• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The BIG BIG MacWorld Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
shantyman said:
Shog, you were wrong about iLife being inlcuded. Of course I think it's beyond cheap that there is no keyboard or mouse.

I said iLife probably would be included! I said no iLife and iWorks.
 

scorcho

testicles on a cold fall morning
tedtropy said:
It certainly doesn't make me angry. More competition is always a good thing, I just think there's better existing devices in the arena that Apple will now no doubt dominate. Namely, devices like the Creative MuVo Micro N200. MP3 playback, FM tuner, voice/FM recording, line-in encoding and...gasp, a backlit LCD. Not to mention a 15 hour battery life. Yeah, you'll pay a little more for it, but it does the idea right. It's called paying for quality, come no, Apple fans live by that matra. :D

prod10737_hdr_1_6_1.jpg

i think a more salient comparison would be with the Muvo TX FM line, as it's a usb thumbdrive with a glued on lcd screen and detachable battery pack. it's basically what the iPod Shuffle should've been if Apple weren't so damn innovative.

p4s.jpg


i bought my 256mb version for 80 bucks on black friday. has an FM tuner, microphone/radio recording, backlit screen and 15 hours o'battery life with one AAA battery. USB 2.0 interface to boot.
 

Timbuktu

Member
Lyte Edge said:
I almost wonder if Apple just didn't have anything really new to show for the beginning of this year, and just "slapped" the Mac Mini and iPod Shuffle together just to have something "new" to sell.

The Mac Mini is really 'new' for Apple, they've never gone downmarket before. This is a new direction for them. I don't remember a Macworld keynote getting this much attention from mainstream media or here at GAF for a long time.
 
shantyman said:
Oops. You know why I am a bitter old man? Because Taka-arashii was removed from VF4!

I only played with Aoi, you know that. You do remember repeatedly getting whupped by my Aoi, don't ya? :p




shantyman said:
In all seriousness, do you like the mini in any way?

It looks good, but that's hardly a surprise. Not anything beyond some of the specialized mini ITX computer boxes from Japan, Taiwan, and Korea though. Check out the Soldams and even some of the Shuttles for comparo.

The problems is the G4. With the G5 (as in, the current PowerMac CPU), it would have made for a true successor to the Cube.
 

tedtropy

$50/hour, but no kissing on the lips and colors must be pre-separated
scorcho said:
i think a more salient comparison would be with the Muvo TX FM line, as it's a usb thumbdrive with a glued on lcd screen and detachable battery pack. it's basically what the iPod Shuffle should've been if Apple weren't so damn innovative.

p4s.jpg


i bought my 256mb version for 80 bucks on black friday. has an FM tuner, microphone/radio recording, backlit screen and 15 hours o'battery life with one AAA battery. USB 2.0 interface to boot.

Yep, or that. The Muvos are truly amazing little devices. Meanwhile Apple basically just mimicks what others have already done, rips off the screen, and suddenly it's brilliant.
 

shantyman

WHO DEY!?
Shogmaster said:
I only played with Aoi, you know that. You do remember repeatedly getting whupped by my Aoi, don't ya? :p

Of course I remember, provided you remember losing to Taka just as much!
 

Timbuktu

Member
Ok. Some industry reactions to put this in some perspective:

Lawrence Schear writes:I've been playing with this ipod shuffle for about an hour now; at first I was skeptical because of the lack of display, the emphasis on 'random' play, and the overly simplistic design (this thing is really just a plastic flash keychain all ipodded up). But now I understand- your musical interface is basically invisible and there are no decisions to make. By the way- floods of people were streaming in as I left the Apple store and several employees at the door were handing out shuffles from boxes by the dozens. People were buying 3, 4, 5 of these things at a time. Amazing what a brand can make people do.

