not helpful to figuring out what is happening. Figuring out what is happening is helpful. Not everyone plays that way but generally my play style is very much that way.
melonrabbit
Member
Yes. So, he's either town or a godfather.
Why are you assuming a blocker, and what does that have to do with them killing
Pop-O-Matic
Banned
Ouro, you soft-claimed some sort of blocking role at the end of yesterday. Maybe that's why we don't have a kill?
could be
melonrabbit
Member
Shit. You're right. Blocker can do both. Never mind.
That's a thought. 2 investigative roles, scum having a ninja and a godfather to weaken those investigator. Not that I'm saying nin is a godfather. Just spitballing.
2 or 3 scum?
melonrabbit
Member
Also when I was rereading yesterday this post and its verbiage jumped out at me.
Who said I protected someone
melonrabbit
Member
Interesting way to phrase that.
Is it
Hush lover
I'm assuming 2 scum, maybe a neutral
melonrabbit
Member
Which questions, Karl? I was leaning towards there being 2 scum and a neutral.
melonrabbit
Member
Im giving Ouro the benefit of the doubt for now. Let's pretend he's our very efficient doctor.
Nin still feels kinda off but I'm not able to place the feeling yet as to why.
Gorlak, Ive been off and on about but his post yesterday that singled out LP really seemed more of a town move than scum. LP wasnt on anyones radars going into D2.
Of the people left Im inclined to believe scum is one of these four:
exmachina
Pop
Kyan
Karl
Nin still feels kinda off but I'm not able to place the feeling yet as to why.
Gorlak, Ive been off and on about but his post yesterday that singled out LP really seemed more of a town move than scum. LP wasnt on anyones radars going into D2.
Of the people left Im inclined to believe scum is one of these four:
exmachina
Pop
Kyan
Karl
melonrabbit
Member
Pop or Kyan?
melonrabbit
Member
melonrabbit
Member
I'm loosely giving him the benefit of the doubt. If you have something to say or an additional theory to pose, by all means go ahead.
I have a theory on what happened last night. If it's correct, it's a genius tactic by scum and I'm a little impressed.
BUT
It relies on there being no other explanation for there being a no kill last night. If someone has info I'd like to hear it. Worst case we then have 3 PRs out in the open - cop, doctor, and whatever - but then scum has to choose which one to kill and we get results from the other two tomorrow.
So once everyone checks in, I'll float the idea and see what you all think.
BUT
It relies on there being no other explanation for there being a no kill last night. If someone has info I'd like to hear it. Worst case we then have 3 PRs out in the open - cop, doctor, and whatever - but then scum has to choose which one to kill and we get results from the other two tomorrow.
So once everyone checks in, I'll float the idea and see what you all think.
Assumptions:
put yourself in the shoes of a 2 man scum team who consist of a ninja and a godfather
from this you can assume that there are 2 town sided investigation roles, or maaaaybe a joat.
if each invest role can only find one of the scum, and infact gives false town reads on the other scum, it would behoove them to leave their relative invest role alive as last scum.
cop only helps a godfather earn town cred, so they would not kill you.
ergo, when the doctor comes forward, saying whether they protected you and so stopped an attempt on you, or took the riskier strat and protected someone else could help us try to parse what we are dealing with
hydro.....
hydro.....
oh god i can't even say the words
you think we have a hydro cannon situation on our hands?
Thanks for clearing me honey :*
As you can see my earlier statement was indeed the truth
melonrabbit
Member
I think it might be possible.
just to show you all
melonrabbit
Member
Don't thank me yet.
Nin, what's your read on the situation? Who do you think is scum? What does LP being a ninja mean to you?
Well that is indeed true since i had no time to actually post in the last day phase.
i will do my very best to be more active this last day phase
melonrabbit
Member
What are you two going on about??
What is a hydro cannon?
What is a hydro cannon?
melonrabbit
Member
Step up your game.
This one actually makes some sense though.
If this one makes sense, the other one made sense too damnit!
Just so I can keep track:
1. [m] Gorlak - hasn't checked in
2. [m] Ourobolus - nothing yet
3. [m] Lone_Prodigy - dead
4. [f] melonrabbit - claimed to cop nin as town
5. [m] Sorian - HAHAHAHA HE'S DEAD
6. [m] exmachina64 - hasn't checked in
7. [m] nin1000 - showed as town to melon, claims vanilla
8. [m] StanleyPalmtree - dead
9. [m] Pop-O-Matic - hasn't said one way or another if they have info from last night
10. [m] Kawl_USC - hasn't said one way or another if they have info from last night
11. [m] Kyanrute - hasn't checked in
1. [m] Gorlak - hasn't checked in
2. [m] Ourobolus - nothing yet
3. [m] Lone_Prodigy - dead
4. [f] melonrabbit - claimed to cop nin as town
5. [m] Sorian - HAHAHAHA HE'S DEAD
6. [m] exmachina64 - hasn't checked in
7. [m] nin1000 - showed as town to melon, claims vanilla
8. [m] StanleyPalmtree - dead
9. [m] Pop-O-Matic - hasn't said one way or another if they have info from last night
10. [m] Kawl_USC - hasn't said one way or another if they have info from last night
11. [m] Kyanrute - hasn't checked in
Well, i thank you for clearing my name today, i assume that i will get killed the next night pahse though :3.
Currently ? I guess we are at a pretty good one considering we killed a mafia player ( a fricking NINJA that could have made our lifes pretty hard ) and no one died because of a doctor/ blocker
melonrabbit
Member
exmachina posted today. he just hadn't said much other than clarifying I checked nin.
Oh, whoops, you're right. Somehow glossed over it just now despite me quoting him earlier, lol.
i dont know but that vote on me , giving no explanation at all even though he was lurking the thread to defend himself in the last hour, felt kinda off to me. I dont mind a vote on me but a vote without any reasoning ? I even had to ask one day phase later for it and then it was just "my gut".
Not trying to throw shade at you ex-machina but i am just pointing out that you should consider to give a bit more reason towards your actions. ( at best in the same day phase )
Not trying to throw shade at you ex-machina but i am just pointing out that you should consider to give a bit more reason towards your actions. ( at best in the same day phase )
Gorlak will probably be asleep, since its 01:00 here in Germany.
True enough. I can wait.