So I'm curious as to what people's opinions of the VN(source) are. I've read some opinions elsewhere that seem to think somewhat highly of the source but it sounds like the usual LN bait but with some grimdark thrown in.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Summer 2014 Anime |OT2| Or, where Jexhius finally watches more Doremi for Hito.
- Thread starter Narag
- Start date
- Status
So I'm curious as to what people's opinions of the VN(source) are. I've read some opinions elsewhere that seem to think somewhat highly of the source but it sounds like the usual LN bait but with some grimdark thrown in.
AquaWateria
Member
Anything else you liked.
Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso CM, featuring Goose house's cover version of Sukima Switch's classic song "Zenryoku Shounen" (which you may be familiar with from Ouendan 2):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3puyMPeafMI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3puyMPeafMI
R_thanatos
Member
Zankyou no Terror Episode 6:
Right, I officially hate Lisa any scene she is in drags this entire anime down several notches, she is so unnaturally crowbarred into this story then even the characters can't stop remarking about it.
Anyway, I really like Five and she has quickly set herself up to be the chessmaster's chessmaster within the confines in the world. Shibuzaki shines in spite of getting sidelined for this arc for the moment.
We are also getting a fair pit of political manoeuvrings with the arrival of the new players, which probably has deeper underpinnings. Anyway, another thing I am getting tired of is the mincing of the morality of Twelve and Nine. I have no idea where this streak of nobility is coming from, or really much of anything when it comes to their morality. Anyway, this was overall a alright episode, clearly all setup to next week.
Right, I officially hate Lisa any scene she is in drags this entire anime down several notches, she is so unnaturally crowbarred into this story then even the characters can't stop remarking about it.
Obviously her purpose is being unfurled as she is going to be the X Factor that spoils Five's little game somehow.
I did like the fact that this anime subverted the lone rouge detective act.
Clannad AS: Under the Green Tree
Pretty standard recap, except for the range it covered, perhaps. I did think it would go poetic and end with Tomoya saying he loved the town, as a counterpoint to saying he hated it at the beginning of the series.
As for my final thoughts, well, I did enjoy the series. The light-hearted humor was wonderful, and the drama was really hard-hitting. I do feel that perhaps there was a bit too much emotional manipulation towards the end, but then again, it kind of makes sense for the series. In the earlier arcs, they would start out light-hearted and then go into some serious complication, which Tomoya would end up fixing by the end of the arc. In a sense, that's what the entire series was, the same dramatic arc blown up on a grand scale.
Definitely worth a watch, but expect to cry a lot towards the end.
Pretty standard recap, except for the range it covered, perhaps. I did think it would go poetic and end with Tomoya saying he loved the town, as a counterpoint to saying he hated it at the beginning of the series.
As for my final thoughts, well, I did enjoy the series. The light-hearted humor was wonderful, and the drama was really hard-hitting. I do feel that perhaps there was a bit too much emotional manipulation towards the end, but then again, it kind of makes sense for the series. In the earlier arcs, they would start out light-hearted and then go into some serious complication, which Tomoya would end up fixing by the end of the arc. In a sense, that's what the entire series was, the same dramatic arc blown up on a grand scale.
Definitely worth a watch, but expect to cry a lot towards the end.
Admiral Woofington
Member
Now I can say I'm taking a selfie of my side boob and get an A for English.
Twin Tails
Member
Look forward to this one, i played the VN a while ago. I could see this being totally alright.
http://www.fbi.gov/news/stories/2008/june/international_060308
Seems like they do operate overseas if it's terrorist involved. It's a little unusual but not of the realm of possibility.
It's also possible that the US was involved with that academy or whatever that 9/12 flashback to.
in fact you can say you are taking a selfie of my side boob while twerking in front of a yooper and still get an A
Save 'N Quit
Banned
It's an okay VN that has issues with some of the girl routes being a big hit or miss (No spoilers for now)
Characters-wise you have Yuuji (MC) being a serious, deadpan character whose easily labeled as a gary stu by some, but genuinely has some very funny moments when reacting to the stuff around him. Then you have the girls who all can be figured out the moment you see them like: Big sister slut -> Amane, Senjougahara expy -> Yumiko, and Wannabe Tsundere -> Michiru. They still have their own hidden personalities from issues dealing with something that occurred in their own back stories that you eventually find about and help them overcome.
Best part of the entire VN is easily the common route (Though Angelic Howl has the honor of being the best written) and if the anime has any sense at all, they will adapt that part.
Pretty much accurate. It's not quite as bullshit as some of Key's stuff but there's a lot of nonsense that you pretty much just have to run with. For example - The main lead is a genius assassin that works for a shadowy section the government that has a wide reach into politics despite only being 17/18 from what I recall.
Each route is quite individual though so it makes me wonder how they're going to tie them all up. They're all a bit too long to try and do a Yosuga no Sora with. Especially Amane (the red head). That one just went on and on and on.
Waifu ranking because it's standard form:
Sachi(Pink) > Michiru (Yellow) > Yumiko (Purple) >>>>>>>> Makina (Brown) >>>>> Amane (Red)
here's hoping one of them is a pet girl dub ^-^
Euphemism, or is this an all-ages VN?
