• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The GTAIV Comparison Head-to-Head Thread Episode V: An Epic Tale of ManBoobs and Woe

Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Draft

Member
Atrocious pop in basically confirmed by all media sources.

Optional hard drive strikes again.

I didn't think it would end up being a big deal way back when, but that is clearly not the case.

What a disappointment.
 
Sushen

Sushen

Member
I haven't made my mind 100 percent, yet, still. And, it's the first time that I'm even giving a serious chance to ps3 version when it comes to multiplatform games. However, the fact that I have 4 times more friends with 360 than ps3, and the multiplayer feature seem overuling my other concerns on 360 version...damn HDD-less 360 and lousy dvd-rom. Tough choice...for me.
 
B

BenjaminBirdie

Banned
Draft said:
Atrocious pop in basically confirmed by all media sources.

Optional hard drive strikes again.

I didn't think it would end up being a big deal way back when, but that is clearly not the case.

What a disappointment.
Click to expand...

Atrocious? What exactly are you basing this on?
 
M

MoeB

Member
Sushen said:
I haven't made my mind 100 percent, yet, still. And, it's the first time that I'm even giving a serious chance to ps3 version when it comes to multiplatform games. However, the fact that I have 4 times more friends with 360 than ps3, and the multiplayer feature seem overuling my other concerns on 360 version...damn HDD-less 360 and lousy dvd-rom. Tough choice...for me.
Click to expand...
Those friends with 360s are not real friends. You know it's true.
 
B

bigmakstudios

Banned
BenjaminBirdie said:
No almost about it. Zero Pop-In For PS3!!
Click to expand...

Yeah, isn't this great? PS3 owners don't get pop-in but 360 owners get hardly noticeable, undistracting pop-in! Buy a PS3 and Uncharted today!

un-t.jpg


Uncharted5.jpg


uncharted_drake_fortune_sc1.jpg
 
A

AgentOtaku

Member
when your shooting, do you have to press R2 fairly in for it to register? ....or is it something like Turok, Army of Two, or The Darkness, where the slightest touch of R2 will register a shot?

Thanks again
 
B

BenjaminBirdie

Banned
Sushen said:
I haven't made my mind 100 percent, yet, still. And, it's the first time that I'm even giving a serious chance to ps3 version when it comes to multiplatform games. However, the fact that I have 4 times more friends with 360 than ps3, and the multiplayer feature seem overuling my other concerns on 360 version...damn HDD-less 360 and lousy dvd-rom. Tough choice...for me.
Click to expand...

DVD-Rom has no effect on this game as you play it, only on its development.

Unless you burned the DVD-Rom yourself. Then you're in for some chop.
 
D

DuckRacer

Member
For whatever reason Kotaku changed their wording around...
Pop-In & Loading
With a huge, seamless streaming world, data must be constantly read from the disc. The PS3 version, with its required HDD install, loads missions a couple seconds faster and decreases pop-in. The Xbox 360 version can suffer from some very noticeable texture loading, as things like trees, vehicles and building signs will regularly pop-in as one tools about town. It can be distracting, especially during high speed chases, and the PS3 version isn't entirely immune from it, but it's not a game killing problem.
Click to expand...
:|
 
PuppetMaster

PuppetMaster

Member
The DLC better be frikin amazing if 360 owners are going to have to put up with texture and models popping in throughout the game. Or else there are going to be some very pissed off fans.
 
L

Loudninja

Member
AgentOtaku said:
when your shooting, do you have to press R2 fairly in for it to register? ....or is it something like Turok, Army of Two, or The Darkness, where the slightest touch of R2 will register a shot?

Thanks again
Click to expand...

You can use RI and L1 you know?
 
J

J-Rzez

Member
Crushed said:
Is this game like a freaking Rorschach test or something? Nobody can fucking agree on the differences.
Click to expand...

From the one's I've read, it's seems generally in line that there's less pop in on the PS3 version and less loading times. Other sites said the PS3 version looked smoother too, Kotaku is the first to say the 360 has better AA. Some said the PS3 version is sharper. Others said the 360 version is more colorful.

I guess it's just nitpicking at the further end of the spectrum that the media is trying to push a winner. Usually it's a 360 port that they champion. Bit this time it seems the PS3 version is going to get the nod. Unless they pull the DLC to try and put the 360 version ahead.

Duck said:
For whatever reason Kotaku changed their wording around...

:|
Click to expand...

:lol

What, you expected Kotaku to glow about the PS3 and it's version? Apparently they found a way to not give the edge to the PS3.
 
T

Treo360

Member
Lion Heart said:
Come on guys. All of you who come in here saying "i just played it on 360, its great so stfu"...you havent played it on the PS3 so relatively speaking, you still dont know what the differences are. (and vice versa)
Click to expand...


But it does well to quite those who have not played it on any version. People like to hammer on the minutia and fail to see everything else. Does pop-in happen? Yes. Does it distract from the game? No, not at all, but this being GAF we don't actually play games now do we? No. We have threads like these from people who have agendas/biases no matter how big or small.

The problems lies with the fact that there a differences in what certain sites are saying, and that none can really agree on anything, coupled with the fanboys here who don't have both systems we get shit like this. I mean you were never going to get it for the 360/PS3 so then why are you proclaiming one is better than the other? In the end it never really mattered.


/rant


Enjoy the game, it's fun.

Now if you'll excuse me I have to start a thread about Gaming and Married life: How GTA:IV is ruining it edition:lol

PuppetMaster said:
The DLC better be frikin amazing if 360 owners are going to have to put up with texture and models popping in throughout the game. Or else there are going to be some very pissed off fans.
Click to expand...

Good thing there isn't anything major to suffer from, but believe what you will.
 
B

BenjaminBirdie

Banned
Draft said:
Actual game effecting pop in. Slamming head first into invisible "bollards."

Wretched.
Click to expand...

If you're talking about the Zapruder GIF, it was a pirated and poorly burned copy. It will not exist on a retail copy. The only pop in is tree leaves, billboards, cars in the distance. Crackdown, basically.

Now, you can feel free to sit there and tell me that Crackdown was rendered unplayable because of this, but know that it will render your argument pretty undefendable, as most everyone played the living shit out of it, regardless.
 
D

Draft

Member
nofi said:
Well, there's NONE of that on PS3.
Click to expand...
Listen man, put aside your super scope six for a moment and step back from the system war. This is not about that.

This is about a damn detachable hdd forcing me to play an inferior version of GTA4. This is about me. And for what? The Arcade? The Arcade SKU? How I hate it. How I hate its demographic.

I'm going to go find someone buying an Arcade and push them down a flight of stairs.
 
MMaRsu

MMaRsu

Member
Draft said:
Actual game effecting pop in. Slamming head first into invisible "bollards."

Wretched.
Click to expand...

I've read nor seen anything like this on the 360 version.

Man some people in this thread are crazy I'm staying the fuck outta here
 
N

nofi

Member
Draft said:
Listen man, put aside your super scope six for a moment and step back from the system war. This is not about that.

This is about a damn detachable hdd forcing me to play an inferior version of GTA4. This is about me. And for what? The Arcade? The Arcade SKU? How I hate it. How I hate its demographic.

I'm going to go find someone buying an Arcade and push them down a flight of stairs.
Click to expand...

Hey, you said there was game breaking pop-in. You didn't specify which damned console.

Forget it, I'm off to play some more GTA IV. I tried to help...
 
Z

Zombie James

Banned
Luckyman said:
The framerate seems dissapointing. Not anywhere 30fps smooth. More like sub 20 when driving.
Click to expand...

Again, live streams say otherwise. The framerate looked great, especially compared to the PS2 GTAs.
 
MMaRsu

MMaRsu

Member
Luckyman said:
The framerate seems dissapointing. Not anywhere 30fps smooth. More like sub 20 when driving.
Click to expand...

You have the game then?

GT.com footage or any other footage I have seen disconfirms this.

So.......shut it
 
J

JB1981

Member
I'd prefer pop-in to a iffy framerate.

All the vids I've seen of the 360 version have been very smooth. For those who have had some time with it, how is the framerate exactly?
 
L

Lion Heart

Banned
Just to clarify..there is pop in on ps3.

When does Gayspot do theirs? Im sure they will favour the 360, or atleast deem them equal.
 
N

nofi

Member
MMaRsu said:
You have the game then?

GT.com footage or any other footage I have seen disconfirms this.

So.......shut it
Click to expand...

It's not perfectly smooth by any stretch (again, PS3 version) and drops from 30 to (I guess) mid 20s. It's fine, though.
 
J

JB1981

Member
nofi said:
It's not perfectly smooth by any stretch (again, PS3 version) and drops from 30 to (I guess) mid 20s. It's fine, though.
Click to expand...
how is it on ps3 overall? are you satisfied with how it looks, runs?
 
Y

Ynos Yrros

Banned
Kotaku at it again. Changing their own articles, having opposite position from every reliable source, just to play to their agenda.
 
N

nofi

Member
JB1981 said:
how is it on ps3 overall? are you satisfied with how it looks, runs?
Click to expand...

I fucking love it.

I've played it pretty much non-stop since yesterday lunch. It's the best game I've played for years. Runs fine, looks gorgeous.

It's just not perfect, that's all.
 
S

Sandman7

Member
speculawyer said:
Have we had any bans in this thread yet?
Click to expand...

Disappointingly, no. But I am optimistic - the night is still young and the game still has to come out.

The irony of me posting here is that I have close to no interest in the game. I feel like the kid in the playground that goads two people into fighting just to see the violence.
 
cyberheater

cyberheater

PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 Xbone PS4 PS4
Ynos Yrros said:
Kotaku at it again. Changing their own articles, having opposite position from every reliable source, just to play to their agenda.
Click to expand...

It was obvious that it was a typo by the syntax of the original sentence.

The original went like this:-

"...and the PS3 version is entirely immune from it, but it's not a game killing problem."
Obvious really unless your fanboy googles are too tight.

Glad to see that pop-in isn't a huge problem on both console versions.
 
J

J-Rzez

Member
Draft said:
Actual game effecting pop in. Slamming head first into invisible "bollards."

Wretched.
Click to expand...

I'm sure it's not that bad. But it may affect others playing more that people think. Some people may really pay attention to detail that much and it'll drive them crazy. Just like how some people get sick from motion blur and stuff I guess.

Time to start saving for a PS3 Draft, in case this trend starts happening more often, which it very much could considering how the PS3 is picking up world-wide.

Yeah, isn't this great? PS3 owners don't get pop-in but 360 owners get hardly noticeable, undistracting pop-in! Buy a PS3 and Uncharted today!
Click to expand...

Pictures, seeing, hearing, and playing that game is bliss. Still my game of the year 07, and the benchmark for many aspects in games to me.
 
T

Treo360

Member
JB1981 said:
I'd prefer pop-in to a iffy framerate.

All the vids I've seen of the 360 version have been very smooth. For those who have had some time with it, how is the framerate exactly?
Click to expand...


Smooth like the shit they say you exude :p

Is there some hitching? Yes, but it's so rare that you really do have to look for it, but don't let that stop you from enjoying the game. If you weren't so far south of me in Jersey (Brick area right? I'm in Bayonne) I would have shown you myself.
 
D

danwarb

Member
Ynos Yrros said:
Kotaku at it again. Changing their own articles, having opposite position from every reliable source, just to play to their agenda.
Click to expand...
You think the PS3 version is "entirely immune" from pop in?
 
f@luS

f@luS

More than a member.
JB1981 said:
I'd prefer pop-in to a iffy framerate.

All the vids I've seen of the 360 version have been very smooth. For those who have had some time with it, how is the framerate exactly?
Click to expand...

the GT review shows many framerates issues (but quite small) and once , some tearing...but it may be the video and not the game
BUt the textures....so much morphin' thats weird
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

LTTP: Battlefield 4 (PS3) 2013
LTTP
35
1K
Kupfer replied
GTA 3 (Dreamcast "Super Early Version" vs PlayStation 2) - Gameplay Comparison
Retro Trailer Indie 2 3
111
11K
saintjules replied
GTA 6: Ray-Tracing Will Be A Huge Focus For Rockstar
News
43
5K
hlm666 replied
Video Game Esoterica: The Death of Ridge Racer in Arcades! Rave Racer
Retro Trailer
10
678
Holammer replied
RTTP: Silent Hill 2/3. (maybe they haven't aged that well? Don't kill me)
2
57
2K
AeonGaidenRaiden replied
Top Bottom