Weisberg and Fields occasionally will describe the scene in text, but in this seasons long sex scene between Phillip and Elizabeth, set to Queens Under Pressure, the script had just three words: They fuck hard.
But, Weisberg added, We spent a lot of time talking about those three words.
Which, of course, can lead to its own troubles. Well sometimes be in the strange position of talking about specifics you wouldnt otherwise talk about, Fields said, recalling a much-discussed episode of The Americans where Phillip and Elizabeths teenage daughter walks in on them giving each other oral sex at the same time, better known as sixty-nining.
There was a lot of discussion as to what that act might be, but then when we got down to what that act might belook, there are a lot of variations of that act, Fields said. The question at hand, as posed by episode director Thomas Schlamme: Whose ass are we going to see, here?
What works on-screen in any context is going to be different from viewer to viewer; theres probably nothing harder to define, though, than a great sex scene. And thats because sex is, more or less, everythingthe meeting point of self, intimacy, biological drive, and desire. Even when it is consensual and enthusiastic, it can still contain multitudes: Sex can be routine or eventful; it can be easy or challenging. It can be harmful and healing; it can be good, bad, or just meh.
But there are some guidelines. When asked about what makes a great sex scene, all three showrunners pointed to the emotional state of the characters. For Weisberg and Fields spies, its about the complicated and not always gratifying quest for closeness. The characters claw through their multilayered identities towards the intimacy, Fields said. That allows you to feel the importance of intimacy, that people will fight their way through that.