The colors of this photo will appear different to everyone. I think?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Don't worry guys: I've asked all 5 Connecticut congressmen/women, 2 senator, and governor (and former governor) what they think over twitter. We'll get to the bottom of this eventually.
 
And you changed your standpoint on it because...?

It's a blue/black dress. We can all agree on that, but seeing merely gold/white or black/blue is silly. It's a mix of both and you can waver on either depending on how you wish to perceive it.

When people are saying it is changing, they mean it. I changed my stance when I saw it change.

White Gold, to Blue Gold, complained so much about it looking black.

I did the whole RGB value stuff, but after about an hour or two I saw a deep blue and black. Then I could switch :D

I know that when people say black, they mean it.

That's why I am so fascinated. This isn't an illusion where out minds are hiding the truth, this is like the girl spinning left or right, we see one or the other.

Almost all who went detective in RGB values started seeing blue and gold according to this thread. Mostly those who originally saw white and gold.
 
Ok I just watched a news report about this and each time they put the picture up the color scheme would switch back and forth.

This is legit creepy. Please stop.
 
So the people who see blue/black, does it look the same as the photo showing the deep blue/black? The pic of the person wearing it.
 
When people are saying it is changing, they mean it. I changed my stance when I saw it change.

White Gold, to Blue Gold, complained so much about it looking black.

I did the whole RGB value stuff, but after about an hour or two I saw a deep blue and black. Then I could switch :D

I know that when people say black, they mean it.

That's why I am so fascinated. This isn't an illusion where out minds are hiding the truth, this is like the girl spinning left or right, we see one or the other.

Almost all who went detective in RGB values started seeing blue and gold according to this thread. Mostly those who originally saw white and gold.

I think it's because the longer you stare at it (if you are staunchly white/gold) the more you start looking for imperfection and start being able to pick out the blue from the white and then as the white gets bluer the black becomes more and more apparent. Your eyes just get used to the color.

I still easily see why people can see it as white/gold and the black itself is *definitely* reflecting as a gold (a very muddy gold but still that tinted gold back of the yellow reflecting off of black).

I can freely switch my perception between either but it still takes my eyes a second or two to adjust. It depends on what I focus my eyes on though.
 
So the people who see blue/black, does it look the same as the photo showing the deep blue/black? The pic of the person wearing it.

Definitely not. You see the color distortion, recognize it's a lighting issue, and then interpret what the dress is in reality.

That's why I mentioned earlier people should clarify when they make an assessment: Are you interpreting the actual pixel value of the photo or making a claim of the real color of the dress in person?
 
hahaha this I can use my imagination and it works, in my mind is the gold/white dress being illuminated with black light

This post reminded me of an episode of Friends.

zrUc1D4.jpg


Look at Ross's blue teeth!
 
It's red and yellow and orange and red and yellow and orange and red and yellow and orange and red and yellow and orange and satan and red and yellow and orange.
 
Definitely not. You see the color distortion, recognize it's a lighting issue, and then interpret what the dress is in reality.

That's why I mentioned earlier people should clarify when they make an assessment: Are you interpreting the actual pixel value of the photo or making a claim of the real color of the dress in person?

This is why I say it's a semantic argument and not actual perception.
 
So many people are over looking the obvious in the question? Whats the colour of the DRESS not the colours in the picture. The dress is clearly White and Gold.

The white only looks blue/greyish because of the lighting. If you hold a white piece of paper and hold it in the sunlight. Look at the side where the sunlight is hitting the page and it is clearly white. If you look on the other side where it is in the shade it is blueish/greyish but that still doesn't change the fact that it is a white piece of paper.
 
So the people who see blue/black, does it look the same as the photo showing the deep blue/black? The pic of the person wearing it.

not me although I still see it as blueish white/gold, but can force it to look black and blue if I begin to see it from the bottom, but its nothing close to the actual blue black photo of the dress, what I see is a VERY washed out photo of a blue/black dress, but its just my mind overcompensating for the bad white balance/overexposed and trying to recreate a blue/black dress
 
The original image was overexposed and was white and gold.

Now that it has been colour corrected (and proven through the website) it is blue and black.

Unless your monitor is fucked up these are the facts.
 
Okay so here's the original:


Modified brightness -20 with +20 blue in highlights only to counteract the yellow:


Further modified version with brightness -40 and +40 blue in highlights only to counteract the yellow:





I left preserve luminance on for both modified images. But you can see more natural blacks and natural whites, especially in the cloth next to the dress.
 
So the people who see blue/black, does it look the same as the photo showing the deep blue/black? The pic of the person wearing it.

Have you ever heard of lighting? We know the yellow light is reflecting off the shiny black material, giving it a gold tinge. And that the over exposure is making the blue appear a few shades lighter.

But we are superior human beings and we recognize a blue and black dress when we see one. :P
 
So many people are over looking the obvious in the question? Whats the colour of the DRESS not the colours in the picture. The dress is clearly White and Gold.

The white only looks blue/greyish because of the lighting. If you hold a white piece of paper and hold it in the sunlight. Look at the side where the sunlight is hitting the page and it is clearly white. If you look on the other side where it is in the shade it is blueish/greyish but that still doesn't change the fact that it is a white piece of paper.

What's interesting is that you're wrong. Factually it is a black and blue dress.

But this photo is overexposed... the content of a black and blue dress is not in there.

And from my view, any viewing of the dress in that photo appears white and gold, and I cannot see how others see it differently.
 
OK it has finally clicked over for me. I can see how people are saying Blue/Black now.

Whoa....

Edit: Its kinda crazy, I can see a definite blue, although its pale. Before it was definitely showing as a white with what looked like a very slight blue tint, like an off white balance. The black was absolutely gold.

Well, I am glad it finally changed for me, its pretty cool.
 
This has gone viral to a degree I don't think I've seen on the Internet up until now. As in, truly mainstream, TV, radio, FaceBook, Twitter, etc. Well, at least in Australia. It's everywhere.

It's started to turn meta already, which in interesting. I probably saw 25 status about it today alone on FB.
 
Whoah, what the fuck? It was white and gold to me, then I scrolled down and saw the mod added photo, then scrolled back up and it was like the first picture had been dyed blue. What???
 
So many people are over looking the obvious in the question? Whats the colour of the DRESS not the colours in the picture. The dress is clearly White and Gold.

The white only looks blue/greyish because of the lighting. If you hold a white piece of paper and hold it in the sunlight. Look at the side where the sunlight is hitting the page and it is clearly white. If you look on the other side where it is in the shade it is blueish/greyish but that still doesn't change the fact that it is a white piece of paper.

Haha, and just when it seems like everyone has accepted that the actual dress is blue and black. We get a post like this.

I love it.
 
Just got home, the gold got much darker, for a moment appearing almost black and the very light creamy blue is much darker (but still not as dark as the actual dress). My room is dramatically darker than my job.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom