Free climbing in BotW was the most "immersive" game feature I had seen in ages. You're looking at it purely from a realism standpoint when the visual style should have dissuaded any notions of that, immediately.
It allowed for a truly go anywhere, do-anything-you-can-think-of gameplay setup. Often times you were limited only by your imagination. It was about
gameplay.
Reading this board, I really get the sense that some people don't actually like gams. They just like simulations of real life and they want to get as close to that, and then claim some sort of ... I don't know, victory? "Oh I like this thing that is best in class, so therefore I am the best." Doesn't work that way I'm afraid.
Yeah I disagree with you on this one about as strongly as one can get. You've never gone rock climbing or seen good rock climbers have you. They can look like this on a sheer cliff. But again, this game is not about
realism.
I feel bad for people who can't understand the pure joy of this game.