Support NeoGAF

[Men_in_Boxes]

As a weary traveler seeking out quality modern day Star Trek, I've crash landed on a class M planet known as The Orville.

Is it hospitable to those of us allergic to NuTrek? Not likely, but possibly.

I've watched the 5 best episodes (according to IMDb) between S1 and S2 in preparation for S3. Here are my findings:

- Humor scrapes hard. 9/10 jokes don't land at all, which is surprising considering Seth McFarlands history. Bortus (a more comedic Warf) does land a lot of his jokes.

+ Great camera work. They do this crazy thing of keeping the camera still while actors deliver lines.

- At times, it feels a little too family oriented. Almost a G rated tone.

+ The interpersonal relationship drama (dating, marriage) is pretty in your face. I suspect this tests well with the 10 - 14 year old demographic.

- There's almost 0 Norm Macdonald from what I've seen.

+ All 5 episodes do transcend to some rewarding high moments. There's a warm, optimistic, feel good vibe I can get behind.

- Does get a little too preachy imo.

Season 3 starts tomorrow. Show apparently has a bigger budget now thanks to Hulu and episodes no longer have to be 43 minutes long. As we all know, season 3s can be pretty special for Star Treks.

 

[jshackles]

I love the Orville. Been waiting for season 3 for years. Can't wait.

 

[AJUMP23]

I will miss the Slime ball that was Norm's character.

It has good characters and is fun.

 

[Javthusiast]

Currently watching season 1. Love it already.

 

[NecrosaroIII]

As a weary traveler seeking out quality modern day Star Trek, I've crash landed on a class M planet known as The Orville.

Is it hospitable to those of us allergic to NuTrek? Not likely, but possibly.

I've watched the 5 best episodes (according to IMDb) between S1 and S2 in preparation for S3. Here are my findings:

- Humor scrapes hard. 9/10 jokes don't land at all, which is surprising considering Seth McFarlands history. Bortus (a more comedic Warf) does land a lot of his jokes.

+ Great camera work. They do this crazy thing of keeping the camera still while actors deliver lines.

- At times, it feels a little too family oriented. Almost a G rated tone.

+ The interpersonal relationship drama (dating, marriage) is pretty in your face. I suspect this tests well with the 10 - 14 year old demographic.

- There's almost 0 Norm Macdonald from what I've seen.

+ All 5 episodes do transcend to some rewarding high moments. There's a warm, optimistic, feel good vibe I can get behind.

- Does get a little too preachy imo.

Season 3 starts tomorrow. Show apparently has a bigger budget now thanks to Hulu and episodes no longer have to be 43 minutes long. As we all know, season 3s can be pretty special for Star Treks.

My wife and I enjoy it. Agree with the comment on the humor. The plots have all been excellent. Definitely made byba team that understood what worked about star trek

 

[Wildebeest]

Dr Finn is the closest to a TOS character you can get. Everything else in the show is a gateway drug to the doctor.

 

[BadBurger]

Fantastic show, it was Star Trek in the absence of Star Trek.

Watching now, its opening with one of the doctor's sons. I forgot it has been so long between seasons - this kid is damn near grown now, the last I saw him he was half this size lol (pretty sure it's the same kid anyway).

 

[Men_in_Boxes]

The Orville just had its Uncharted 2 moment. The production values jump for s3 is massive.

Episode was pretty awful imo, but I'm genuinely excited for the rest of the season.

 

[TaylorSwiftFan]

We loved it as well. I liked the head of security in the early seasons.

 

[mcjmetroid]

I enjoyed the latest episode. Maybe a little bit long and an interesting choice to start with a somber episode.

 

[jason10mm]

We loved it as well. I liked the head of security in the early seasons.

Is Seth still banging that chick or have they broken up and now she can come back?

 

[Jaybe]

Ever watch Avenue 5? I thought that was great. I like season 1 of Orville but not as smartly written as Avenue 5. That “House” actor was superb for it.

 

[akimbo009]

Love and love it's speeches. Give it to me!!

Rip Norm.

 

[01011001]

it's crazy that it has been almost 4 years between season 2 and 3. I really missed the show

the first episode was meh, but I guess they had to adress the elephant in the room before going forward

 

[BigDeadFreak]

Ah, so many childhood memories. It'll be good to see them back on our screens.

 

[Dr.D00p]

The ship still looks an utterly shit design.

 

[HoodWinked]

Is Seth still banging that chick or have they broken up and now she can come back?

hmm he's dating the new character. Seth using Orville as a vehicle for him to get paid and get pussy, what a legend.

 

[nush]

Damn, they are really gunning for that lost Star Trek audience here. I've got a feeling based on this one episode and having seen the two previous series that this could be a decent jumping in point if you want a good bootleg Star Trek show.

 

[JordoftheDead]

Been meaning to watch it. I like Seth as an idea but less so when he actually stars in things but will give it a go.

 

[Catphish]

Watched S1:E1 last night. Thought it was pretty good.

Will continue

 

[Kenpachii]

Pretty good episode

 

[ahtlas7]

So it’s not full of McFarland raunch?

 

[mcjmetroid]

Honestly if you haven't seen it yet and you like star trek. Forgot strange new world or any of that nonsense and give this a watch instead.

First series is more of a comedy series but series 2 is much more series and that's the direction the series will be taken going forward.

It's 100% the best star trek like series since Deep space nine in my opinion.

Don't be afraid because it's something you're not familiar with.

 

[jason10mm]

I'm curious what horrible sexual relationship they will put the doctor lady in this time. I think Seth just likes messing with that actress 'cause she has, by far, the most difficult storylines of any sci-fi show ever. First

Spoiler: season1

blob sex, the most disturbing image EVER

and then

Spoiler: season 2

she is so broken she has sex with an impassionate robot

. A flying jellyfish alien can't be far behind

 

[H4ze]

Orville is pure love, giving me scrubs vibes since the first season, absolute feelgood stuff

 

[JayK47]

Decent start to "season 3". I could have really used a recap. It has been 3 years. I was lost for most of the episode.

 

[Men_in_Boxes]

My ep1 review: Bad but I'm optimistic about the shows future.

My ep2 review: Terrible but now I'm cancelling my Hulu subscription.

 

[Mossybrew]

I think I must have been ill or something when I watched the first two seasons. I couldn't get through the first S3 episode, it's just, so cheesy. Maybe I'll save this for some Sunday when I'm super hungover and don't want to move off the couch.

 

[Fbh]

First episode of the new season was Ok-ish. I agree it got a nice bump in production values but

Honestly if you haven't seen it yet and you like star trek. Forgot strange new world or any of that nonsense and give this a watch instead.

First series is more of a comedy series but series 2 is much more series and that's the direction the series will be taken going forward.

It's 100% the best star trek like series since Deep space nine in my opinion.

Don't be afraid because it's something you're not familiar with.

I kinda liked S1 the best though. The comedy was a bit hit and miss but it had more of that "exploring strange new worlds" feeling of classic Star Trek.
S2 had some good episodes but was bogged down by too much relationship drama.

 

[mcjmetroid]

Oh boy I didn't really like the 2nd episode.hmm so far this series isn't impressing me I'm afraid.

 

[HoodWinked]

terrible episode 2. it was like an episode of the power rangers.

 

[nush]

Episode 2 was great, good riff on Aliens and introducing a new enemy. This shows going for the home run this season.

"You might get the sniffles." "I am prepared.".

 

[ipukespiders]

This show is the best Trek in a long time, and season 3 is fantastic so far.

 

[Aggrotek]

terrible episode 2. it was like an episode of the power rangers.

Episode 2 was great, good riff on Aliens and introducing a new enemy. This shows going for the home run this season.

The duality of man.

 

[DeafTourette]

Ep 3 was pretty good! The mystery wasn't obvious. Good callback to season 1.

Episode 1 was a thinking man's episode... Can you move past hate? Can you truly move past trauma with a glaring reminder there every day?

 

[mcjmetroid]

Ep 3 was pretty good! The mystery wasn't obvious. Good callback to season 1.

Episode 1 was a thinking man's episode... Can you move past hate? Can you truly move past trauma with a glaring reminder there every day?

Agreed. A vast improvement. Actually one of the best!

I'm kinda starting to miss the humour though. Series 2 was the perfect balance.

 

[DeafTourette]

Agreed. A vast improvement. Actually one of the best!

I'm kinda starting to miss the humour though. Series 2 was the perfect balance.

I just realized that the being in this latest episode is their version of Q!

Edit: actually I think Star Trek Picard took a lot of inspiration from elements like the Kaylon and their hate of organic life (in season 1, at least).

 

[HoodWinked]

ya i guess it's the adage good artists copy, great artists steal.

good episode but ya its basically just Q.

 

[nush]

Building the toolbox now, Borg last week, Q this week. Hologram character next week?

 

[Fox Mulder]

I was skeptical of this show at first but I loved the first two seasons. It's more like TNG than any of the star trek garbage that has come out especially recently. You can tell he actually loved that stuff.

 

[Kenpachii]

Episode 2 really showcases they can't act for shit in serious enviroments. As nobody seems to take anything seriously. It's pretty bad.

This could have been a classic voyager episode or even tng, but felt complete lack of interest in the actors to pull anything off.

 

[nush]

Episode 4, again solid STNG like episode, start of the Alexander storyline.

 

[Kenpachii]

Episode 3 was actually good.

 

[AJUMP23]

I think EP4 just dropped and it was great. Treaties gone wild.

 

[mcjmetroid]

Episode 4 was excellent! an excellent return to form. It's getting better after the first 2 unforunate episodes.

 

[Kimahri]

Didn't like the first episode much, but from 2 and on this season is a blast. A little odd with so little humour, but damn, this show is exactly what star trek is supposed to be. So glad we have it.

 

[DeafTourette]

I must be the only person here who likes New Horizons and NuTrek

 

[jason10mm]

I must be the only person here who likes New Horizons and NuTrek

Yes you are, but like that disheveled uncle that gets a little handsy at Xmas dinner, we welcome you all the same

 

[HoodWinked]

Episode 4 was really solid, actually kind of surprising that the episode was even kind of anti abortion a weird coincidence in release timing.

 

[nush]

Wow, a social commentary episode, wasn't expecting that. This week, Don't transition your children.

"I surmise that your capacity to reason has been compromised by your cultural indoctrination"

If this show was more popular I could see this episode really rustling some jimmies.