• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

The Sims 2 - Gamespot review

Wario64

works for Gamestop (lol)
6.5
http://www.gamespot.com/ps2/strategy/thesims2/review.html

And rather than attempt to help focus the single-player play on interesting, cohesive goals, The Sims 2 for consoles seems content to try to offer the same open-ended gameplay as the PC. Unfortunately, it also keeps the unlocking scheme from the previous console versions, which actually makes these options more restrictive overall. This isn't the same game as the PC version of The Sims; this one's "adapted" for consoles with fewer and different features, such as apparently not having any child sims, only adults. And really, the only way to advance through the game is to constantly hammer away at your assigned goals. You won't be distracted by much in the way of surprising and unique AI behavior along the way, because here The Sims 2's AI just isn't that great when left to its own devices. What's left is a game that offers a fairly good presentation and improved control, but it ultimately holds the most appeal for obsessive collectors with its many unlockable objects, unlockable clothing sets, and hidden cooking recipes. Unless you fit that fairly niche description, The Sims 2 on consoles probably isn't for you.
 
shouldnt even be called sims 2


the create a sim sucks


you cant even select the face just "sliders" on size

only 1 story houses
no having babies/toddles/kids/teens/etc




very poor game and I like the sims series, this went right back for SotC instead
 
That review is for the console/psp ports. Sims 2 for the DS is probably the best of them all.

Im enjoying being a hotel manager.
 
IGN says it's...fun

http://xbox.ign.com/articles/662/662202p1.html

8.5 Presentation
Slick menus, great look, friendly interface. Great package, overall.
8.0 Graphics
The graphics engine is far smoother this time around, plus there are tons of cool new effects.
8.0 Sound
Funny voicework and cool, catchy tunes throughout.
8.5 Gameplay
Very deep, engaging gameplay that's just different enough to win new fans while keeping the old.
8.5 Lasting Appeal
Lots to unlock and many areas to explore. Plus, it can last forever if that's what you want.
8.5 OVERALL
(out of 10 / not an average)


In summary, the console edition of The Sims 2 marks a definite improvement over the Urbz: Sims in the City in terms of visual presentation, sound and gameplay. It tweaks the PC formula enough to attract the console crowd, yet keeps enough of the traditional Sims formula to warrant a look from fans of the original. It's a fun, funny and truly engrossing entry in the series.




:scratch
 
Well this just went off the list.

I was going to pick it up for my woman, but after telling here about all the SUBTRACTIONS she said go for the PC version.

No kids?
No aging?
No death? (this is the best part!)
One Story houses?

NO SALE!

No wonder it's a discount ($39, discount for EA) release
 
IGN Cube said the same thing (Cube editor reviewed it).

So who didn't play the game this time? Gamespot or IGN?
 
I bought this for Gamecube, and I'm kinda disappointed in my purchase. It isn't bad per se, just isn't all I'd hoped it would be. I didn't bother w/ Urbz, so, 2 me this is only a small improvement on Bustin' Out. In some ways it's actually a step down from that game. Having only adults is something I just don't really understand when past versions had it. I get the technical difficulties and impossibilities of pulling off all of the PCs features on a current-gen console w/ no hard-drive(excluding XBox), but some of that stuff could've been done. This game is basically a prettier version of Bustin' Out w/ "direct-control" added in and other features taken out.
 
koam said:
IGN Cube said the same thing (Cube editor reviewed it).

So who didn't play the game this time? Gamespot or IGN?


I think it is a case of Gamespot comparing the console versions to the PC version. You can't do that, they are totally difference experiences. The console versions can't compare to the depth and longevity of the PC game. I have played the PC version since the day it came out. I can't see a current gen console handling that game. So if I compared a console version to it, then yeah the console version would get hammered.
 
littlewig said:
It's the same reviewer...

Edit - Does anyone know how to find a compiled list of reviews by a single reviewer on IGN?

Juan is a Cube editor. The Cube team and the PS2 team are fairly good with their review scores. The Xbox team is a disaster.
 
Damn deku is enjoying sims 2 and u only bought it cause of the ign review.. Looks like I may have to check that one out :)

Can you get us a more detailed impression other then last nights Deku?
 
Top Bottom