Biggest-Geek-Ever
Member
I've read reports that Darth Vader holds his lightsaber outside the cockpit of his tie fighter and shreds an entire rebel fleet to pieces.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Rogue One Reviews & Impressions (Spoiler Tags Required)
- Thread starter Cross-Section
- Start date
- Status
Good, if they're true.
The spoilers are in the other thread, not this one.
LOL pretty sure that top post was just a callback to the early Rey concept art for TFA
you know, this one
LOL pretty sure that top post was just a callback to the early Rey concept art for TFA
you know, this one
I still want this in Episode IX, no matter how absurd it is.
Colin Trevorrow got a Velociraptor to hop on a T-rex while fighting the Indominus.
I am fairly confident he wouldn't pass up the opportunity.
KeyBladerXIII
Member
LOL pretty sure that top post was just a callback to the early Rey concept art for TFA
you know, this one
That would've been the most horrid, over the top bullshit ever, and I actually enjoyed bringing down a star destroyer with the force in Force Awakens.
Biggest-Geek-Ever
Member
NO.
Yes
I would totally be cool with Luke doing this, because I really want him to be the ultimate badass of the SW universe.you know, this one
Cross-Section
Member
I'm half-expecting it to happen, given Trevorrow's involvement, except Rey won't even be in an X-Wing, just flying around Superman-style.
bonesmccoy
Banned
I'm curious about reactions after 2nd and 3rd viewings. I enjoyed TFA when I saw it in the theatre, but I like it a lot more now after several viewings.
Yes, Starkiller Base is a weak part of the film - it just gets less annoying as time goes on.
phazedplasma
Member
One of those pieces of concept art that will always look better than something actually in motion.
bonesmccoy
Banned
It looks pretty terrible as is
CloudyTuba
Member
Wilford Brimley was in an Ewoks movie. I dont know how I could have gone this many years without being aware of this. Is that a rabbit hole I should go down?
I support your decision to limit your gaf contributions to ball busting every six months.
Old Luke wouldn't be so flashy. If there's ever a good place for someone to canonically bring down a Star Destroyer with the Force, it would be Luke in 8 or 9 to show how far he's come.
As long as we never get anything as ridiculous as him holding open a black hole with the Force.
Cross-Section
Member
I mean, it could work, it just can't be a conventionally-shot sequence.
Get John Williams to compose a nice operatic piece, shoot at 0.75 speed, focus on contrasts much like the art itself does. Could be cool.
Biggest-Geek-Ever
Member
I'd be down for Luke to be what Yoda should have been in the prequels: so powerful in the force he doesn't even need to use a lightsaber anymore. But him cutting through the knights of ren like butter would be money, too.
Basically, I'm easy to please when it comes to Luke.
Cross-Section
Member
The entire movie is on Youtube, so it's not like it's hard to get ahold of.
It would work perfectly in Genndywars.
brandonh83
Banned
The hero we need.
Cross-Section
Member
Cross-Section
Member
R2's just like "You really had to cut through the canopy too?"
Biggest-Geek-Ever
Member
My head just can't wrap around the idea of a 3 foot lightsaber leaving these fucking valleys in a star destroyer. It's so impossible that I want to see it on the screen.
LOL pretty sure that top post was just a callback to the early Rey concept art for TFA
you know, this one
I actually loved this idea. So over the top crazy that it just had to work.
Cross-Section
Member
Rey focuses her prodigy-like force abilities into the saber's kyber crystal, supercharging the blade into something that can cut, like, 5 hulls deep.
There's your plot justification.
demosthenes
Member
My hope is that after the Knights of ren killed the Jedi apprentices that luke wanted to murder them and felt the dark side. I hope he's been training this whole time to find the middle and own it. That sometimes you need to end bullshit and that doesn't mean you're going to become the next Darth vader.
Cross-Section
Member
Sexy.
You don't have to go into detail, but if you take a look in the spoiler thread, does it seem like the reddit guy we're quoting saw the same movie that you did?
Oh wow, that's insane!
SolicitorPirate
Member
LOL pretty sure that top post was just a callback to the early Rey concept art for TFA
you know, this one
"As ah said, Rey, kids are cruel. And ah'm very in touch with mah inner child."
I would avoid the GAF spoiler thread if you want to be surprised.
No. As in, no opening crawl.
Excellent, thanks!
Not uh, I wanted to see kid Darth Vader play with his friends and accidentally save the day while yelling yippie and woah.
PHOENIXZERO
Member
God I fucking hated that movie when I was little for doing that... That's actually all I remember of it and I remember very little of the first one too aside from the basic plot and a scene or two.
Gnome Scat
Member
LOL pretty sure that top post was just a callback to the early Rey concept art for TFA
you know, this one
I'd walk out of the theater.
CloudyTuba
Member
When the prequels were still just starting, I thought Episode 3 would basically be this movie (at least, what I know of it from trailers).
So, maybe I finally get to see the episode 3 I expected all those years ago.
I almost had a heart attack, my bad lmao. Didn't even read it just thought it was a spoiler. Been hurt too bad in the past.LOL pretty sure that top post was just a callback to the early Rey concept art for TFA
you know, this one
That would be hilarious. Though we've already had him standing outside on top of his TIE while it descends. Small steps!
That would be hilarious. Though we've already had him standing outside on top of his TIE while it descends. Small steps!
This and the stunt he pulls in Lords of the Sith are Vader's most Anakin moments.
Aruarian Reflection
Chauffeur de la gdlk
Don't think I'm going to finish my armor in time... why did I wait until so late to start working on it ;__;
Cross-Section
Member
Went and dug up some impressions on the score, as we haven't had a ton of people commenting on it besides "it's good" and "sounds like Star Wars".
From the Film Score Monthly forum:
From the Film Score Monthly forum:
CédricD said:
CédricD said:
SargerusBR
I love Pokken!
Would immediately buy another ticket.
I would walk out too, because nothing after that could hope to match up to that scene after that, and then buy a ticket to the next immediate screening so I can see the scene again. Lololololol.
When the Blu-Ray comes out you can make a fan supercut that's just 2 hours of that scene on loop, it will be glorious.
- Status