-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Star Wars Mafia |OT| A Wretched Hive of Scum and Villainy
- Thread starter MattyG
- Start date
Why do I have a sneaking suspicion that a night watch would change nothing?
Maybe more rebels would be alive if we started a night watch after day 1!
Zippedpinhead
Member
If it helps you all sleep easy you can tie me up beforehand
Zippedpinhead
Member
Those infomercial action GIFs are hilarious. My personal favorites are the cutting bread with a pyramid, and the one where they can't pour milk.
My biggest worries are that TWE/Zubz aren't what they say, and/or either Czar or Traube are playing us.
If OA comes out at as Mafia, it might be worth going after Traube. That Barry death might have been used to cover for fellow Hutts when we were close to voting them.
Alternatively, I'm going to start policy lynching the inactive players.
If OA comes out at as Mafia, it might be worth going after Traube. That Barry death might have been used to cover for fellow Hutts when we were close to voting them.
Alternatively, I'm going to start policy lynching the inactive players.
Zippedpinhead
Member
Easy? Maybe for everyone else, but for me it feels like nothing but a target on my back...
You had 2 votes. It seemed like mostly idle talk. One of those votes is OA. I guess we'll see what happens.
How do you know there are only two hutts left?
Assuming 3 Hutts at start. I'm inclined to believe it was 4. If it was only 3, they seem doomed. Maybe losing our armorers was a good thing for town, since our blasters were far more likely to kill ourselves.
On mobile I am way too lazy for that.
Shit, you might as well go all in and Double Dog Dare him.
first you were saying there were 2 main hutts, then 3, now 4? come on no way there were 6 hutts and johnny in a 23 player game. death is on the line had 27 players and 4 mafia.
You should go for redhood first. If he is another Hutt then you can detain me. Not because I am a hutt. But a giant fool who failed you big.
I would rather you not do that. The hutts are going to keep me alive and the only way I am biting the bullet is from detainment. You saved another rebel
I sure hope so.
Zippedpinhead
Member
I still say the hardest person we will have to get out is the second imperial agent. They are in this deep...
MattyG, if the only hutt aligned person left is the imperial agent, do they get to start killing at night?
MattyG, if the only hutt aligned person left is the imperial agent, do they get to start killing at night?
I never said 2 main Hutts, as far as I remember.
6 hutts seems like a lot.
OceanicAir
Member
Do not believe his lies!!!!!!
GG town
AbsolutBro
Member
RIP Zubz and TWE ;_; Tragic but not really unexpected.
RIP worthy and zubz. See you on the other side!
The thief is still at large. I personally feel like he is the last remaining Main Hutt. Which means:
Traube (ability confirmed, cant be main hutt unless there were 6)
Ejawa (no activity night 2 when thief hit QB, can only be main hutt if there were 6)
Palmer (cant be main hutt, cleared by setre and johnny)
This leaves:
Redhood56
CzarTim
Zippedpinhead
AbsolutBro
Matt Attack
Raindoc
YesNOnoNOYes
The thief is still at large. I personally feel like he is the last remaining Main Hutt. Which means:
Traube (ability confirmed, cant be main hutt unless there were 6)
Ejawa (no activity night 2 when thief hit QB, can only be main hutt if there were 6)
Palmer (cant be main hutt, cleared by setre and johnny)
This leaves:
Redhood56
CzarTim
Zippedpinhead
AbsolutBro
Matt Attack
Raindoc
YesNOnoNOYes
Extremely unlikely to be YesNo. My vote is Redhood or Matt Attack.
I agree with this. Rymuth wouldn't have left if he was a thief, so I think yesno is an ordinary rebel. And it's not me either so...
Matt Attack
Member
If you were to vote for me, what would be your reasoning? Because I'm having difficulty thinking of a good reason why I would be at the top of anybody's list of suspects.
What would be your reasoning for voting me? Is it just because I was the other suspect Palmer called out, or do you have your own suspicions against me?
I'd be happy to explain any of my actions thus far if anybody's got any questions, because I really don't want you guys to detain a rebel. We've got some strong momentum right now, let's not mess that up with a mislynch.
I have nothing against you. I was saying that it isn't me so the only other person mentioned is you. You had my back a lot of times too so i like you. I'm more suspicious of zipped than anyone else. Mainly because he was fine with being killed even though he claimed town. Why would a town want to hurt the town?
That's one way of retaliating for us getting 2 hutts in a row. 
I'm a bit suspicious of zipped right now. He was trying to get a vote going away from Oceanic, then switched to Oceanic when it was almost majority. When he saw Palmer unvoted, he backed out too, only to change again, shortly before we got majority again. It felt like puting a little effort to try and save Oceanic, but knowing it was probably a lost cause. I'd be very suspicious of Traub too, if it wasn't for the role confirm. First saving Makai, then insisting on leaving Oceanic be.
I'm a bit suspicious of zipped right now. He was trying to get a vote going away from Oceanic, then switched to Oceanic when it was almost majority. When he saw Palmer unvoted, he backed out too, only to change again, shortly before we got majority again. It felt like puting a little effort to try and save Oceanic, but knowing it was probably a lost cause. I'd be very suspicious of Traub too, if it wasn't for the role confirm. First saving Makai, then insisting on leaving Oceanic be.
Zippedpinhead
Member
While I personally think that czartim's assessment is spot on for the last hutt alive, we need to think that any non-power left could be the last imperial agent.
I'm still an ordinary rebel, and I'm sorry that my voting to close out oceanic, and then back off so czartim could post his theory (even if it was against me), and then vote again after it everything was said and done could be considered suspect.
