Perspicacity
Banned
You're right. Punk would have to be fighting a battle of wits of some sort - outsmarting Lesnar at every turn and working with his brain to feel credible. Even with what you said it's a hell of an uphill battle, but I think with a lot of time, they could do it. You've changed my mind!
Now, do I think the WWE could do it right? Hellll naw... but it's fun to speculate.
This is the biggest issue. In current WWE the geniuses are the guys who get themselves intentionally counted out for no reason. Actual smart characters should be guys who can adapt, right now Mr. Small Package is the only person doing that.
It's what bugs me about Punk, to a certain extent. He doesn't seem to care about working out. I'm certainly not saying you need to be jacked or anything, and certainly don't use steroids, but at least try just a bit. Otherwise, it just looks silly when he's beating up on a guy like Cena, or Show, or even Lesnar. Or at least book him in a way that's credible. It may not have mattered when I was a kid, and I really thought Kane & Taker had powers or whatever, or somehow Rock spitting on his hand made it hurt more, but it sort of matters now. Especially with MMA looking so credible.
Punk could work out 12 hours a day and still be tiny compared to Cena. The ability to develop muscle tone and size (past a certain point) has more to do with genetics than it does effort. He talks about how much he hates the way he looks, but that he has to keep a lot of weight on just to look reasonably sized among the big guys.
Mind you, I think you have a point of needing a credible look or very credible booking, but I don't think you can knock the guy for his size.