• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Spring Anime 2013 |OT -7| My Giant CG Pony Can't Possibly Read This Much Baudelaire

Status
Not open for further replies.
Zettai Shougeki: Platonic Heart/Master of Martial Hearts

Okay, so since I've partially recovered from that mess of a finale, think I'll give some ACTUAL impressions.

So this is a 5 episode OVA series with a focus on fanservice and girls fighting. It's pretty much in the Ikkitosen "genre", but without the RTK slant. There's some tournament going on where the winner gets any wish they want granted. Pretty standard setup there.

I don't have a ton of compliments for the first 4 episodes. The presentation is way too subdued for the premise, the fights are poorly paced, the animation is inconsistent, the art and character designs are generic as hell, and they just flat out aren't very interesting. Really, everything about it is wasted potential, especially with how the fights are set up to be these ridiculous, over the top encounters, but kind of peter out before they even begin, even if there's occasionally some not bad choreography.

Sounds like a pretty bad set of OVAs, right?

HOWEVER

What makes this so memorable is the absolutely ridiculous final episode. Now, troll endings are nothing new, especially if you're a regular of this thread. The thing is, in the case of Platonic Heart, saying it comes out of nowhere would be an understatement.

People will generally point to School Days or Blood-C when talking about trollish developments. However, in both of these cases, you can tell the shows were actually building toward such events, even if they were more extreme than anyone could have imagined. Here, the abrupt nature of how things play out almost make it seem like it's parodying such developments

To give a comparison, imagine if Spongebob ended with a mind-broken Sandy being sold as a sex slave, Patrick found decapitated in a gutter, Squidward arrested for eating babies, and Spongebob killing Mr. Krabs and hollowing out his corpse so he can live on as his boss and no one ever finds out. That's pretty much the equivalent of how this ended.

And you know what? It's better for it. I was all ready to give this a 4 on MAL, but the finale made it jump up to a 7. Such a ridiculous turn of events must be commended regardless of what came before it.
 

cajunator

Banned
happy 420!


Best show to watch lit.

photo kana 3

ibpMlfaaR80zkn.gif


image.php

I dont know if this is awesome or totally creepy.
 

Theonik

Member
Aim for the Top 2! DIEBUSTER 04
ibymXIXUuQrPBD.png
iV1oQZw5HGHcv.png

:SDBurton all up it this
Spoilers in links maybe
OMFG OMG. AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
SO AWESOME.
The twins were massive assholes good they died. I had sort of predicted Nono was a buster machine for a while now but that was still awesome. Imperial army eh? So she was made in Gunbuster times of sorts. And that was a Gunbuster esque space monster trapped in there possibly the last of its kind? 10000 years huh and in SOL? Could it have been there since Gunbuster 05? Wait... Does this mean we are about at the time Noriko comes back in Gunbuster? AAAAAAAAA
Still think watching Gunbuster first isn't actually needed but some awesome fanservice there. There are a lot of universe holes from it too.
 

OceanBlue

Member
I dont know if this is awesome or totally creepy.

I always wonder if people find the fanservice in this show creepy because, presumably, the main character is actively seeking/causing it (and not in a comedic way like Sora no Otoshimono), instead of the fanservice falling into the main character's lap thanks to circumstance.

I'm not watching the show so I can't really comment on it too much, but I was trying to think of a reason why people find it creepy when other fanservice shots in other shows are framed in similar ways. Maybe it lingers a little too long or something.
 

Seraphis Cain

bad gameplay lol
Planning to watch it after I finish Persona 4 The Animation.

Just curious but what is the general GAF consensus on Persona 4 anyway?

I can't speak for GAF, but a friend of mine is one of the most hardcore P4 fans you'll ever meet. And he haaaaaaaated it. Anecdotal and all, but hey.
 

Quasar

Member
I always wonder if people find the fanservice in this show creepy because, presumably, the main character is actively seeking/causing it (and not in a comedic way like Sora no Otoshimono), instead of the fanservice falling into the main character's lap thanks to circumstance.

Well I generally don't find the main characters photos creepy as he normally is asking permission, whilst everyone else is stalking and taking secret photos without permission.
 

Jintor

Member
Bodacious Space Pirates 17

:sdburton

Also, I had a dream I was being forced to watch Oreimo for some reason. At least, I think it was Oreimo. I don't remember what I was actually 'viewing', but I remember thinking it was OreImo.

Planning to watch it after I finish Persona 4 The Animation.

Just curious but what is the general GAF consensus on Persona 4 anyway?

As an anime? It's fine. Pacing is fucked as shit though but it mostly comes across intact.

I can't speak for GAF, but a friend of mine is one of the most hardcore P4 fans you'll ever meet. And he haaaaaaaated it. Anecdotal and all, but hey.

TAIGA NO WHAT HAPPENED
 
Planning to watch it after I finish Persona 4 The Animation.

Just curious but what is the general GAF consensus on Persona 4 anyway?

Ive watched the anime three times, I guess it was worthwhile and worth watching, a bit ugly at times, but otherwise sold me on the game that I need to play once I finish DeSuOC.

Yusuke for best character.
 

PsionBolt

Member
I always wonder if people find the fanservice in this show creepy because, presumably, the main character is actively seeking/causing it (and not in a comedic way like Sora no Otoshimono), instead of the fanservice falling into the main character's lap thanks to circumstance.

