I played till like 4 in the morning last night and had a blast...
I like it a hell of a lot more than ToS, thus far (then again, I've never been a big Tales fan). I'll admit, I was a wuss and played on easy in order to avoid frustration associated with AI and such, however, it has allowed for a very smooth playing experience. ToS isn't hard at all, but the AI -NEVER- seems to listen to you. I swear, if I say "conserve your TP", they don't do it...they just keep doing whatever they want. The only action they listen to is when you tell them to do nothing. So, naturally, hearing that SO3' AI was worse, I decided I didn't want to deal with any of the problems. It's been a bit TOO easy thus far (I usually clear battles without taking any damage, for example), but it's still be a lot of fun. I prefer the controls and feel of the battles in this so far to the 2D plain of ToS. It was easy to get backed into a corner in ToS, and that was annoying as hell. Also, ToS often felt a bit less responsive (ie - all Tales games buffer your input to a degree when performing most actions).
The story isn't particularly amazing thus far, but it's WAY beyond ToS (as in, I'm actually interested in seeing what happens next). Graphics, gameplay, audio (ESPECIALLY), and story are all more appealing to me than ToS. Granted, I've only put 15 hours into ToS. I don't want to sound TOO harsh here, though, as I still enjoy playing ToS. It's a good game indeed, but it has basically been compared to SO3 for a while and everyone has suggested it to be vastly superior. I just don't understand the attention it has recieved, considering that it plays a WHOLE LOT like Eternia or any other installment.
I'm waiting for the "you can't hit the enemy on the ground" thing to come into play. At this point, enemies very rarely actually seem to fall down and I have had no problems beating the hell out of them with some decent combos (which are fun). Do later enemies just start falling down all the time or something? Most of these guys (including "bosses") will take shit tons of punishment.
Well, I guess I'm just suprised with the game. Expectations can really impact the experience. When I went into ToS, I was expecting something truly godly that stands above all RPGs released in the last few years (just based on GA's response). It's no different from your average Tales title...only it's 3D. I kinda went into SO3 expecting major issues surrounding a lot quality game...but it's so much better than I thought it would be. I guess I should have listened to Shouta here, but when so many other people trashed it...I had a difficult time hanging onto those positive impressions.