• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Rock Band Platform |OT|

Status
Not open for further replies.
MrOctober said:
No that's much worse. The Britney one sounds way too similar. Completely unneccesary.
Click to expand...
The one by Britney isn't technically a cover. GaGa wrote it for her for her Circus album, but passed on it.

Also, disappointed in Hit the Lights' cover of "More than a Feeling."
 
Jet Grind Radio! said:
The one by Britney isn't technically a cover. GaGa wrote it for her for her Circus album, but passed on it.

Also, disappointed in Hit the Lights' cover of "More than a Feeling."
Click to expand...
Thanks Toy Soldier.
 
Archie if that was released as a Britney Spears song and Gaga never did it, but it basically sounds almost the same to me at least, would you still like it?

Or are you buying into the "idea" of Lady Gaga and the music is secondary?
 
MrOctober said:
Archie if that was released as a Britney Spears and Gaga never did it, but it basically sounds almost the same to me at least, would you still like it?

Or are you buying into the "idea" of Lady Gaga and the music is secondary?
Click to expand...

If you can't hear the difference between Britney and Gaga, you're insane. One is good. One is awful.
 
I dunno; it's a pretty unfinished demo, but it's not dramatically different from Gaga's version.

Methinks the fan fervor is clouding judgement.
 
TheGreatDave said:
If you can't hear the difference between Britney and Gaga, you're insane. One is good. One is awful.
Click to expand...
Neither can sing well one just has a "hipper" image right now. Those songs are so similar I refuse to believe her image isn't playing a part in the decision.
 
MrOctober said:
Neither can sing well one just has a "hipper" image right now. Those songs are so similar I refuse to believe her image isn't playing a part in the decision.
Click to expand...

Gaga can sing well. Most her songs are hardly vocally difficult but she's done plenty of live stuff that shows she can sing.

Girl just has a charisma in her performance that's completely lacking in the Spears version.
 
MrOctober said:
Neither can sing well one just has a "hipper" image right now. Those songs are so similar I refuse to believe her image isn't playing a part in the decision.
Click to expand...
this

If she wasn't trying to be all weird and shit nobody would give a fuck about her terrible music.
 
corkscrewblow said:
this

If she wasn't trying to be all weird and shit nobody would give a fuck about her terrible music.
Click to expand...

Retarded and untrue. The music is selling her because it's great pop music. She's became a huge star because of her image, but the music had to be there to back it.

Haters :lol :lol :lol
 
TheGreatDave said:
Retarded and untrue. The music is selling her because it's great pop music. She's became a huge star because of her image, but the music had to be there to back it.

Haters :lol :lol :lol
Click to expand...
Pop music is more about image, timing and a financial push into the media more than it is the music these days. Just about every single pop star and their music is interchangable.
 
TheGreatDave said:
Bad Romance is better than anything released by Between The Buried And Me, c/d?
Click to expand...
c. It takes much more talent to be able to sing over growling into a mic. Gaga shits on BTBAM.
 
So here's one of the songs I've been working on.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u5i9V3FcgXw

Just jump to 2:43 if you're a guitarist. That's one solo, which is mostly ho/po triplets, that's longer than all of Motorcide. And there's a second solo that's 1:10 long. And the major drum pattern is a three-under-two polyrhythm.

It's a hard song.
 
MrOctober said:
Pop music is more about image, timing and a financial push into the media more than it is the music these days. Just about every single pop star and their music is interchangable.
Click to expand...

You can say that going back decades. Doesn't change the fact that Gaga's music has been so successful because it's actually good.
 
corkscrewblow said:
There are no pics.


It's a video
Click to expand...

I'll have what they're having then.

So anyways, Bamboozle was a good time.
Aquabats killed it day 1. They fought crabs on stage.
Against Me played too much new stuff, but was under a fake name so small crowd, which was awesome
Protest The Hero played all Fortress and new stuff which pisses me off, i wanted to hear Keiza stuff.
Ke$ha is awful, really really awful.
Paramore was really good live this time, unlike the last time where we had rain, shit mixing, and haley being half-sick. So that was cool.
Hanson was nostalgic, and was kinda entertaining
Attack Attack=Crabcore live. I saw the last song, it was Stick Stickly. They did the crab move, then busted out neon glasses and started raving at the DDR Breakdown. Hilarity watching a hardcore mosh pit to it

Day 2
OK Go was disappointing, poor mixing, no energy/stage presence
Fun. wasn't too bad
MC Chris was awesome to see, just because he did MC Pee Pants during the set.
Motion City Soundtrack was good as always (Very interesting set of NIN covers they did at the friday kick-off show)
Mute Math was the best band of the weekend, barely over Aquabats
Minus The Bear was good, nothing special, good set
Girl Talk was awesome, just people relaxing and jamming for a bit
Matt And Kim were really good, got the crowd going leading into...
MGMT: Giant mosh pit. Seriously, they all just descended to the stage during Kids. That pit was worse than the Protest the Hero pit, i shit you not
Weezer, however, was awesome. Played mostly stuff off of Blue and Pinkerton and Red. Was really cool actually. Did play the popular singles with that though (Hash Pipe, Dope Nose, If You're Wondering)
 
If you want a shitty cover look up Vanessa Carlton's version of "Paint It Black." Maybe if she hadn't tried to emulate the "singing" of the original song it would have worked...
 
Charron said:
So here's one of the songs I've been working on.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u5i9V3FcgXw

Just jump to 2:43 if you're a guitarist. That's one solo, which is mostly ho/po triplets, that's longer than all of Motorcide. And there's a second solo that's 1:10 long. And the major drum pattern is a three-under-two polyrhythm.

It's a hard song.
Click to expand...
When does this go up for playtest, and just how hard do you want me to be on it first pass?

This easily has the potential to become your best seller, though
 
MCS...NIN covers?...tell me more..

I was going to say about csb's "shitty cover of shitty song is shitty" comment, Me First and the Gimme Gimmes make lots of shitty songs good (most of them aren't shitty to begin with... but there are some that are).
 
b5he2x.jpg


FUCK this song. Ugh.
 
Heh, 2 stars. That reminds me of my Ace Of Spades Expert drum score that's so shitty, it's in the -2.4 percentile on keldon.

24kwdgg.jpg


I surpassed the lowest ranked player by thousands.
 
Kung Fu Fighting is one of the only songs I truly despise, that chart is just pure shit.

I got the new Steve Vai and Job For A Cowboy songs that popped up on RBN at some point during the weekend, pretty fun stuff on guitar. I'm starting to think that Homeward Bound is my favorite RBN track on guitar, those solo's are just so much fun.

Anyone pick up the Tecmo Bowl XBLA game?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Rock Band 4 and its DLC will delist on October 5, 2025 - Licenses for songs have are expiring
2
51
2K
kevboard replied
Sleeping Dogs Mobile Port
Platform 
3
142
asdasdasdbb replied
  • Featured
Mario Tennis Fever |OT| Mushroom Swingdom
|OT|  2 3
128
1K
Kokoloko85 replied
Delta Force Is Putting Other Shooters to Shame on Steam
Business Platform 
17
161
cafecat replied
  • Featured
2XKO |OT|
19
852
e0n replied
Top Bottom