secondapps is great, I've been using it daily since 2008. Its just not what I want from a fullsized browser. I wouldn't use the secondapps site on my laptop so why would I use it on a screen that displays even more information than that one does? Its a ridiculous notion.
And lets not act like secondapps is 100% equal to the desktop site either. Its a fabulous creation and ckohler is a genius. But quoting and editing and all that stuff is cumbersome in comparison to the full site. The full site is just that, THE FULL SITE. The mobile site is tailored for smaller screens. Which this one is not.
Think my opinion is wrong and bring up misremembered events from the past all you want, but all it does is make you look like a tremendous asshole when I have a perfectly valid complaint.
I just bought a new product to browse the web on and it does something I consider to be very annoying on what is by far my most visited website. How could I be anything other than frustrated?
It's a forum. The mobile site lets you browse and read threads easily. Also it let's you show spoilers which isn't possible in mobile safari, and has things like highlighting posts you've made, which would otherwise need scripts (which mobile safari doesn't support).
While 'proper' browsing is a nice intent, you could argue that on any touchscreen device, the secondapps version *is* the proper and more fully featured version.
I'd agree with you on news sites etc though, where mobile sites are often very basic and cut down.