Hey guys, recently got an urge to get a good board game after playing Settlers of Catan. While interesting, it felt rather simplistic ultimately, but I really, REALLY enjoyed the negotiation mechanics. I really love the games where you can set up those kinds of dynamic deals and trades (well, we did go off the record and make up our own trades, like saying "I'll let you move the robber for me if you give me this", etc.)
Generally I want a game that is:
-strategic, more so than luck
-Sociable/negotiation heavy
-I guess management? I like managing lots of things, thinking ahead, etc.
-Decent length, like 2 hours or so
Actually, I'd like a casual (but strategic) board game, and a more hardcore board game.
As good as Catan is, I feel like it was very simple, but I really liked what I read about the Cities and Knights expansion pack, so that could be the more casual game I choose.
As far as a more hardcore game, I like the idea of farming, collecting resources, etc., strategy, management, negotiation, and have found some great sounding games:
Shogun
(Age of) Steam
Dominant Species
Puerto Rico
A Game of Thrones
Agricola
Edit: Going to add two more:
Stone Age
Tigris and Euphrates
Are any of these very negotiation-heavy like Monopoly/Catan where you can make your own spontaneous deals/partnerships of that sort? I can't recall, but I read about one game where you make lots of bribes and stuff, maybe it was Puerto Rico, but then I also hear that Puerto Rico is a pretty quiet game.
I am so far leaning towards Agricola, though Shogun and Dominant Species sound like Runner ups.
How is Dominant Species in terms of negotiation? And is Puerto Rico really quiet? Any opinions on Shogun?
RISK is also another negotiation-heavy game, but Risk is also very luck based and sometimes way too long and tedious (also, I own it).
And please, no Ticket to Ride.
Also, sorry if this is a noob question, but do you need the base game to play SoC expansion packs, and can you play SoC's 5-6 player Cities and Knights expansion pack the original way (4 player Cities and Knights)?
Thank you