JustinJ004
Banned
I mean, the way I see it, getting mad at Valve for taking away a second-hand key is tantamount to getting mad at the police for taking possession of a stolen TV you bought from a pawn shop. Sure, you have proof of purchase, but if the original owner can produce something more pertinent then it's only natural that you're going to lose out. There's a small distinction to be made in that in the case of SCDK, you know that the key wasn't stolen and the company is just being a dick, but Valve doesn't and can't be expected to know this -- it has to make the call with the evidence it's provided and it's going to choose physical evidence over a digital receipt.
Edit: To be perfectly clear, I'm not blaming you for getting into this situation, just disagreeing with what Valve's role should be. As I said before, most resellers try their best to make their stores seem as authentic as possible, and rarely does a day go by where someone doesn't ask if [some reseller] is an officially-recognised retailer, plus in the case of SCDK in particular it's a reasonable assumption that there situations wouldn't arise since it's affiliated with an actual retailer that ships physical goods.
I don't think Valve should be even remotely thought of or act like the police at all and when they do encounter situations where they suspect something illegal has happened they should pass the information on to a legal body to deal with instead of making rash and (in this instance at the very least) wrong decisions. They should at least ask the other party (ie me) for information before denying me access to my game surely?
I know you aren't blaming me and am sure you understand I'm pretty frustrated at the moment with all this, I was bloody loving playing DS2 - more than any game in the last 18 months or so which doesn't help my mood with the whole thing.
To be honest I'm still mostly worried about losing my saves, I'm sure I'll get my money back in the end. I just think Valve should have at least made an effort to contact me before acting