Wonder what it could be. Maybe they picked up Hanayamata? Personally I'd rather NISA get that one, but we'll see.
Save 'N Quit
Banned
Steam version is all-ages.
The fan translated version is 18+ and includes all the sex scenes.
Snkfanatic
Banned
I hope it is finally some news about the Non Non Biyori release
The main character's background is pretty silly but IMO the scenarios behind the girls are probably more nonsensical, especially with how they're treated.
Avoid Cardcaptors at all costs. If thats what you watched, then watch it uncut and subbed again like its the first time because it quite literally is.
No worries. that song will drill its way deep into your brain over time.
Her writing is the most incredibly melodramatic tear your eyes out of your face sorta stuff. I kinda like how overdone it is.
Only thing keeping me watching it thats for sure. I dont talk about this show, but Im still watching it for her.
You might be right. I love Hajime so much as a result. Like looking in a mirror at my own personality
Me..I collect mugs along with all the other things. I have a few dozen by now.
Actually, when I get my own place and have some more space, Ill display my mugs and car models for an even more eclectic looking room than I have now.
Try to picture how fun all that will look together.
No but Sabagebu is delivering some great entertainment.
you know... you guys are temping me to watch love lab...
but then I have a feeling you won't like it when I come back and talk about how stupid and unfunny it is (I mean there is a small chance I won't hate it and I would try my best to find redeeming points, but I can't remember the last time a k-onish (bunch of cute girls in a random club) looking show was actually enjoyable for me)
but then I have a feeling you won't like it when I come back and talk about how stupid and unfunny it is (I mean there is a small chance I won't hate it and I would try my best to find redeeming points, but I can't remember the last time a k-onish (bunch of cute girls in a random club) looking show was actually enjoyable for me)
Oh definitely, I was just giving that as an example since it's not giving anything away. A lot of the stuff in the VN follows it's own vein of logic that while kinda makes sense is totally far removed from how common sense tells you it would happen.
Edit: Actually, thinking on, that's not true for Michiru's route. That's straight up bullshit.
Snkfanatic
Banned
It is on my to watch list...but then again I love K-On.
Should have lifted it straight from the OP.
Tokyo Ghoul 07
Censorship strikes again and again. The scene before OP was especially jarring.
This academy that Amon spoke of must be some serious doping center. All those doves can stand up to Ghouls with no problem.
OP is the best of the season and the new ED is a nice companion to it.
in general when I think moe I think
when I think k-on past the first few episodes I think
>.>
but azumanga doesn't fill me with the urge to burn things just by mentioning it's name because while the main character is cute, there is a point to the show aside from eating cake and falling over.
and k-onish isn't all female cast it's
all female cast of moe girls, with a club or club like setting.
NaDannMaGoGo
Member
Chihayafuru - 25 [Finished]
Well, I enjoyed this quite a bit. Didn't even feel like fast-forwarding or anything really. In my book, there was a good balance between character development and time spent on Karuta. I mean, both were pretty closely intertwined anyways.
Most surprising to me is how I never really got bored of that sport; there seems to be quite a lot of depth and the mindgames are funy to follow. Now, despite not actually knowing Karuta in real life at all (gonna search for some YouTube videos though), I have to assume that a lot of the aspect surrounding that sport are exaggerated in this anime. While mindgames and thinking about strategy are one thing, these characters, analyze their opponents and make huge changes to their playstyle while often succeeding at doing so. It's just a bit hard to believe that they could do it to such a degree when the game is constantly going on and they mustn't forget the card placements as well as being very focused.
One small issue I could point out though, is that it's kinda hard to follow the game at times, especially when you can't speak Japanese and have to rely on subtitles. That makes e.g. some of the 'same syllable' explanations somewhat confusing to follow in English. The show also doesn't really give the audience any more information about the state of the game than is available to the actual players. So you can simply never know what the right next move is supposed to be. Still, I actually prefer this as that has its own advantages, especially when tension is concerned.
That said, nothing appears to be comically over.exaggerated in a way where I'd just start rolling my eyes. Also for the sake of presentation (and being an anime) you want to go a bit over the top to make it more interesting.
The characterization is pretty strong overall. Our core trio Chihaya, Taichi and Arata get most of the focus (well Arata when he actually appears in an episode ;P) but the other 3 school club members also get their own fair share. So do side characters, especially most opponents we encounter. Those aren't just that, they're actual human beings with their own reasonings etc.
I think I enjoyed following Taichi's character development the most so far. While I was looking forward to Arata the most and he doesn't make that many appearances, I actually ended up being somewhat fine with that because the rest of the cast was good enough.
I wasn't expecting this season to end just in the middle of...nothing special though. It makes sense though if the second season is just continuing right where this one ends. It also would've been pretty unbelievable if Chihaya and co. actually made it to the national grand finals this quickly.
I think with this being my first 'sports anime' is a bit advantageous as I'm not tired of going through the same formula (that probably being a bunch of diverse characters, their sport, and slow climb to success). After all the "plot" is of course rather predictable with these kind of stories.
Now, I guess I would have to dive into the second season. However earlier comments made it seem like that one isn't very good? edit: The premise of getting another whole 5 new members for the schools club doesn't sound very appealing btw. Would rather like 1-2 more and continue focusing on everyone already established.
I'd btw. rate this show a 7 or 8/10, can't quite decide just yet.
Well, I enjoyed this quite a bit. Didn't even feel like fast-forwarding or anything really. In my book, there was a good balance between character development and time spent on Karuta. I mean, both were pretty closely intertwined anyways.
Most surprising to me is how I never really got bored of that sport; there seems to be quite a lot of depth and the mindgames are funy to follow. Now, despite not actually knowing Karuta in real life at all (gonna search for some YouTube videos though), I have to assume that a lot of the aspect surrounding that sport are exaggerated in this anime. While mindgames and thinking about strategy are one thing, these characters, analyze their opponents and make huge changes to their playstyle while often succeeding at doing so. It's just a bit hard to believe that they could do it to such a degree when the game is constantly going on and they mustn't forget the card placements as well as being very focused.
One small issue I could point out though, is that it's kinda hard to follow the game at times, especially when you can't speak Japanese and have to rely on subtitles. That makes e.g. some of the 'same syllable' explanations somewhat confusing to follow in English. The show also doesn't really give the audience any more information about the state of the game than is available to the actual players. So you can simply never know what the right next move is supposed to be. Still, I actually prefer this as that has its own advantages, especially when tension is concerned.
That said, nothing appears to be comically over.exaggerated in a way where I'd just start rolling my eyes. Also for the sake of presentation (and being an anime) you want to go a bit over the top to make it more interesting.
The characterization is pretty strong overall. Our core trio Chihaya, Taichi and Arata get most of the focus (well Arata when he actually appears in an episode ;P) but the other 3 school club members also get their own fair share. So do side characters, especially most opponents we encounter. Those aren't just that, they're actual human beings with their own reasonings etc.
I think I enjoyed following Taichi's character development the most so far. While I was looking forward to Arata the most and he doesn't make that many appearances, I actually ended up being somewhat fine with that because the rest of the cast was good enough.
I wasn't expecting this season to end just in the middle of...nothing special though. It makes sense though if the second season is just continuing right where this one ends. It also would've been pretty unbelievable if Chihaya and co. actually made it to the national grand finals this quickly.
I think with this being my first 'sports anime' is a bit advantageous as I'm not tired of going through the same formula (that probably being a bunch of diverse characters, their sport, and slow climb to success). After all the "plot" is of course rather predictable with these kind of stories.
Now, I guess I would have to dive into the second season. However earlier comments made it seem like that one isn't very good? edit: The premise of getting another whole 5 new members for the schools club doesn't sound very appealing btw. Would rather like 1-2 more and continue focusing on everyone already established.
I'd btw. rate this show a 7 or 8/10, can't quite decide just yet.
Snkfanatic
Banned
Hehe ya I understand that that style of show is not for everyone. Those shows usually bring a huge smile to my face so I tend to steer towards them. I can't help it..the moe has me.
AquaWateria
Member
What's the VN called?
That stereotype doesn't even hold any water upon watching the actual show. Once Azusa appears the show reveals its true nature, and then becomes some of the best emotional anime I've seen in S2. The last stretch of episodes and the movie is powerful stuff.
AquaWateria
Member
Should have lifted it straight from the OP.
Tokyo Ghoul 07
Censorship strikes again and again. The scene before OP was especially jarring.
This academy that Amon spoke of must be some serious doping center. All those doves can stand up to Ghouls with no problem.
OP is the best of the season and the new is a nice companion to it.
Hmm I really want to know how far this adaption is gonna cover.
Turin Turambar
Member
Grisaia no Kajitsu.
Snkfanatic
Banned
Ya I was going to post something along these lines. I can see why people think that with season one but damn did I get hit hard with the end of season 2 and the movie. Especially if you really love the show, it is a mix of happy and sad at the same time.
The last School Festival of season 2...man. Tears were shed.
Moral Panic
Member
I love Chihayafuru. Great female lead (yes she is a ditz but it isn't hammed up too much), the sport was completely foreign to me before watching the show but I really like the way they presented it. It got my AOTY 2012
Moral Panic said:
Denki-gai no Honya-san PV
It's about the workers at an Akihabara manga shop. This and Shirobako will be my fill of anime-about-anime this upcoming season.
It's about the workers at an Akihabara manga shop. This and Shirobako will be my fill of anime-about-anime this upcoming season.
i've seen all of season 1 of k-on and the first 1-2 eps of season 2. (I was hoping they were going to actually do something, but alas they just went right back to doing nothing)
up until that point any scenes not related to falling down or eating cake feel like they are there just to pad out the show and get to more scenes of falling down or eating cake...
perhaps the second season/movie actually eventually go somewhere but their pointless screwing around (and horrendous season 2 opening song) drove me away from the series for good.
I wanted a series about creating music with friends, and when they actually go to do a concert what happens... we hear the final note of the concert... we don't see anything -_- It doesn't help that I detest yui and didn't enjoy following her adventures in tripping at all.
- Status