Since you don't need a clutch to do that, I don't see how a DSG in manual shifting mode wouldn't be able to provide you with the same experience.
I'm sure it would but I don't own one and none of the dealerships around here seem like they want to let me borrow a DSG equipped sports car for a day to try it out. The bums!
But seriously. The best DSG setup with paddle shifters still isn't going to be as interactive as a good old fashioned manual with a proper clutch. There's a fun factor and a really satisfying feeling if you do it right, especially with the heal and toe action.