I have no list anymore. I trust Palmer and traube, only because I don't think we have 6 hutt aligned players. I'll back any vote against eJawa and Matt attack. Czartim is probably closest to "trustworthy" as I can throw any of the rest of you. I do not trust absolutbro or redhood, but I can't see any reason to vote for them over the other two.
That leaves raindoc and yesNOnoNOyes. Raindoc, from what I can tell, matters, but not as a hutt or imperial. YesNOnoNOyes has the benefit of knowing that someone else gave up that job before he got it. Worked out really well for MattyG last game, could be the last imperial agent this time.
I'm still an ordinary rebel, and I'm sorry that my voting to close out oceanic, and then back off so czartim could post his theory (even if it was against me), and then vote again after it everything was said and done could be considered suspect.
I have no list anymore. I trust Palmer and traube, only because I don't think we have 6 hutt aligned players. I'll back any vote against eJawa and Matt attack. Czartim is probably closest to "trustworthy" as I can throw any of the rest of you. I do not trust absolutbro or redhood, but I can't see any reason to vote for them over the other two.
That leaves raindoc and yesNOnoNOyes. Raindoc, from what I can tell, matters, but not as a hutt or imperial. YesNOnoNOyes has the benefit of knowing that someone else gave up that job before he got it. Worked out really well for MattyG last game, could be the last imperial agent this time.
Zippedpinhead
Member
Town hurt town? We murdered our own force sensitive and one of our armourers. My death, as an ordinary rebel, would have hurt considerably less than those two...
Which is exactly why we need as many Rebels alive at all times. We lost 2 very important roles and while I understand your fear of detaining a rebel power role, It still rubs me the wrong way.
Zippedpinhead
Member
I can understand it rubbing you the wrong way, but both those days I said I was a viable kill that wouldn't hurt the town, and instead we had two massive implosions. At this point, yes, we need every rebel we have left, but if I could go back and switch myself for blarg or exmachina I would.
Especially blarg, I have a feeling that he would have been really entertaining to watch.
Now walk me through the reasoning why we think there is a thief. The proof is that Quantumbro lost his shield the night he revealed himself? That is pretty legit, and since no one else has come forward with a gun (because it doesn't make sense for any of us to come forward with a shield) I think that he passed a shield to either Zubz or worthy. A correlation to that is this, maybe he did pass a non shield item, my money is that quantum passed a weapon to a hutt..
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
Aaaaaaahhh Combat Buddies are gone ;____; See you on the flip side, TWE/Zubz!!!
o7
Well, as for me, I only joined on Day 4, and the theft happened on Night 2 and I think Rymuth maybe would have played a bit more if he had gotten an interesting role. I'm saying I'm just an Ordinary Rebel :< But I'm an active player !! And I dont mind non-power role, since I'm just learning the game :>
OK, on towards my thoughts!!
eJawa, you posted this on Day 3:
So far you have flown under the radar, but its Day 6 now.... and I think now it's time for you to role claim....
I'm not quite convinced that town still has any additional power roles, to be honest. We have traube still (with his override abiliy) - yay, he's still with us! - and Palmer the Bothan Spy, so if there's another power role, it seems a bit lopsided. But I'm all ears!
Palmer and Czar seems to have had some theories to test against eJawa previously and I went back to reread the thread and I saw these posts:
I also think there are still 2 main Hutts left and 1 imperial undercover.
Palmer, Czar, now that we've reached this point in the game, do you think your previous theories about eJawa have gotten more data? Can either of you explain more of these theories regarding the push for eJawa before Makai and OA?
o7
Well, as for me, I only joined on Day 4, and the theft happened on Night 2 and I think Rymuth maybe would have played a bit more if he had gotten an interesting role. I'm saying I'm just an Ordinary Rebel :< But I'm an active player !! And I dont mind non-power role, since I'm just learning the game :>
OK, on towards my thoughts!!
eJawa, you posted this on Day 3:
So far you have flown under the radar, but its Day 6 now.... and I think now it's time for you to role claim
.... I'm not quite convinced that town still has any additional power roles, to be honest. We have traube still (with his override abiliy) - yay, he's still with us! - and Palmer the Bothan Spy, so if there's another power role, it seems a bit lopsided. But I'm all ears!
Palmer and Czar seems to have had some theories to test against eJawa previously and I went back to reread the thread and I saw these posts:
I also think there are still 2 main Hutts left and 1 imperial undercover.
Palmer, Czar, now that we've reached this point in the game, do you think your previous theories about eJawa have gotten more data? Can either of you explain more of these theories regarding the push for eJawa before Makai and OA?
Why me? I can't be a main hutt, which leaves IA. If I was IA I've been doing a poor job of that by going after people as suspicious as Makai and Oceanic. IA would have to be careful and try to convince others to vote for unconventional targets. Kinda like you are trying.
For YesNo:
Now that we have gotten 2 main hutts I feel pretty confident about ejawa not being a main Hutt.
Now that we have gotten 2 main hutts I feel pretty confident about ejawa not being a main Hutt.
So far you have flown under the radar, but its Day 6 now.... and I think now it's time for you to role claim
Nah. I'd role claim if thought doing so would provide info to anyone but the hutts, which it doesn't.
I'm curious about this too. I thought it was odd Palmer was going after me, rather than someone who was caught in a probable lie.
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
Okies. So you're saying that we still has unclaimed power role! That's quite surprising... Given that we've got... 1 Former Senator, 2 Armourers, 1 force sensitive cop, 1 tracker, 1 rebel with a blaster, a bothan spy, and a pair of combat buddies. That's already... 9. With you, it would be 10!
Mull on this I shall.
Czar, oh? I don't quite understand why after we got 2 main hutts, it would mean ejawa isn't likely to be one? .___.