"The Mac Mini is a great way to get OSX power without the dosh. I'm thinking about picking one up myself."
- John Biggs, Technical Editor, Laptop, PC Upgrade, Surge

"The Mac mini is 2 x 6.5 inches. Your car stereo is 2 x 7 inches. Are you thinking what I'm thinking?"
- Matt Myers, System Administrator, Tru Playa


"I think the Mini is a home run and will only encourage more potential switchers to leave Windows in the dust, although I'm holding out hope that a $699 or $799 iBook is not too far behind.


As for the Shuffle, I'm not to keen on the lack of an LCD for selecting specific tracks. (1GB is a fair amount of music.) But for the price I suspect that even existing iPod owners will snatch one up for their workouts."
- Mark Spoonauer, Editor in Chief, Laptop Magazine

"The Mac Mini idea rocks. A cute, inexpensive personal computer complete with all the productivity software a casual user needs, the iLife apps, and the iPod's good looks? Brilliant. With its small size and quiet design, it might make a good addition to the home entertainment center too.


The only thing that wowed me about the iPod Shuffle was the price. The lack of a display kills it for me. Forget putting audio books on it, Podcasts, etc. -- it's pretty much a music only device if you can't pick tracks. Gotta love how they took its most glaring limitation and tried to tout it as its coolest feature."
- Anonymous former gadget magazine editor who now works at a large software company in Redmond.

"The most impressive thing to me about the iPod shuffle is the price point - $149 for 1 GB of flash storage is a lot of bang for the buck. The usual impressive Apple styling is there, but I'm dubious on the lack of a screen - what if you actually want to listen to a certain song? The Apple hype machine spit out some pretty text about how cool it is to be "random", but I wonder how well that will work in real life...


Based on what I've seen so far, the Apple Mini is quite impressive. I'm blown away by how small it is - I was expecting some sort of Blade-sever-esque size, but the Apple Mini makes my Shuttle XPCs look like a full tower. The specs for it are absolutely pathetic (167 mhz bus speed? I can type faster than that), but people aren't going to buy one because it will their fast, main computer. They'll buy one as a second or even third computer, something to compliment what they already have, or to fit into a tight space. Hell, I've never owned a Mac (and frequently smack Apple around) and even I'm considering picking one of these up. The Apple OS has always intrigued me, but the price point always put the idea of getting one on the "When I get $2000 that I have nothing better to do with" shelf."
- Jason Dunn, Executive Editor & Publisher, Digital Media Thoughts


"Mac mini = adorable, and sharp market placement to boot. I wanted to hate the ipod shuffle. And I do hate the chumps that are buying 5 at a time just because it's an ipod, but I have to say, the screens on most flash players are useless anyway, and I usually set mine to random anyway. Also $150 for a gig player (if I'm remembering right) is a really goddamn good price for a player, let alone one that apple has deigned to come down from its mountain to bestow upon us.
- Scott Alexander, Senior Editor, Playboy

"I will buy ipod shuffle in the hope that now I don't have an excuse of not getting to the gym. mac mini is going to my five year old niece, so that i can make sure she doesn't get bad habits like windows."
- Om Malik, GigaOm
 
Timbuktu said:
Ok. Some industry reactions to put this in some perspective:

Christ do I ever hate the overly cute pro Apple drivel.

Hey, I personally don't like Windows, but I don't have to look like a whiney loser when trying to needlessly bash it.
 

Phoenix

Member
nitewulf said:
exactly. all corporate culture adheres to the *.doc format. you may do whatever you wish, but you better make sure there is a doc version available for everyone else. MS Word is staying proper where it is.

Every product in the world that wants to export Word format exports the well understood and document Word95 format. Most compatibility problems with documents come from using features that didn't exist in Word95 and therefore couldn't be exported.

My corporate culture supports the "export it to PDF or web" format. But that's just us, while Time Warner is a huge company, we aren't the only folks in the world.... just a lot of them :)
 

Phoenix

Member
gohepcat said:
Hahahaha
haha
hahahahaha.

You are outta your friggin mind! I'd be willing to bet that I actually watched over a million word and excel documents go though our mail servers at work to every part of the globe, and to every kind of business in the world.