Humourously enough, while he does ask people for their photos, he has fanservice fall into his lap as well. Just in episode three alone, there was an accidental kiss, boob-grope, boob-faceful, and upskirt.
 
Man, Cajun for all your KanaHana love, you haven't seen Sketchbook (according to your MAL). It's basically 13 episodes of her talking like that plus delicious slice of life goodness.

I love me some Sketchbook, but Sora talks less than some minor characters throughout the entire show. I could be remembering wrong however, its been a while since I watched it.
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
Hataraku Maou-sama 1-3

Turned out to be the most well written and consistently good show of the season. No Magi, rotoscope or CG here, just good old fashion shenanigans.

After episode 3, I'm firmly on #teamchiho. For a 15 year old anime girl, she has BALLS OF STEEL. Maou is also very lovable, and his suave easygoing nature makes Chiho's fawning actually believable. What is this, an MC who is a legit dateable guy?

Where's that image of Chiho and Emi fighting over Maou like some sassy black women.
 

Mr.Jeff

Member
I love me some Sketchbook, but Sora talks less than some minor characters throughout the entire show. I could be remembering wrong however, its been a while since I watched it.
She doesn't talk directly much but she does do a lot of narrating which is just as good. Sora is pretty :cajun in general though.

Plus it also has Makino Yui who I kinda think was a proto-version of KanaHana in some ways.

The French get everything good. This now includes Mushishi on Blu-ray.
I seem to remember reading somewhere that the Blu-Ray version of it wasn't that good? Unless they improved it or I made it up in my mind.
 

Syrinx

Member
Heartcatch Precure 31

Sasorina, Cobraja , and Kumojacky get new toys to play with. Dark Bracelets. They don't seem to do that much. They just make Desertrian more violent and make the Heart Flowers of their victims witl faster. But hey, stronger enemies is a good thing, as long as they're not massively overpowered.

Erika can seem like a bit aloof and airheaded at times, but man, she runs a tight ship at the Fashion Club. She really wants to make the fashion show a success. To help that, she enlists the help of her sister (more Momoka is never not a non-undesirable situation), and tries to enlist Yuri's help...for whatever reason. I guess it's cause Tsubomi sees her suffering and loneliness and wants to help her. She's a better person than I; I'd at some point just get tired of the repeated cold shoulders Yuri gives them. Turns out though that
Yuri lost her fairy and her heart flower in battle, so it's not really her fault.
Plus, you could see some emotion in her eyes. There's something there; it's just not powerful enough to come out.

In the end, Yuri makes a deal with Tsubomi that
if her heart flower blooms again, she will participate in the fashion show.
Since Toei has already spoiled the fact that
Cure Moonlight will return, I'll assume that she will and she will be there.
 

OceanBlue

Member
Well I generally don't find the main characters photos creepy as he normally is asking permission, whilst everyone else is stalking and taking secret photos without permission.
Sounds like they put the side characters in there to make the main character look better by comparison!

Humourously enough, while he does ask people for their photos, he has fanservice fall into his lap as well. Just in episode three alone, there was an accidental kiss, boob-grope, boob-faceful, and upskirt.
Now I'm interested.

For some reason, the impressions and screenshots of the show remind me of Amagami.
 

7Th

Member
The Persona 4 boys are totally not attractive at all compared to the P3 male cast. Male MC is the only one that's kinda handsome.
 

Metrotab

Banned
The SNAFU Show - 2

Everyone is such an asshole in this series. It's kinda refreshing, to be honest. And the MC observing the rest of the class reminds me of my loner days.
 

Stuart444

Member
OreImo S2 - 03

Well, that was a fantastic episode. Great seeing Saori without her glasses. Makes up for not seeing much/knowing much about her last season.
 

Soma

Member
The Persona 4 boys are totally not attractive at all compared to the P3 male cast. Male MC is the only one that's kinda handsome.
3 had better girls too

femc (i still love my sleepy mc though)
mitsuru
elizabeth
yukari


etc etc
 

Jintor

Member
FemC and MC are pretty rad. I wish they existed in the same universe, but apparently having one denies the existance of the other or whatever (in a meta sense)
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
Did someone say AKIHIKO
oPj1HEt.jpg

He's like Zyzz but with less douchebaggery and stereoids.
 

OceanBlue

Member
P3 girls > P4 girls, but P4 Protag > P3 guys. I never really liked Mitsuru or Akihiko for some reason. Akihiko is definitely better than most of the P4 guys though.
 

Tomat

Wanna hear a good joke? Waste your time helping me! LOL!
Hataraku Maou-sama 1-3

Turned out to be the most well written and consistently good show of the season. No Magi, rotoscope or CG here, just good old fashion shenanigans.

After episode 3, I'm firmly on #teamchiho. For a 15 year old anime girl, she has BALLS OF STEEL. Maou is also very lovable, and his suave easygoing nature makes Chiho's fawning actually believable. What is this, an MC who is a legit dateable guy?

Where's that image of Chiho and Emi fighting over Maou like some sassy black women.

Maybe it's just me, but it's odd to see a show like this that is genuinely funny with a cast that isn't completely stupid.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom