I have to say, I went and tracked down a slow mo of the 'incident' and fuck I watched it about 20 times on my phone and couldn't tell what the fuck happened. maybe there is a better angle that shows it clearly, but to me, that looked like it could have come off either the Scots or the Aussie dude.
Note that I'm a kiwi supporter, so the scots going through would have served my purposes admirably. I just didn't think it was 'clear' that Joubert fucked that call. From where he was standing it may have looked clear as day off a Scot (even if it wasn't). Ref has to call what he sees and he had no TMO option.
edit: regards to how pissed you are at the result, it's obvious to see HOW a ref could get the call wrong. I don't believe there was maliciousness. Anyone got an awesome slo-mo gif of the moment?
I found this vid where it's shown
http://www.balls.ie/rugby/joubert-twitter/312975
at around 20 seconds. I could totally see that Joubert saw the aussie guy touch it, then the scotland 20 comes running in and the impact certainly could look like it came off his shoulder.
Do I misunderstand the call? If it DID come off the scotish guys shoulder (which it apparently doesn't) should the call be a penalty, or is the argument that even if that was the case, it should still NOT be a penalty?