Space Battleship Yamato 2199 1
Decided to finally check this out. After the live action movie, I really had no idea what to expect since the movie attempted to remove the campiness of having a giant WW2 ship flying around in space by grounding it in their "homage" to nu-Battlestar Galactica.
Of course, the episode opens with a dramatic space battle to get things going (thankfully sparing us the info dump for the middle of the episode - although even that infodump was placed in the context of the episode at least), but right off the bat I'm hilariously confused:
I have no idea what I think about a Japanese writer using a Battle of Bastogne reference (McAuliffe famously said "NUTS" when asked by the Germans to surrender), but it just seems kind of weird for some reason. I wonder if that was just some WW2-porn for the nerds out there or if Bastogne is considered a famous battle in Japan (I suppose mythologizing a battle where the Americans beat the Germans is better than Tawara or Guadacanal or any number of Japanese losses
).
I'm sure I'm also the only one who cares about that stuff anyway. I don't even have a problem with cultural appropriation after all (since Aria is basically Venice-porn), but you'd think that since the Japanese "lost" to the Americans, they wouldn't hold American war stories with any real reverence. It's Space Battleship Yamato and not Space Battleship USS Enterprise after all.
The only other thing that bugged me was old-fashioned 2D sea battles in space:
Given that I just watched
Star Trek 2 and Kirk kicks Khan's ass by exploiting Khan's two-dimensional thinking, seeing spaceships try to flank each other in 2D is just stupid. Even
Moretsu Space Pirates was about to do 3D space battles!
Other than that, so far the story seems as standard military scifi as the movie was. But what the heck, I'm looking for any kind of starship science fiction now, and since I'm almost done
Time Jam, this might slot in quite nicely.