Just got my Urban Armor Gear case from Amazon, and it's really nice. Nice blend of the heavy duty protection, but still managed to be pretty slim, and it has a really stylish look to it. Very tight fit, so the buttons work surprisingly well, despite being one mold. Though the power button is not "clicky" like the volume buttons, but still responsive.
It also has a huge lip which is what I wanted as I will not be going with a screen protector. Pocket scratches don't bother me much, just drops.
Only downside for the case I see is that because it's such a tight fitting case it takes some effort to remove. It's not hard, but it took some time. It's also not very flexible.
http://www.amazon.com/dp/B008EPW1MI/?tag=neogaf0e-20
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-TkisFfUcyo&feature=plcp