If you're not a Windows centric organization (and there is no way we could be) and have considerable number of Macs, Linux boxes, Solaris and other varied *nix worksations around Office simply cannot be your format of choice because of such poor support on the other platforms that your workforce is using. At best you export it to Word95, but more often than not you're exporting .pdf because you know that EVERYONE can see it.
 

Dilbert

Member
Jesus fucking Christ, you can't have a Mac-related thread without Shogmaster shitting all over it.

GREAT JOB, MAN! I applaud you and your diligent work!
 

Dilbert

Member
nitewulf said:
since i'm here already, how do i shuffle songs with my ipod? when i select shuffle, it shuffles my entire library. i dont want that! is there any way to shuffle a playlist? or by genre?
Starting at the main menu:

Settings > Shuffle (Off | Songs | Albums)

I suspect that you want to pick "Songs" almost every time, given your question. Then, browse to your desired playlist and start playing. It will shuffle whatever songs are in that playlist.
 

xsarien

daedsiluap
-jinx- said:
Jesus fucking Christ, you can't have a Mac-related thread without Shogmaster shitting all over it.

GREAT JOB, MAN! I applaud you and your diligent work!


You know, oddly enough I'd say he's been remarkably restrained in this thread. Nothing bad to say about the Mac Mini, nothing good to say either, but still... ;)
 
xsarien said:
You know, oddly enough I'd say he's been remarkably restrained in this thread. Nothing bad to say about the Mac Mini, nothing good to say either, but still... ;)


Hey lay off! He's my groupie! Get yer own.
 

cja

Member
iPod shuffle UK/Ireland pricing
512MB = £69/€99
1GB = £99/€149

Very competitive for this side of the pond. Flash Muvo and iriver players cost as much for only half the capacity. Prices are going to be slashed! Yep, no screen, no FM radio, no voice recorder but the brand name makes up for all this and more with most consumers.

The pricing really negates the point of using a lot of computing devices for mp3 playback, be that a palm, laptop or media player. A 512MB memory stick costs £69.99, a 512MB iPod shuffle costs £69.00. No brainer.
 

fart

Savant
i kind of wish they'd announced more factory stereo ipod connectors, otherwise still pretty underwhelmed. just about everything needed a slightly lower price point.
 

mattiewheels

And then the LORD David Bowie saith to his Son, Jonny Depp: 'Go, and spread my image amongst the cosmos. For every living thing is in anguish and only the LIGHT shall give them reprieve.'
Can anyone else watch the stream at all? It stops like every 3 seconds with me, I just gave up after a while.
 

mrklaw

MrArseFace
cja said:
iPod shuffle UK/Ireland pricing
512MB = £69/€99
1GB = £99/€149

Very competitive for this side of the pond. Flash Muvo and iriver players cost as much for only half the capacity. Prices are going to be slashed! Yep, no screen, no FM radio, no voice recorder but the brand name makes up for all this and more with most consumers.

The pricing really negates the point of using a lot of computing devices for mp3 playback, be that a palm, laptop or media player. A 512MB memory stick costs £69.99, a 512MB iPod shuffle costs £69.00. No brainer.


Very good point for Europeans. I have a 512MB memory stick for my PSP, but so far its crammed with videos (thats what PSP is good for). So it'd be just as easy to drop one of these in for music only for the same price as another memory stick - and its no size at all (wonders if the headphones are removable to use for PSP as well)
 

Manics

Banned
Regardless of what you think about the iPod shuffle, it's a starting point for Apple's introduction to flash-based players. While other companies have had versions for years, and have improved on these versions, apple has just put this thing out. They'll come out with other flash-based players, and people will rave about them, and the improvements they've made from the shuffle.

I still think it's a good first step and lots of people will get into this market picking up a shuffle.

With regards to the Mini, I don't understand how anyone can bash this thing? I think it's a brilliant move by Apple to market to PC users who have curiously thought about checking out an Apple, but were always put off by the price and commitment to owning an entirely different OS than they're used to. Now they can get the Mini which is a self contained system from which you can learn all about the Mac OS and maybe even start to like it.

