jshackles
Gentlemen, we can rebuild it. We have the capability to make the world's first enhanced store. Steam will be that store. Better than it was before.
Have you used other d-pads, like DS3/DS4/Wii U Classic/etc?
Cause when you say amazing and I see other people say it's alright but it's still not on the same level as those I mentioned, it makes me wonder if you have a different opinion or just lack the exposure to the other controllers.
I currently have a Wii U pro controller, my PC Xbox 360 controller (wireless, with the "improved" D-Pad), and the Xbox One controller on my desk this very minute. I feel like the Xbox One controller has the superior D-Pad of the three. The only controller you've mentioned that I don't own is the DS4, so I can say that my comparison may not be 100% complete.
I really like the Xbox One controller's D-Pad in that's it's really "clicky". Besides the audible "CLICK", it has the same feedback like you'd get from a mechanical keyboard. Well, not exactly but really close I'd say. The Wii U pro controller comes close, but doesn't quite have the same feel to it. The Xbox 360 controller, in comparison, feels incredibly mushy.
Of course, I'm no controller "expert" or anything but I've owned pretty much every "first party" controller produced since the NES. The D-Pad on the Xbox One seems superior to pretty much anything that's been released in the last few console generations.