The problem with reviews is that they play with controllers. And for controller users, F1 2012 is by far the best game made by Codemasters because you can actually drive the car with some precision unlike previous games.
Unfortunately, the game is borderline unplayable to the large majority of people that use wheels. I'm not convinced that they didn't do it on prupose after the constant whining from controller users about people with wheels being faster than them online...
Yep, I play with a controller and 2012 was the first one of these games that I'd call playable. I didn't actually buy it though, that's why I'm looking forward to this year's game. Hopefully they can find a way of pleasing both controller and wheel users this time.