I've been a PC user all my life, have never even turned on a Mac before in my life, and I'm seriously thinking of picking up a Mini just for the hell of it cause it's so cheap and I want to know more about what Apple is all about. I think this thing has the potential to be huge.
 

Manics

Banned
tedtropy said:
Yeah, Jobs is certainly more suave when concerned to the sexy beast that is Bill Gates. But at the end of the day, which of the two ridiculously rich men is the richest? Eh?



So in the end, it all comes down to a pissing contest huh? Who's got the biggest wang?
 
I have no desire to buy an iShuffle, but I do not at all understand the hating.

It's a gaddamned budget product, eeking into the under-$100 slot to be an impulse purchase. It's not that much more expensive than the memory stick, and it plays music.

Hell yes, spending a little more, you can get a better player (that's larger) in other flash players. And spending more still, you can get a much better price/storage ratio in an even larger box with a micro-player, or spend more yet, and get an even better price/storgae ratio in a full-sized media player.

It's a niche Apple is filling, and it's pretty fucking smart to do so. The iShuffle will probably be a hit-- so what's wrong with it? If people want it, Apple did their job.

(Now, the iPod Mini I really don't understand the success of-- but that's another topic)
 

tedtropy

$50/hour, but no kissing on the lips and colors must be pre-separated
Manics said:
So in the end, it all comes down to a pissing contest huh? Who's got the biggest wang?

Perhaps you didn't read the last two sentences, but dude, I was joking. But yes, Bill Gates win teh OS warzorz.
 

Manics

Banned
tedtropy said:
Perhaps you didn't read the last two sentences, but dude, I was joking. But yes, Bill Gates win teh OS warzorz.


The last 2 sentences? I quoted your entire post.

Difficult to tell when someone is joking or serious especially in a forum full of Apple lovers and haters. I'm neither but was just making the point that the most successful person doesn't always equate to the best person.
 

tedtropy

$50/hour, but no kissing on the lips and colors must be pre-separated
Manics said:
The last 2 sentences? I quoted your entire post.

Difficult to tell when someone is joking or serious especially in a forum full of Apple lovers and haters. I'm neither but was just making the point that the most successful person doesn't always equate to the best person.

But at the end of the day, which of the two ridiculously rich men is the richest?

I was hoping that sentence would've denoted the futility of the debates people have between the two. No big deal. Both Bill Gates and Steve Jobs have been more successful in life than any of us will ever be, they just excel in different arenas.
 

Phoenix

Member
First iMac Mini deals

http://www.macmall.com

iMac Mini
+ free keyboard
+ free mouse
+ free shipping
+ free headphones
+ free earbuds
+ free wireless G router
* photo printer for <$10


MacMall has a long history of giving away loads of stuff when they start their mac sales and I expect that in their next deal revision they'll do the 512MB bump for free (with $25 installation fee) as they do with all their other machines.
 

xsarien

daedsiluap
So I'm not sure if this has been brought up yet:

http://www.apple.com/macmini/specs.html

Is there ANYTHING about the Mac Mini that's user-serviceable? Must the towers be the only Apples you can actually open? As much as I'd like a MM with a gig of memory, I'm not paying Apple $400 for the part and labor for an upgrade that could, between Crucial or Kingston, cost half of that.
 

RevenantKioku

PEINS PEINS PEINS PEINS PEINS PEINS PEINS PEINS PEINS PEINS PEINS PEINS oh god i am drowning in them
Phoenix said:
MacMall has a long history of giving away loads of stuff when they start their mac sales and I expect that in their next deal revision they'll do the 512MB bump for free (with $25 installation fee) as they do with all their other machines.

And if you let me know when that happens, I'll be quite indebted. ^_^
 

tedtropy

$50/hour, but no kissing on the lips and colors must be pre-separated
xsarien said:
So I'm not sure if this has been brought up yet:

http://www.apple.com/macmini/specs.html

Is there ANYTHING about the Mac Mini that's user-serviceable? Must the towers be the only Apples you can actually open? As much as I'd like a MM with a gig of memory, I'm not paying Apple $400 for the part and labor for an upgrade that could, between Crucial or Kingston, cost half of that.

I'm guessing its using a laptop form-factor hard drive, although from what I've read on Apple's site, it claims its only upgradeable to 80GB. That may be increased with a firmware update, but obviously this machine was not designed to be all that expandable internally.
 

xsarien

daedsiluap
tedtropy said:
I'm guessing its using a laptop form-factor hard drive, although from what I've read on Apple's site, it claims its only upgradeable to 80GB. That may be increased with a firmware update, but obviously this machine was not designed to be all that expandable internally.

Well, neither is a laptop, and even those have memory expansions. Apple shows the thing "naked" on their website, it looks like a perfectly standard, 184-pin memory module, sitting right on the outside of the "cage". I refuse to believe that there isn't a way for someone to just pop this sucker open, hell, people figured out how to do it with iPods.

(I mean, Jesus, I don't even think the gumdrop iMacs needed to be taken in to have the memory installed.)


Someone tell me I'm horribly misinformed, I'd love a MM.
 

tedtropy

$50/hour, but no kissing on the lips and colors must be pre-separated
Willco said:
If I can get more RAM and it still was ~$550, I might get a Mac mini.

Yeah, 256MB definitely ain't cutting it these days. I'd say the video adapter is a big bottleneck, but this is by no means intended to be a gaming machine. With a little more HID capacity and more RAM, this would be a sweet little machine for doing everything but gaming and advanced video/audio editing.

If Apple could make this sucker $500 flat, with 512MB of ram, and a fricken' keyboard and mouse included, I'd be especially impressed,
 

Willco

Hollywood Square
xsarien said:
1.25 GHz G4
512 MB
40 GB HDD

$574.00, free shipping.

Eh, that's a little much. I was hoping we could get that Mac Mall deal where it'd be like ~$530 w/ 512MB RAM.

What software is include, btw?
 

Willco

Hollywood Square
I tell you what Apple, you give me these specs for $559.99, you got yourself a deal!

1.42GHz PowerPC G4
512MB DDR333 SDRAM
ATI Radeon 9200 with 32MB DDR video memory
80GB Ultra ATA hard drive
Combo drive
DVI or VGA video output
 

SteveMeister

Hang out with Steve.
Willco said:
Eh, that's a little much. I was hoping we could get that Mac Mall deal where it'd be like ~$530 w/ 512MB RAM.

What software is include, btw?

Clicky

A little surprising that it doesn't come with iWork.

Oh, and get it with the base RAM -- the Mac mini uses a single PC2700 333MHz DDR SDRAM DIMM. You can get a 1GB Kingston DIMM for around $160. Apple charges 3 times that amount.
 

fart

Savant
actually feder with the 70$ off 500 deal at amazon right now you could buy that today for that price, more or less.
 

xsarien

daedsiluap
Willco said:
Eh, that's a little much. I was hoping we could get that Mac Mall deal where it'd be like ~$530 w/ 512MB RAM.

What software is include, btw?

iLife ‘05 (includes iTunes, iPhoto, iMovie, iDVD and GarageBand), AppleWorks, Quicken 2005 for Mac, Nanosaur 2, Marble Blast Gold and Apple Hardware Test.

It's not much. But as far as jumping from PC to Mac goes, it will be cheaper. iWork is basically Apple's answer to Powerpoint and Word, and it's going to be $75. Compare that to a new Mac license for office, which runs about $400.

SteveMeister said:
Clicky

A little surprising that it doesn't come with iWork.

Oh, and get it with the base RAM -- the Mac mini uses a single PC2700 333MHz DDR SDRAM DIMM. You can get a 1GB Kingston DIMM for around $160. Apple charges 3 times that amount.

Yes, but the trick is getting inside the Mini to install it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom