Tathanen
Get Inside Her!
So FSA as LTTP prequel is attractive to you because OOT is too inconsistent with what LTTP says happens, yes? Well let's look at some of the inconsistencies FSA would introduce.
- LTTP specifically states that Ganondorf invaded the sacred realm in search of the Triforce. In FSA his ambition is instead the Trident.
- LTTP's Dark World is a polluted and distorted version of the Sacred Realm, thusly polluted because of Ganon's evil presence after he was sealed in it. The FSA Dark World is called the "Dark World" before Ganondorf has any interaction with it whatsoever, and isn't really distorted in any capacity. It shares no similarities with the LTTP Dark World, NOR with the Sacred Realm.
- LTTP's sages sealed the Sacred Realm, not the Four Sword. The Four Sword being the sealing device, then placed in the already-existing "Dark World" is wholly inconsistent with the pollution of the Sacred Realm, and the cleansing at the end of LTTP.
These are MUCH bigger than OOT's inconsistencies, particularly if you go by the JP script. If their goal was to make a more convincing backstory, they sure as hell didn't accomplish it in any way, shape, or form. If we're talking about "obvious allusions to ALttP," OOT fits the bill much better. FSA just uses its assets and tries to tell a new story with them, for what I believe is just homage purposes. "We need to make a multiplayer Zelda game sorta quick, let's use LTTP assets, people will think it's fun." The actual PLOT sure doesn't work with LTTP in any way, shape, or form.
First, come on, I don't think these things need to be spoilered.
Anyway, if you think the connection was being set as early as LTTP GBA, you'd think they would have changed any of those bullets I noted at the start of this point, wouldn't you? LTTP's Ganon/SacredRealm/DarkWorld backstory is VERY heavily weaved into it, and FSA doesn't work with it at all.
Well if we assume "not a meaningless easter egg," for all we know, the timeline split made the moon not crash. Or maybe the crash just takes out clock town, and not the mountain with the swordsmiths on it. Or maybe they made swords for the Gerudo people for a long time, and many of their wares were circulating the culture, and made their way into Ganondorf's hands. Come on, there are a TON of explanations here that aren't "cross-timeline travel."
Okay now that one's better, sure. But I attribute it to the Tingle Tuner staff not really thinking about it very hard. I mean come on, your assumption is pretty out of this world. What would cross-timeline travel even mean? How, and for what purpose? To enable the stupid Tingle Tuner backstory? That is a HUGE thing to imply from such a throw-away little thing, and that is more than enough for me to go with "they made a mistake" as an explanation.
- LTTP specifically states that Ganondorf invaded the sacred realm in search of the Triforce. In FSA his ambition is instead the Trident.
- LTTP's Dark World is a polluted and distorted version of the Sacred Realm, thusly polluted because of Ganon's evil presence after he was sealed in it. The FSA Dark World is called the "Dark World" before Ganondorf has any interaction with it whatsoever, and isn't really distorted in any capacity. It shares no similarities with the LTTP Dark World, NOR with the Sacred Realm.
- LTTP's sages sealed the Sacred Realm, not the Four Sword. The Four Sword being the sealing device, then placed in the already-existing "Dark World" is wholly inconsistent with the pollution of the Sacred Realm, and the cleansing at the end of LTTP.
These are MUCH bigger than OOT's inconsistencies, particularly if you go by the JP script. If their goal was to make a more convincing backstory, they sure as hell didn't accomplish it in any way, shape, or form. If we're talking about "obvious allusions to ALttP," OOT fits the bill much better. FSA just uses its assets and tries to tell a new story with them, for what I believe is just homage purposes. "We need to make a multiplayer Zelda game sorta quick, let's use LTTP assets, people will think it's fun." The actual PLOT sure doesn't work with LTTP in any way, shape, or form.
viciouskillersquirrel said:then in GBA ALttP found the shards of the same sword in the Dark World
First, come on, I don't think these things need to be spoilered.
Anyway, if you think the connection was being set as early as LTTP GBA, you'd think they would have changed any of those bullets I noted at the start of this point, wouldn't you? LTTP's Ganon/SacredRealm/DarkWorld backstory is VERY heavily weaved into it, and FSA doesn't work with it at all.
viciouskillersquirrel said:If Termina were subject to a timeline split (which I doubt), then Zubora and Gabora couldn't make swords in the adult timeline anyway, because Link only ever stopped the moon from crashing in the child timeline. It's cross-timeline travel or bust, buster.
Well if we assume "not a meaningless easter egg," for all we know, the timeline split made the moon not crash. Or maybe the crash just takes out clock town, and not the mountain with the swordsmiths on it. Or maybe they made swords for the Gerudo people for a long time, and many of their wares were circulating the culture, and made their way into Ganondorf's hands. Come on, there are a TON of explanations here that aren't "cross-timeline travel."
Also, way to just totally ignore the Legend of the Fairy.
Okay now that one's better, sure. But I attribute it to the Tingle Tuner staff not really thinking about it very hard. I mean come on, your assumption is pretty out of this world. What would cross-timeline travel even mean? How, and for what purpose? To enable the stupid Tingle Tuner backstory? That is a HUGE thing to imply from such a throw-away little thing, and that is more than enough for me to go with "they made a mistake" as an explanation.