Reptars Revenge
Member
Damn I didnt know it was a three way cross over with "Chicago Fire". Flash you are embarrassing Earth 1
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Supergirl |OT| Adventure Runs in the Family - Mondays 8/7c on CBS
- Thread starter Skux
- Start date
- Status
MikeBreezy92
Member
Oliver: So How was Earth 3?
BlackGhost
Banned
Zero...........are you Grant Austin?
Honestly if that was one of the series best episodes, I guess I know I don't really want to watch Supergirl.
StarCreator
Member
I wouldn't label this episode anywhere near series best.
Only episode of Supergirl I've seen since the pilot - I had no idea this show could be even cheesier than a CW show. But here we are. I thought it was still a fun crossover though. The highlight of the episode was whenever Barry and Kara were looking giddy with each other.
This was very fun, but also hilariously bad.
I think my biggest surprises from never having watched this show were
A) Supergirl being adorable as fuck
B) That Winn guy actually being straight, cause from everything I had seen in the previews, I expected him to be token gay friend character.
Firemen saving the day was.....man. Just....man.
I think my biggest surprises from never having watched this show were
A) Supergirl being adorable as fuck
B) That Winn guy actually being straight, cause from everything I had seen in the previews, I expected him to be token gay friend character.
Firemen saving the day was.....man. Just....man.
The nature of a crossover drawing audiences is that it's self contained though. You draw people in for one big event. Doing it over two weeks, or setting up a plot line that requires advanced knowledge isn't really a sharp idea. It's why Siobhan's stuff was kept simple and vague and they didn't bother messing with Alex and the Martian at all.
It was kind of nice to have the people of a superhero city actually do something.
More so since the heroes didn't even think to do the same.
Obliterator
Member
Episode was ultra cheesy but I enjoyed it a lot.
The people of a superhero city doing something is good and I like it.
The people taking out the two supervillains while the heroes are absolutely shitting the bed eventhough they should at least put up a fight OR put the villains into a vulnerable situation, that I do not like.
Like,the firefighters literally just shot water at the two. They weren't even being pressured by one of the heroes or something.
At least give Barry SOMETHING to do, I know he is just a guest but come on.
And they knew Flash fans would be watching, so make Supergirl at least a LITTLE competent instead of this.
DAVIDHUXLEY
Member
After the dourness of other ip's, extra cheese please.
Good episode overall but the fight in the park was not the best,special effects wise and all,Banshee's make-up was kinda bad also...so did this show not get a confirmation of renewal yet...? I mean it would be really sad that Benoist doesnt get to play Supergirl anymore,she is just perfect for the role.
Jon Carter
Member
Having Barry there further highlighted to me how Kara and Jimmy have zero chemistry.
fallengorn
Bitches love smiley faces
I enjoyed it. Going in, wasn't expecting it to go all Spider-man at the end but it was fine.
It was worth it just to see Barry and Kara together.
It was worth it just to see Barry and Kara together.
A kryptonitian birthing matrix?
What a cop-out.
And he is friends with Felicity Smoak
Lactose_Intolerant
Member
Seriously, the villains on this show are horrible. Maybe comic book attire just doesn't work in the real world or the show doesn't have the budget to do it justice but each week they all look terrible.
Even the other Krytonians have crappy outfits.
Not everyone have the coolest villain costume ever like Reverse Flash.
Livewire was a lot better in her solo episode.
Costume design on Supergirl is definitely weak outside of the leading lady. Most superhero shows frankly, DD's outfit oh boy. The Vancouver team is just straight up better, but have even less budget.
Stallion Dan
Member
Sadly it was, even with the dud final showdown.
StarCreator
Member
Seriously, let's review Livewire from her debut:
This episode doesn't even come close... She isn't even demonstrating the same power set at all! I guess that's what happens when you have to do effects for three metahumans instead of just one.
This episode doesn't even come close... She isn't even demonstrating the same power set at all! I guess that's what happens when you have to do effects for three metahumans instead of just one.
I wouldn't call that one of the series best. Livewire, Human for a Day, For the Girl Who Has Everything & Falling were all better. Maybe 8 & 9 too.
Diggle's reactions to Supergirl and Martian Manhunter
That episode also had a lot more Cat Grant.
Diggle's reactions to Supergirl and Martian Manhunter
That episode also had a lot more Cat Grant.
Dean Cain is in the hands of Cadmus now, all will be fixed shortly.
It was just as bad as every crossover episode. The show gets neutered for an episode. It was cute and lite and kind of fun. Cat Grant was thankfully consistently great. Nice knock at the CW too. Amazed that Martian Manhunter wasn't even in this episode at all. Do they save money per episode by not including everybody?
The race should have been a lot longer and more fun! Craptacular ending. I wanted to see them race over land, mountains, rivers, and the ocean before he warped back. Silly me.
I realize it is pointless to apply physics or rules to a superhero show crossing over with another, but ... Barry ends up on "Earth-3" shall we call it, for the first time, and even though he probably left Central City, which exists on this Earth, he BAMF!'s to this Earth's National city right as Supergirl, the heroine, is thrown out a window, and catches her.
And everybody just loves each other. This is the lightest of all entertainment. Where is the dark , the stormy rain, the CGI destruction? *
* just poking fun, I still enjoyed it for what it was.
The race should have been a lot longer and more fun! Craptacular ending. I wanted to see them race over land, mountains, rivers, and the ocean before he warped back. Silly me.
I realize it is pointless to apply physics or rules to a superhero show crossing over with another, but ... Barry ends up on "Earth-3" shall we call it, for the first time, and even though he probably left Central City, which exists on this Earth, he BAMF!'s to this Earth's National city right as Supergirl, the heroine, is thrown out a window, and catches her.
And everybody just loves each other. This is the lightest of all entertainment. Where is the dark , the stormy rain, the CGI destruction? *
* just poking fun, I still enjoyed it for what it was.
KDash31987
Member
Oh, hey, one of my old posts got quoted. Cool.
Crossover was fun. Can't wait to see them together again.
He's been on the show a bunch of times. Also, he (Jay Jackson) was a real TV newscaster long before he played Perd Hapley. And he's popped up in a whole lotta stuff.
Crossover was fun. Can't wait to see them together again.
He's been on the show a bunch of times. Also, he (Jay Jackson) was a real TV newscaster long before he played Perd Hapley. And he's popped up in a whole lotta stuff.
OdysseusVA
Banned
kylecoley182
Banned
This isn't earth 3 heres why:
Barry said he saw evil visions of them selfs while going though the breachs
Barry said he saw evil visions of them selfs while going though the breachs
dead souls
Member
Loved it.
Can Grant be in every episode?
Can Grant be in every episode?
Pretty sure he was just talking about Earth-2.
kylecoley182
Banned
oh thats right...
the_firewithin
Member
Well Olsen has no charisma so this isn't hard to pull off. Wynn had more chemistry with Barry too
Maddocks
Member
I kept hoping that Zoom would show up just to say,"never forget, I'm the fastest man alive." and just leave.
Loved the episode though, made sense they would be friends because they both have seem some weird shit in their own words, and it seems Barry has visited earth 3 to see the evil versions of everyone. Future episode!
Loved the episode though, made sense they would be friends because they both have seem some weird shit in their own words, and it seems Barry has visited earth 3 to see the evil versions of everyone. Future episode!
Jorok Goldblade
Member
Kara was flirting with James by giving an exposition dump on how they're going to merge Earth Arrow with Earth Supergirl.
- Status